Threshold arguments are based on the gap between an individual’s choice and the resulting moral progress. In the case of vegetarianism, the threshold argument against act-consequentialism is that if an individual chooses to adhere to vegetarianism, this does not guarantee that there will be a decrease in unnecessary suffering, thus rendering choices that promote vegetarianism useless. In argument form this states that:
1. If a threshold of x cannot be realized, then consequentialist theories of vegetarianism are moot.
2. A threshold of x cannot be realized.
3. Therefore, consequentialist theories of vegetarianism are moot.
However, in his article, Almassi challenges premise two of this argument using a modified Bayesian probability theory. The Bayesian probability theory states that as new evidences develop, the degree of belief in a hypothesis increases. Almassi modifies this theory by adding role modeling into it. Using the probability theory with role modeling plugged in, Almassi shows that the threshold of x can be reached. Because of the ripple effects that our actions and choices have, there is an increase in the probability that the threshold of x has been realized. Almassi expands on role modeling by stating that role modeling affects, not only those around the individual, but also the individual himself. The more often an individual p...
... middle of paper ...
...se of act-consequentialism because he uses the probability theory and employs role modeling in order to do so.
Almassi, Ben. "The Consequences of Individual Consumption: A Defence of Threshold
Arguments for Vegetarianism and Consumer Ethics." Journal Of Applied Philosophy 28, no. 4 (November 1, 2011): 396-411. Philosopher's Index, EBSCOhost (accessed February 15, 2014).
Blackburn, Simon. The Oxford dictionary of philosophy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1994.
"Position of the American Dietetic Association and Dietitians of Canada: vegetarian diets."
Canadian Journal Of Dietetic Practice And Research: A Publication Of Dietitians Of Canada = Revue Canadienne De La Pratique Et De La Recherche En Diététique: Une Publication Des Diététistes Du Canada 64, no. 2 (2003 Summer 2003): 62-81. MEDLINE with Full Text, EBSCOhost (accessed February 16, 2014).
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- 1. Introduction Alcohol is a legalized drug that is often consumed in excess. The heavy consumption of alcohol or binge drinking is an issue in New Zealand society that has not been discussed until recently however the social cost of binge drinking is increasing rapidly. This report discuses the behavior of binge drinking, and the looks at the reasons that people participate in this behavior. It also discusses the social and individual consequences of binge drinking The main sources used to research this report were journal articles sourced from both Ebesco database and Google Scholarly.... [tags: Alcoholism, Alcoholic beverage, Binge drinking]
1342 words (3.8 pages)
- According to Center for Disease Control and Protection, about 4,700 people under age twenty one die from injuries involving underage drinking every year. Illegal alcohol consumption has been a major problem with high school students around the nation. Lowering the drinking age from twenty one would result in major consequences for America’s adolescents. By lowering the drinking age, alcohol would be more accessible to those who choose to participate in underage drinking. The desire to drink for teens and young adults between the ages of fourteen and twenty can be caused by peer pressure or an act of rebellion.... [tags: underage drinking, from 21 to 18]
604 words (1.7 pages)
- Because the world is ever changing, people do not really stop and look at the things happening around them. People do not usually think about how population is interrelated with consumption and how both affect the world in different ways. A population has the ability to expand infinitely so long as there are enough resources in the environment to sustain it. As long as resources are available, populations can grow to large numbers; however, when resources become scarce, populations can also decrease to small groups.... [tags: consumption, population, resources]
3157 words (9 pages)
- Consumption is a complex social phenomenon in which people consume goods or services for reasons beyond their basic use-value (Firat, Kutucuoglue, Arikan Saltik & Tuncel, 2003). Sometime after the industrial revolution, consumer societies emerged around the world. A consumer society is one in which the entire society is organized around the consumption and display of commodities through which individuals gain prestige, identity, and standing. Media as well, has for long been contributing in increasing the level of consumption among people.... [tags: consumer society, media, consumption]
1027 words (2.9 pages)
- Prohibition and other substance bans have a long history in the United States dating back to the late 19th century. Cohen (2006) believed the root cause for drug-prohibition movement, including alcohol, derives from race. In the era of mass US immigration, Chinese, Mexicans, Black Africans, and European denominations, posed a democratic threat to White “native” Americans. White Racial fears amplified the moral problem of drug use to the Protestant Church by associating drugs with individual racial minorities.... [tags: Unintended Consequences]
1409 words (4 pages)
- Relationship Between Consumption and Identity In traditional societies, people's identity was rooted in a set of social roles and values, which provided orientation and religious sanctions to define ones place in the world. In modernity, identity is often characterised in terms of mutual recognition, as if ones identity depended on recognition from others combined with self- validation of this recognition. Identity still comes from a pre set of roles and norms. For example, a mother or a catholic, identities are still limited and fixed, though I believe the boundaries of possible new identities are continually expanding.... [tags: Identity Identities Consumption Essays]
1583 words (4.5 pages)
- When you think of British poets you quickly think of William Shakespeare. But, did you know that Shakespeare was not the only famous and successful play writer during his time. In fact, there were hundreds of famous British writers we do not hear about. One of Williams Shakespeare biggest competors was the successful Ben Jonson. Jonson was one of the most extravagant poetic that ever lived. He was known for his humorous plays, poems, and literary critics (www.luminarium.org). Ben Jonson was born June 11, 1572 in London, England (www.poet.org).... [tags: british poets, ben johndon, british poems]
867 words (2.5 pages)
- The purpose of this study was to examine the relationship among drinking motives, sport-related achievement motivations and alcohol consumption in a population of student athletes. Interaction effects for each type of drinking motive and achievement motivations were observed. The results indicated that there was a relationship between all three ADS subscales and alcohol use, as well as one SOQ subscale and alcohol use, but these relationships were moderated by both gender and athletic status. Implications for these finding are discussed below.... [tags: students, athlete, hazardous drinkers]
1967 words (5.6 pages)
- Business Analysis of Ben and Jerry's Introduction: Overview of the Case The corporation of Ben and Jerryâ€™s first began on May 5, 1978 in a small town called Burlington located in Virginia. The founders of this ice cream parlor were Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield with only limited funds of $8,000, they produced a famous nationwide parlor that caters to millions of people. Specialty flavors of Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Cherry Garcia, Rain Forest Crunch, and frozen yogurt are attractions and symbols to the corporation.... [tags: Corporations Ice Cream Ben and Jerry's Essays]
2274 words (6.5 pages)
- Ben Franklin / Many disagree with this statement and would conclude that in reality as well as appearance Franklin was an ambitious man and intent on self-improvement. Franklin was indeed an opportunist, always looking for an opportunity to advance himself, but he was America’s first universal man. He was an individual who could do many things exceedingly well and has paved the way for many who aspire to succeed in life as he had. Benjamin Franklin’s “erratas” have come to help the youth of America’s past and present, and will continue to help the future youth of America.... [tags: essays research papers]
825 words (2.4 pages)