Essay on Counterterrorism Techniques: Diplomatic Initiatives vs. Military Force

Essay on Counterterrorism Techniques: Diplomatic Initiatives vs. Military Force

Length: 1400 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

3. When it comes to counterterrorism, some critics argue that Western diplomatic and development initiatives may prove to be far more effective than using military force in countering and reducing the popularity of terrorist groups like al Qaeda in Muslim countries. Do you agree or disagree and why?
Debate over formulating appropriate responses to terrorism has raged for many years. In the case of extremist groups such as Al Qaeda and their operations in the Muslim world, many critics have argued that Western diplomatic and development initiatives may contribute more to a long-term solution than the application of military force ever could. In this essay, I will explore the landscape of counter terrorism by examining the seismic shift in tactics that is emerging amongst analysts, who are moving incrementally towards a broad recognition that diplomacy and development are more powerful tools in addressing extremist violence that military coercion has proven to be. Diplomatic and development initiatives can dramatically truncate the ability of extremist groups to recruit and inspire adherents by addressing the sources of terrorism, conversely military offensives have often served to further radicalise restive elements.

At the beginning of the ‘War on Terror’, rhetoric on counterterrorism was terrifyingly simplistic: ‘We do not negotiate with terrorists!’ Being a cornerstone of the coalition strategy. Philip Wilcox, the United States (US) State Department Coordinator for Counterterrorism during the late nineteen nineties writing for the intelligence community sums up a view broadly held at the time; that the conflict with terrorist organisations will be won when terrorism and its practitioners have been ‘renounced and marginaliz...

... middle of paper ...

...S administration in response to a recognition that low-level insurgents would be better persuaded to lay down their arms through diplomacy than by military offensives has begun to develop protocols for reengaging in diplomatic relations with Taliban and Al Qaeda sympathisers. Extremist groups have proven to be remarkably resistant to military coercion with both the Taliban and Al Qaeda growing in strength and membership during the conflict with Western forces. Diplomacy and economic development have emerged as the only tactic that can bring about a long term solution; stability and tolerance are by products of a society that can engage with its diverse elements rather than isolate them. Public support is key to extremist recruitment and by being seen to uphold their own norms and values states forge for themselves a powerful tool for the protection of p

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

India's Security Role Exercises Diplomatic leverage in Asia-Pacific Multilateral Organizations

- ... Since the US-alliance withdraw its military troops from Afghanistan by the end of 2014, there is an increasing concern that China will fill the power vacuum in Afghanistan as more than 70 percent of oils is imported from the Middle East and Africa . Thus, India views Afghanistan in the context of rivalry with China due to Afghanistan's substantial economic potentials and its buffer state status. At the same time, Nopen claims that China also sees 'Afghanistan as a pawn in its rivalry with India, completing a series of alliance with Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh' as both China and India are heavily dependent on energy supplies and resources from other states as the world's major ener...   [tags: china, diplomatic power]

Powerful Essays
1931 words (5.5 pages)

Diversity Is Not Only Reserved For High Profile Diplomatic Initiatives And Media Spot Light

- The act of dialogue is not only reserved for high profile diplomatic initiatives and media spot light, but a process owned by everyone all over the world, that have a right and need to be heard. Throughout the course, I was given scenarios that encouraged me to think critically about diversity and the privilege I have because of my various social identities. The scenarios were presented in the form of activities that allowed the class to have an open and honest discussion. I was taught the importance of respecting individual differences and discussing conflicting viewpoints to better understand ideologies outside of my own....   [tags: Gender role, Gender, Race, African American]

Powerful Essays
1881 words (5.4 pages)

President Obama’s Diplomatic Style Toward Africa: Putting the Future of Africa in the Hands of Africans

- ... is focused more on security than on humanitarian assistance, with the top recipients of aid being those countries where terrorism is a threat. But with the increase of humanitarian aid used as a tool for fighting corruption and conflict, this distinction is hard to make. Like Bill Clinton and Bono, many believe that relieving poverty through grants will increase development, turning war-torn and disease-ridden areas into peaceful and prosperous nations. Ironically, research is showing that it can have quite the opposite effect....   [tags: worldwide humanitarian initiatives]

Powerful Essays
2733 words (7.8 pages)

Analysis of Initiatives of Healthcare Reform Essay

- Over the last 5-10 years the healthcare system has begun reformation to increase safety, efficiency, cost reduction, increasing continuum of care, and increases in information technology (IT). There are many influences that are creating this need for change including laws, regulations, and the consumers of the healthcare system. The consumer is beginning to take charge of their health and become an advocate of their healthcare needs and plans of action. This transformation has created a greater need for the healthcare system to increase the use of health management information system (HMIS)....   [tags: Health Reform Initiatives]

Powerful Essays
3072 words (8.8 pages)

Military Technology's Impact on the Environment Essay example

- The evolution of military technology through the more efficient and innovative utilization of natural resources has helped shape the environment in a wide range of areas. Homo sapiens lacking strong jaws, sharp teeth, and cutting claws have employed tools to better conquer the natural environment and vie with each other for scarce resources. These scarce resources such as wood and a myriad of metals have been harnessed to advance military technology. In doing so, military technology’s impact on the environment has steadily increased through time....   [tags: Military Technology]

Powerful Essays
1420 words (4.1 pages)

A Veteran Banned From Military Housing Essay

- Doberman Pinschers and German Shepherd dogs mark 100 years with the AKC. Both German Shepherds and Dobermans were the Devil Dogs in WWII (Mahood). Both dog breeds have given years of service to the military. Both dogs have been faithful loyal companions and incredibly intelligent. Both dogs are ranked in the top five for obedience and working intelligence (“Dog intelligence rankings”). Yet, the German Shepherd is currently the military police’s working dog and its veteran companion, the Doberman Pinscher, is currently banned from living in military bases....   [tags: U.S. Military]

Powerful Essays
983 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about Military Careers

- "A young man who does not have what it takes to perform military service is not likely to have what it takes to make a living." When joining the military you must perform your best to protect our country. Tons of men and women around the world fight for the country and make a career out of it. There are three major branches and many different jobs to go with each one. Each have many specific tasks. (Robbie Hughes Interview) Military background and history has been in the world for a long time. It goes back as far as Assyrians, Spartans, Aztecs, Romans and Greek....   [tags: Military History]

Free Essays
2435 words (7 pages)

Essay about The Effectiveness of the Arab and Israeli Peace Initiatives

- The Effectiveness of the Arab and Israeli Peace Initiatives The Arab and Israeli peace initiatives that have taken place between the 1970s and 1990s have been both successful and unsuccessful; however the successful initiatives have been limited in reaching the ultimate goal of peace between the Arabs and Israelis. There have been three major peace initiatives that include the Camp David Accords, Madrid Peace Conference and the Oslo Accords. To assess the effectiveness of these peace initiatives, a look at how successful the outcomes are will be necessary to make a judgement....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1337 words (3.8 pages)

United States' Diplomatic Tactics Essay

- United States' Diplomatic Tactics The United States uses force only after all other venues toward peace had been constituted. For example In the Spanish-American war propaganda was used to turn people against the so called "Yankee's" and American manifest destiny. The sinking of the Maine was definitely a catalyst toward war it always took loss of life for American to be drawn into war. The revolutionary war of course we wanted our freedom the Civil war we wanted freedom from slavery with the Spanish American war we were yet again drawn into war....   [tags: Foreign Relations Policy Diplomacy]

Free Essays
1286 words (3.7 pages)

Military Essay

- Military Organizational Structure The Toad Military Organizational Structure Organization involves a intentional formalized structure of roles. People working together towards a common goal, but in specialized areas. The overall effectiveness of any particular association is directly proportional to the functioning of its members. As a firm increases in size the participants lose sight of the concept of teamwork. To maintain the competitive edge a corporation must remain flexible. To this end, varying styles of organizational structure have been implemented....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Powerful Essays
734 words (2.1 pages)