Court Cases of Supreme Court Vs State Courts Essay

Court Cases of Supreme Court Vs State Courts Essay

Length: 1579 words (4.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Martin v. Hunter’s Lessee is a case heard by the Supreme Court involving a land dispute. Lord Thomas Fairfax was a British Loyalist and landowner in Virginia during the American Revolution. Virginia enacted legislation during the war that allowed for the seizure of land held by those people loyal to the British and took Lord Fairfax’s property. Virginia then granted ownership of a tract of the seized property to David Hunter. After the war ended, the United States and Great Britain agreed to a treaty in which the United States guaranteed to protect the ownership of land held by British Loyalists. When Lord Fairfax died, his nephew, Thomas Martin, inherited the Lord’s land holdings and subsequently sued Virginia to recover the property taken during the American Revolution. Martin was victorious in state court and Hunter appealed to the Virginia Court of Appeals where the lower court’s decision was reversed. Martin then appealed the case to the United States Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court found that since the treaty superseded the state’s law, Martin was the rightful owner of the land and remanded the case back to Virginia Court of Appeals to enter a decision for Martin. The Virginia Court of Appeals refused to comply with the Supreme Court’s decision and questioned the Court’s jurisdiction in cases decided by a state court.
The question before the Supreme Court in this case was whether or not the Supreme Court had appellate jurisdiction over a state court in matters involving federal law. In other words, did the Supreme Court have the power to hear appeals in cases involving federal law that were decided by a state court? The Court found that it did have such jurisdiction as granted by the Constitution. Article III,...

... middle of paper ...

...ried precedents in law. This decision confirmed the supremacy of the Supreme Court as the single deciding body for the interpretation of federal law and Constitutional issues. Ex parte McCardle is the only instance of Congress taking action to limit the appellate jurisdiction of the Supreme Court. This case affirmed the constitutionally granted power of Congress to make exceptions it deems necessary and limit the appellate jurisdiction of the Supreme Court. West Coast Hotel Company v. Parrish is important because it allows the judiciary to decide on issues that developed based on changes in society since the Constitution was written. The writers of the Constitution could not foresee how society would change over time, but recognized it would. This decision provides the judiciary the means to apply what is written in the Constitution to an ever-changing world.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Judicial Process of the Supreme Court Essay

- Nature’s Judicial Process in the Supreme Court consists of decision-making; based on the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court. Although the Supreme Court has the capability to decide all extended cases; it also has the power to ascend under the Constitution, which allows the Supreme Court its jurisdiction in the Judicial Branch of government. The Judicial Process interpret the laws that are established in the Supreme Court; thus, allowing the Court to exercise its power by shifting its system under the Constitutional laws of the United States....   [tags: American Government, Supreme Court]

Better Essays
1160 words (3.3 pages)

State Courts And Federal Courts Essay

- Nearly all rights that involve us are approved by state governments, and like so, state courts manage most arguments that control our day to day lives. Because federal courts protect several of our main laws, they are also very important in our lives. “Due to federalism, both the federal government and each of the state governments have their own court systems ("Comparing Federal & State Courts").” “State court systems vary from state to state, and each is a little different ("State Courts vs. Federal Courts", 2015)....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States, United States]

Better Essays
1457 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Most Important Supreme Court Cases Related to Education

- (1) On May 17th, 1954, the Supreme Court made a decision that would mark a defining moment in the history of the United States. This decision declared “separate but equal” unconstitutional. It was ultimately unanimous, and occurred after a long, sought out campaign to convince all nine justices to overturn the “separate but equal” doctrine that had been sanctioned in the infamous 1896 Plessy v. Ferguson case. The legal path paved in various aspects of racial discrimination in public life has been the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment....   [tags: supreme court, separate but equal]

Better Essays
975 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about The Supreme Court Act Of The State Of Iowa

- Following the decision of the Iowa Supreme Court to invoke the equal protection clause and effectively legalize gay marriage in the state of Iowa, opponents of this decision mobilized and, with the administrative and financial assistance of interest groups from within and outside the state, successfully ousted three of the justices responsible for the ruling. It marked the first time in the forty-eight year history of Iowa’s adopting judicial retention elections that any justice had been so rebuked....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States]

Better Essays
1071 words (3.1 pages)

The Significance Of Supreme Courts Jurisprudence Essay

- Section IV Q8: The Significance of Supreme Courts Jurisprudence through Judicial tests on the Right to Freedom of Speech. The Supreme Court in several cases regarding free speech challenges has produced several significant precedents over time who’s jurisprudence have both defined the limitations of an individual’s right to free speech as well as placed restrictions upon the government’s ability to regulate free speech. Political speech challenges in particular have led to multiple disputes that have resulted in a series of judicial balancing tests....   [tags: First Amendment to the United States Constitution]

Better Essays
1310 words (3.7 pages)

Tort Law Cases Essay

- Presented are four separate cases that have been argued and settled in a court of law. Each of these cases represent a different kind of tort, a tort is a civil wrong or wrongful act, which can be either intentional or accidental, from which injury occurs to another (Hill & Hill n.d.). The torts are as listed, intentional, criminal, negligence, and liability as presented in the four researched cases. State Rubbish Collectors Ass’n v. Siliznoff When a person violates another person’s legal rights deliberately it is considered an intentional tort (Mayer et al....   [tags: Tort Law Cases]

Better Essays
1554 words (4.4 pages)

The Us Supreme Courte Case Essay

- This article is about a US Supreme Courte case held in 1990 indicating that the Oregon state denied unemployment benefits to two people who got fired because they violated Oregon state prohibition on the use of peyote, even though the drug was used as part of a religious ceremony. A private drug rehabilitation organization fired two of its workers (Smith and Black), because the organization found out they had used peyote at a ceremony of their Native American Church. Smith and Black’s counselors filed a claim for unemployment compensation, while Employment Division 's argument was that Smith and Black’s dismissal was considered work-related misconduct and they violated the First Amendment f...   [tags: United States, Supreme Court of the United States]

Better Essays
860 words (2.5 pages)

The Supreme Court Essay

- The Supreme Court *Purpose of the Supreme Court* The United States Supreme Court consists of the Chief Justice of the United States and eight associate justices. The Supreme Court each year hears a limited number of the cases it is asked to decide. Those cases may begin in the federal or state courts, and they usually involve very important questions about the Constitution or federal law. Appealing the state courts decision, you can ask it to be taken to the Supreme Court. To get their higher opinion....   [tags: Supreme Court Justice Constitution Judicial]

Free Essays
1220 words (3.5 pages)

Supreme Court Cases Essay

- Supreme Court Cases First Amendment- Case Facts: Students wore anti-war bands to school, which in turn got them suspended from school. The students sued the school for impeding upon their free speech. Students Arguments: 1st and 14th Amendment-free speech, they weren't hurting anyone. School Arguments: 10th Amendment-allowed the school to suspend the kids in fear of endangering other student's health and academic well being Supreme Court Decision: The students won. "Students do not shed their 1st Amendment rights at the school gates"....   [tags: Law Legal]

Free Essays
1043 words (3 pages)

Courts Essays

- The jurisdiction of the federal courts is defined in Article III, Section 2, of the Constitution, as extending in law and equity to all cases arising under the Constitution and federal legislation; to controversies to which the U.S. shall be a party, including those arising from treaties with other governments; to admiralty and maritime cases; to controversies between states; to controversies between a state, or its citizens, and foreign governments or their subjects; and to controversies between the citizens of one state and citizens of another state....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
1052 words (3 pages)