The Controversy Of Sterilization Of The Disabled Essays

The Controversy Of Sterilization Of The Disabled Essays

Length: 1260 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Controversy of the Sterilization of the Intellectually Disabled
Contraceptives have been practiced in the United states since the late 1800s giving men and women their own choice of determining if or when they would conceive and create a family. This right to reproduce is one of the many free rights given to the citizens of the United States. Unfortunately, not all people that live in the United States have this opportunity. The intellectually disabled community was once sterilized without consent to control the chances that they would have offspring. The idea that the intellectually disabled would negatively affect the United States’ population, through eugenics had caused many to believe that the sterilization of the disabled is essential.
Eugenics was first proposed by a scientist by the name of Sir Waltor Galton. He believed that people that had desirable characteristics would be benefiting to society once they had offspring, with same characteristics. This created a problem for the mentally disabled, since he thought of the disable as “the root cause of the social decline in the first two decades of the twentieth century”, according to the Journal of Intellectual Disability Research (75). He assumed that they were a burden on family members and of little use to society, creating the idea that there was a need of controlling the intellectually disabled from having offspring. The eugenic scientist had sought legal action in the need for sterilization to any human that showed or developed any negative traits that they saw was unfit. These traits included intellectually disability or epilepsy. After the passing of laws that stripped the intellectually disable people of their rights, the sterilization of the intellectually...


... middle of paper ...


... them.
When living in United States, one can think of the freedom that comes with being a citizen. One of those freedoms is the right to conceive children or prevent child birth if desired. This right is one of the many right that the intellectually disabled citizens have had taken from them because of how they are viewed. People believe they are too flawed to be of any benefits to the United States. Others, have thought of them as violent, abusive and burdens on society. These stereotypical views have caused many to try and control the intellectual disabled’s lives. Though, they are disabled, they deserve the choice of parenthood as well as those not disabled. When looking at the unconsented sterilization cases its determined that the medical field needs to have better resources and other ways of educating the intellectually disabled to control unnecessary births.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Eugenics or Forced Sterilization Programs

- Heredity: Like begets like. Eugenics or force sterilization programs were government policies that attempted to force people to undergo surgical sterilization, and also aim to assimilate any genetic deficiency (Keith 2011). The pseudo-science behind eugenics was based on a misconception of heredity that assumed that the deficient inevitably passed down their pathology to their progeny, and with this misconception, heredity became related to the crude term like begets like (Grekul 2008). This term was the foundation of what shaped the Eugenics movement into a dark and horrific period (McLaren 1990)....   [tags: Sexual Sterilization Act, Canadian history]

Better Essays
1630 words (4.7 pages)

Community Living Ontario: Speaking on Behalf of the Intellectually Disabled

- Community Living Ontario is an organization that speaks on behalf of the intellectually disabled. They have established one hundred and seventeen local Community Living associations across Ontario and have over twelve thousand members across the province. Community Living encourages people to accept and include the intellectually disabled within the community. This essay will discuss how Community Living Ontario promotes individuals to be Christ-like by asking people to accept others without prejudices, to stand up for what they believe is right and to show Christ-like love and respect....   [tags: Intellectually Disabled, community,]

Better Essays
596 words (1.7 pages)

Animal Euthanasia: The Population Control Controversy Essay

- Can you recall the last time you have seen the lifeless body of an innocent dog or cat alongside of the road. Better yet, how many people can you think of, that go to a shelter to get a new pet, versus buying an animal from a breeder. My point is that there are many animals dying outside of shelters every day. However, because the adoption rates at shelters aren’t high enough to stop the overcrowding, pets undergo euthanasia. Versus the imminent probability of an animal dying an atrocious death in the wild, they are offered a peaceful and pain-free passing in shelters....   [tags: pet, animal shelters, sterilization, overcrowding]

Better Essays
1344 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about The Vaccination Controversy

- ANA CEO and nurse Myrtle Aydelotte once said, “Nursing encompasses an art, a humanistic orientation, a feeling for the value of the individual, and an intuitive sense of ethics, and of the appropriateness of action taken”.1 In preparing to develop my own nursing practice, I find this statement to be invaluable. It is this philosophy which has guided my educational and experiential journey from scientific evidence and statistics alone, to include patient relationship and ethical understanding. My first exposure to the “Vaccine Controversy” occurred in my biology undergraduate....   [tags: nursing, vaccine controversy, informed consent]

Better Essays
2233 words (6.4 pages)

Court Authorization of Sterilization of a Minor Essay

- Child Law Essay I am going to be answering the question that Wardship jurisdiction enables a court to authorise the sterilisation of a minor when it is held to be in that child’s best interest and the legal and wider implications of this being in place. According to Section 1 (1) of the Family Law Reform Act 1969 a minor is defined as “a person who has not attained the age of 18”. Children between the ages of 10 and 14 are deemed to be incapable of forming criminal intent. This presumption can, however be rebutted by proving that the child in question knew that his or her behaviour was ‘seriously wrong’ for example it was more than simply naughty....   [tags: Family Law Reform Act, Court Jurisdiction]

Better Essays
2148 words (6.1 pages)

Sterilization by Saturated Steam Essay

- Title: Sterilization by Saturated Steam Introduction: Sterilization process is done for the complete elimination of all microorganisms that could potentially be a contaminant and lead to occurrences of hazards. (Chi, 1993) Sterilization is a process defined by killing all the living microorganisms that includes bacteria and spores. This process can be done chemically, physically and by means of physiochemical methods. (Soper & Davies, 1990)There are chemicals used in these processes to ensure all microorganisms no longer exist and they are known as sterilizing agents and are called chemisterilants....   [tags: ionizing radiation, filtration, input of gas]

Better Essays
2171 words (6.2 pages)

sterilization Essays

- The only way to ensure that sterilization has occurred is to use the biological monitoring methods. This is because these are the only tests done which show whether or not actual microbial life has been killed. Biological methods are the only ones which are recommended by the CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention), the AAMI (Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation), the AMA (American Medical Association), OSHA, and OSAP (Office Safety and Asepsis Procedures Foundation) Biological monitoring is basically evaluating a sterilization process by rendering highly resistant bacterial spores biologically inert....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Better Essays
555 words (1.6 pages)

Voluntary Abortion or Compulsory Sterilization? Essay

- Voluntary Abortion or Compulsory Sterilization. Starting in the mid-1960s, some erosion of the anti-abortion laws began to take place. But these efforts have not been supported by many of the more vocal groups who are trying to do something about excess population growth; to them, compulsory birth control and compulsory sterilization are apparently more palatable than voluntary abortion. The result is legal chaos--which has been the situation with reference to abortion since it was first made illegal in this country....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]

Free Essays
1948 words (5.6 pages)

The Reproductive Rights of the Developmentally Disabled Essay examples

- The Reproductive Rights of the Developmentally Disabled Sterilization of the developmentally disabled or the mentally retarded is an issue that has long been debated in America. Mental retardation is defined as the inability to learn normally and develop mentally. Traditionally in America if a mentally retarded person was born to a family, that family had 2 choices- take care of the child at home, or it was strongly recommended that the child was sent to a state run institution or hospital....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1041 words (3 pages)

Radiation Sterilization Essay

- Nuclear and Radioactivity Physics Radiation Sterilization Medical products, such as surgical dressings, sutures, catheters and syringes must be sterilized before they can be used in medical procedures. This is frequently done using radiation. *HOW DOES THIS PROCESS WORK. Radiation sterilization involves exposure of products to gamma radiation from a cobalt-60 source for a predetermined amount of time. The step by step process is such:  Hermetically sealed medical products are packed in cardboard boxes....   [tags: Physics]

Better Essays
990 words (2.8 pages)