The Correlation Between Homeric Rhetoric And Judgment Of Character And Ethos

The Correlation Between Homeric Rhetoric And Judgment Of Character And Ethos

Length: 1814 words (5.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The correlation between Homeric rhetoric and judgment of character and ethos is not a complex concept. According to Todd Frobish, one’s character is based on one’s actions and ability. If a man is old and not as strong or capable as the young, one of his only useful actions is in the counseling of kings and the building of morale; both obviously actions and talents of language, not brawn (pg. 22-23). If a man is young, he is expected to fight with strength and bravery (pg. 23-24). There are those who hold both sets of skills, but common men, and even uncommon heroes, are not expected to be exceptional at both. However, though this system works for many, it does not always work for unfamiliar motives for actions. So, we see that the embassy misreads Achilles and Achilles character, and that Achilles shows that, much like the gods, he is destructively prideful and lustful for glory.
Odysseus is both an exceptional fighter and an exceptional speaker. He urges Achilles, after reciting the gifts Agamemnon offers, to remember his father’s advice. Odysseus recounts Peleus’ instruction that Achilles “hold in check his proud, fiery spirit” and that Achilles ought to value friendship over pride (9.306-315). The kings and captains of the Achaeans understand Achilles inaction to some extent, and they, including Odysseus, seem to think Agamemnon’s gifts a satisfactory recompense for the wrongs Achilles has suffered. However, there is also no denying that Achilles’ inaction is severely hurting the Argive ranks, which Odysseus emphasizes to the warrior. He says that the Trojan attack will be a “nightmare [. . .] and then it will be our fate to die in Troy [. . .]” (9.294, 296). Along with Odysseus’s claim to authority and his dwelling...

... middle of paper ...

...tions and words before approaching Pelides. But, because actions have many motivations behind them, actions and words are not always reliable units for measuring character. However, it is the only method available. The ambassadors did what they knew to do when met with resistance, and that was to try different types of appeals. The different logical, ethical, and emotional appeals were a good beginning, but the appeals were ineffective because they did not understand or know Achilles’ motivation. Achilles’ refutation of the ambassadors clears any confusion about his motivations, but the embassy does not change its strategy. They focus on honor, praise, and the fact that all of this was cause by a riff over a girl. But, though this is a part of Achilles’ grudge, his most significant reason for not fighting is so that he may win more glory and honor for himself.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Judgment

- As this narrative unfolds, we see a young man’s struggles to deal with a friend, family struggles and a great deal of internal conflict. Georg Bendemenn, the narrator, opens the parable describing writing a letter to a friend in Russia giving an impression that it’s going to be a simple story about their relationship. However, as the plot unravels Georg begins struggling more and more to maintain his life as it spirals beneath his feet. Georg Bendemenn is psychologically unstable because of the relationship troubles with his friend and father as well as ‘the judgment’ leading to his final decision....   [tags: Character Analysis, Georg Bendemenn]

Better Essays
1081 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on The Declaration of Independence and the American Ethos

- Imagine traveling from the oppression that seeped from the government in Great Britain during the nineteenth century to a foreign land with the hope of living a better life. This life included “Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness” (Jefferson, 247). This life would also provide a government that allows the citizens to dictate how they are governed and the people’s opinions are always appreciated. This new government would need to be implemented and a set of ethics would need to be created. This land I am talking about is now considered the United States of America and its foundation for its ethics is the Declaration of Independence....   [tags: American Ethos Essays]

Better Essays
1326 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on The Judgement Of The Judgment Seat Of Christ

- ... As stated in Romans 8:1 “no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus”. The main focus of judgement is whether or not one believed in Christ and whether they followed him. To support this Jesus says in John 5:24, “Anyone who hears my word and believes him who sent me has eternal life, and does not come under judgment, but has passed from death to life.” Jesus also seems to indicate that the more knowledge of God’s truth attained, the greater responsibility there is to be faithful. He says in Luke 12:47-48, “That slave who knew what his master wanted, but did not prepare himself or do what was wanted, will receive a severe beating....   [tags: Jesus, New Testament, Last Judgment, Heaven]

Better Essays
729 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about The Political Ethos of the Civil Society

- The Political Ethos of the Civil Society ABSTRACT: Totalitarian political systems in the socialist countries of Eastern Europe destroyed and repressed the civil society that used to exist in them. The authoritarian and totalitarian ethos was formed under a powerful influence of ideologies of the communist parties and politocracy in these countries so that the political ethos of politicians dominated the political ethos of the citizen. The breakdown of the real socialism and its unsuccessful attempts to complete accelerated liberal modernization of these societies caused turbulence of social values in addition to the general moral chaos....   [tags: Politics Ethos Papers]

Better Essays
2764 words (7.9 pages)

Michelangelo's Fresco The Last Judgment Essay

- Art, by definition, is “something that is created with imagination and skill and that is beautiful or that expresses important ideas or feelings”. Throughout history, one way that art has been used is to reflect a multitude of ideas and beliefs. Christian beliefs and ideas have been portrayed in artwork since the beginning of Christianity, although, it was not always acceptable to do so. The idea of the final judgement is a Christian idea that has been displayed in art repeatedly in a variety of ways....   [tags: sistine chapel, christian art, final judgment]

Better Essays
1231 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on The Origin of Judgment

- The Origin of Judgment Introduction The guiding thesis of Experience and Judgment is that logic demands a foundational theory of experience, which at the lowest level is described as prepredicative or prelinguistic.1 Edmund Husserl pursues within that text a phenomenological elucidation of the origin of judgment in order that he might clarify the essence of the predicative judgment. He does so in the belief that an investigation into the form of prepredicative experience will show it to be the ground of the structure of predicative thought, and thus the origin of general, conceptual thought....   [tags: Judgment Edmund Husserl Essays]

Free Essays
3502 words (10 pages)

Ethics And Ethos Effect Sport Essay

- In “Ethics and Sport: Whose Ethics, Which Ethos,” Milan Hosta provides an article that has insight on how ethics and ethos effect sport. Throughout reading this article, it seems that the author only creates more questions rather then answers. Costa does not give clear definitions and comprehendible insight to fulfill his argument. Although Milan Hosta’s article has a lot of detailed information; it has bad organization and it is comprehensively hard to understand his view. The main purpose of the article that I was able to understand is how Milan Hosta argues the degree in which ethics plays a role in sport....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Mores, Moral]

Better Essays
1126 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on The California Ethos

- ... Next, the gold-seekers didn’t concern about their safely issue for finding gold at the riverbeds, mountains or even tunnels with poor weather and bad environment conditions. For them, time was money. They kept working days and nights to achieve their dream and only concerned how much did they gain in California to improve their living standard. Second, I believe that the ethos of persistence was developed in the beginning when the gold-seekers decided to come California for a luck. The gold-seekers spent a long and tough journey from their hometown to arrive in San Francisco with nothing and separated with the families indeed....   [tags: California Gold Rush, immigration, west coast]

Better Essays
882 words (2.5 pages)

Doctrine of Ethos Essay

- The Doctrine of Ethos states that music effects character and emotion of man by way of morals or ethics. It was arranged into certain scales, each with a certain characteristic. Specific scales were said to be able to inspire rage or sadness. Some were said to inspire happiness, and one was even said to weaken the mind due to its simplicity. Greek music, of which the Doctrine of Ethos specifically talked about, wasn’t just solely instrumental. Improvising, they usually incorporated lyrics and even dance....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Free Essays
865 words (2.5 pages)

frankenstein ethos Essay

- The story begins with and is enveloped by Walton’s letters to his sister. His sister is very close to him; as can be seen by the affection terms used for her and the comfort level that Walton has with her; terms such as “dear sister” and “my sister”. This relationship that Walton has with his sister is placed on the reader through his expressions and use of language. The reader is forced into the role of a character that already has some developments. Walton’s sister is a character that exists prior to the story; this can be seen by the way Walton treats his subject....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Free Essays
479 words (1.4 pages)