This essay will provide a theoretical understanding of the four ethical frameworks: Consequentialism, Non- Consequentialism, Virtue Ethics and Care Ethics. When applied to a situation these frameworks help teachers to resolve and justify their decision making. The objective is to apply the four frameworks to the scenario Helping Molly, to establish the most ethical course of action. Finally, a recommended course of action will be justification. The overarching ethical issue present within the Helping Molly scenario is the community sponsorship and the alignment with school beliefs and initiatives.
Consequentialism is an ethical perspective that primarily focuses upon the consequences resulting from an action and aims to eliminate the negative consequences. Within this framework there are three sub-categories: Egoism, Altruism and Utilitarianism.
Egoism considers the best outcome for the decision maker. From an egoist perspective the most favourable outcome for the teacher to do is minimise the stress and conflict of possible outcomes in his/her life. It is therefore in the teachers’ best interest to not upset the principle, to align a similar view to her and not accept the offer of further promotion of funding.
Altruism perspective looks at the outcomes best for everyone excluding the decision maker. From this perspective it is important that the negative outcomes are minimised for the school, its students and Molly. From this perspective, the best outcome for the students and Molly is to give them a chance to develop their musical skills. The outcome best for the school is to be able to justify the sponsorship for Molly by reaping the benefits as a whole ...
... middle of paper ...
... for the teacher is a productive learning environment where student needs are being catered for.
Burgh, G., Field, T., Freakley, M. (2006) Ethics and the Community of Inquiry: Education for the Deliberative Democracy. Thomson Social Science Press: South Melbourne.
Sammel, A. (2010). Lecture Three. Focusing on Virtue and Care Ethics. Griffith University: Gold Coast.
Smith, M.K. (2004). The ethics of care and education. The encyclopaedia of informal
education, Retrieved from www.infed.org/thinkers/noddings.html
Queensland Government Education Queensland. (1998). Health and Physical
Education. Retrieved July 14, 2010 from http://education.qld.gov.au/curriculu
United Nations. (2010). The Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Retrieved July 9, 2010, from http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/index.shtml
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- There are two main ethical issues that have been identified within this scenario. The first is that the acceptance of McJack’s sponsorship conflict with the schools recent efforts and policies to encourage healthy eating habits and lifestyles. Furthermore, if the school accepts the sponsorship offered in conjunction with the stipulated conditions it would ultimately be endorsing discrimination against Molly based on her appearance. The focus ethical frameworks that have been use to provide my final recommendations for this scenario are Consequentialism, Non-Consequentialism, Virtue Ethics and Care Ethics.... [tags: Ethics]
1563 words (4.5 pages)
- Introduction Using the four ethical frameworks from a Normative Perspective this scenario will be critically examined through the lens of the teacher. Ethical issues identified by the author are the divide between the prospective financial supporters and the beliefs and policies of the school. Furthermore the community’s health and wellbeing and the impact one has on the other. Definiton Consequentialism is a decision made based on the possible outcome of the action (Preston, 2001). Through examining the outcome the possible negative results can be eliminated (Dr A.... [tags: Ethics]
1509 words (4.3 pages)
- Teachers are faced with making ethical decisions everyday. In this scenario the teacher is solely responsible for making the ethical decision of whether to go against schools policy and continue sponsorship with McJacks which in turn discriminates against Molly. This essay will consider the possibilities for the teacher from four ethical frameworks and will discuss final recommendations based on this analysis. Consequentialists would argue that an act is right or wrong based on the goodness or badness inherent in the consequences of that act (Hugh, 2000).... [tags: Ethics]
1415 words (4 pages)
- The moral and ethical environment determines how we react in terms of justice, fairness, right, wrong, good, evil, tolerance, care, forgiveness and so fourth to the events that shape the world in which we live. Yet the forces that influence our views on such matters go mostly unnoticed (Burgh et al., 2006). The purpose of this paper is to develop a critical response to the Helping Molly scenario where I believe the key ethical issue is discrimination. A theoretical understanding of four ethical frameworks, more specifically the Consequentialism, Non-Consequentialism, Virtue and Care Ethics frameworks will be offered before they each are applied to analyse the scenario.... [tags: Ethics, Critical Response]
1542 words (4.4 pages)
- Case-Based Environmental Ethics Cases have been widely used in medical ethics and law. In both fields, numerous books and articles about cases have appeared, including book-length catalogs of cases. I argue that pluralistic casuistry provides an adequate approach to environmental ethics. It retains the strengths while avoiding the weaknesses of the other approaches. Importantly, it resolves some broader theoretical issues and provides a clear, explicit methodology for education and praxis. Cases have been widely used in medical ethics and law.... [tags: Philosophy Essays]
1751 words (5 pages)
- In “Consequentialism and Integrity,” Bernard Williams criticizes consequentialism on the ground that it is inherently unreasonable due to its insistence on negative responsibility, and as a result, denies the agent integrity. Peter Railton’s “Alienation, Consequentialism, and the Demands of Morality” is a response to Williams and a defense of consequentialism. In the following essay, I will explain Williams’s attack on consequentialism, and Railton’s argument that consequentialism need not deny the agent integrity.... [tags: Consequentialism and Integrity]
1437 words (4.1 pages)
- 4802EPS The Engaged Professional Exam S2587155 COI Q The overarching ethical issue within the Helping Molly scenario that will be analysed is the discrimination against a person based on their weight with an underlying issue of whether or not it is ethical to disregard a person due to their appearance in order to maximise financial gains. This is apparent within the scenario when McJacks tries to apply the condition of dropping Molly from any advertising photos due to her ‘big build’ and concern of negative publicity regarding the company image.... [tags: Business Ethics]
1995 words (5.7 pages)
- 1. Identify the main pros and cons of a virtue ethics approach. The virtue ethics approach is a theory that suggests that people are judged via their character, not specific actions. An individual who has developed good character traits (virtues) is judged as a morally good person. An individual who has developed bad character traits (vices) is judged as a morally bad person. Most of us have a mixture or virtues and vices. There are many pros and cons linked to this approach. The pros include a. Emphasis on pleasure and emotion – it is good that we should enjoy acting virtuously b. Moral education – being moral is a developmental process c. Consideration of life as a whole – “One swallow doe... [tags: Ethics ]
1015 words (2.9 pages)
- Consequentialism and non-consequentialism are both action based ethical frameworks that people can use to make ethical judgments. Consequentialism is based on examining the consequences of one’s actions as opposed to non-consequentialism which is focused on whether the act is right or wrong regardless of the outcome (Burgh, Field & Freakley, 2006). The three sub-categories of consequentialism are altruism, utilitarianism and egoism. Altruism is when the actions of a person promote the best consequences for others, yet do not benefit the person who performed the act.... [tags: Ethics]
1564 words (4.5 pages)
- Sally has obviously damaged the company, so her actions will definitely require an appropriate form of punishment. However, there are several factors that have to be taken in account. For example, Sally was a loyal, responsible, and fair worker during the last 20 years, so any extreme form of punishment could damage both Sally and the company. On the other hand, an inappropriate response from the management could encourage her deviant behavior towards the company in the future. With several conflicting factors apparent in this case, working out an appropriate solution is difficulty.... [tags: Ethics ]
963 words (2.8 pages)