John Austin viewed law as a legal positivism, which is a term that separates moral rules of positive law, and suggested, “Where there is law, there are patterns of commanding and obeying” (Murphy, Mark 2006, p. 17). Law starts with society therefore, without society and the people that make up our society laws would seize to exist. This idea would connect with law as a social phenomenon. Austin believed that commands reinforced by threats of sanctions from an authoritative figure was the main reason people obeyed laws.
I feel that Austin’s view is logical and consistent as well as persuasive in certain circumstance but not all. Take laws in a jail for example, they would relate to having a pattern of commands that are supported by threats from the prison warden. However, the laws of contracts do not hold commands reinforced by threats to give out sanctions if not followed. Contract laws are not commanding, unless said contract is broken. Austin’s view would be consistent in reference to prison laws, but not contract laws. Due to the fact that prison laws need to be consistent to keep order among the inmates and contract laws are not consistent because they change to fit whatever circumstance or situation that occurs.
In my personal opinion Austin’s argument is influential when it comes to prison laws but not contract laws. Prison laws advisee the offenders to act in a parti...
... middle of paper ...
...e basic human rights. Aquinas feels that in order for people to live well they need to be part of a bigger society which I do not agree with. For instance the Native Americans lived and survived just fine in their small tribes until Americans came and ruined it all. Aquinas’s view that everybody should naturally have basic human rights is logical and consistent as well as persuasive.
In conclusion philosophers over the years and continue to explore the question of what the law is. Many philosophers try to clarify what the meaning behind law is by developing efficient theories about it. The basic concepts of law, according to Murphy is that “law is a social phenomenon, law is authoritative, and the law is for the common good.” (Murphy, Mark 2006 p. 4) Each philosopher instills and holds onto those common places of law in theories in different understandable ways.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- One of the core roles of police officers is that of law enforcement. However, there are times that it is necessary for an officer to rely less on enforcement of the law and instead concentrate on keeping peace in situations that exist outside of the norm. One such situation exists in the policing methods used in “skid-row” type areas of society. These types of areas are an anomaly to the rest of standard communities where simply enforcing the law will not be successful. The goal in these areas is to plainly contain the chaos using a hybrid form of community policing.... [tags: Law Enforcement, policing, criminal justice]
1070 words (3.1 pages)
- Thomas Hobbes’ concept of natural law is shown in his theory of the state of nature, the pre-state environment, and consists of two laws: individuals have to pursue a peaceful life, and are allowed to defend their existence by any means possible. This has particular ramifications in the formation of civil society, especially in terms of loyalty, morality and the relationship between man and the leviathan that is the state. Hobbes’ theory has two of flaws in particular – the logic in his theory of the state of nature, and the relationship he expects mankind to have with the state.... [tags: Politics Philosophy Sociology]
1649 words (4.7 pages)
- Nature versus nurture has been debated between psychologists for years and probably will be for years to come. However, both sides of the debate need to come to their sense because the human being is a product of nature and nurture. There are endless experiments to test each side’s theories; but they will never reach a law. The reason for this is because there is too many variables that cannot be controlled. Nature is what we are born with, so our genes. Then nurture is how we are impacted by our environment; these are, parents, siblings, family, peers, culture, gender, norms, child rearing, and experiences.... [tags: Nature versus nurture, Human nature]
1718 words (4.9 pages)
- The concept of liberty stems from the system of natural law. It is highly dependent on the belief in natural law, in regards to three different aspects. First, the foundation of both concepts. The natural law has been influential in many ways, therefore concepts can be developed or derived from such a system. Secondly, the ideas found in liberty are similar to those found in the natural law in regards to the law being controlled by an entity. Finally, for protection against arbitrary offense to ensure a state of equality.... [tags: Political philosophy, Social contract, Law]
1593 words (4.6 pages)
- Mere Christianity In C.S Lewis’s Mere Christianity, Lewis provides his thoughts and beliefs on the subject of Christianity by setting up a logical breakdown of why Christians and humans in general behave the way they do. The first book Right And Wrong As A Clue To The Meaning Of The Universe has a lot to be discussed with in it. It describes the simple law of human nature and the concept of right and wrong. I believe that Lewis is right when he talks about there being a moral code. I think that each individual society has a set of standards they go by, people might not even be sure why they follow them or who made them; all they know is what they were taught by their elders growing up.... [tags: Morality, Good and evil, Buddhism, Ethics]
902 words (2.6 pages)
- A proper discussion of the concept and legal nature of international sanctions can be achieved by a dual means: assessing the concept of international sanctions and comparing it to the legal regime that attempts to disregard national sovereignty and jurisdictional limit of the law. In order to understand the concept of sanctions this discussion analyzes previous writings by John F. L. Ross who questions the international nature of sanctions that often outlaw staying on the fence. The discussion further delves into the writings of H.... [tags: Law, United Nations, International law]
927 words (2.6 pages)
- There are some, but not many I’d be willing to wager, that can imagine life without some form of digital input device. Computers, cell phones, tablets, cameras, the list goes on when we think about devices that bring the digital world to our fingertips. This gives us an awesome gift to have access to so much information and the conveniences such as shopping, communicating in different ways, and finding information that are enabled by the internet. With this gift though, comes an awesome responsibility that most do not consider.... [tags: Police, Law enforcement agency]
1880 words (5.4 pages)
- The Nature of the Law of Nature Humans are complex beings. They adapt, learn, have intelligence and free will, can reason, feel emotions, and have a conscience. Although such qualities and attributes raise humans above the rest of other life forms, it is questionable as to where the idea of a conscience and emotions come from. What exactly is it that stimulates our responses to certain situations and problems. The answer lies in human nature. What we as humans feel is right or wrong is somehow dictated by something beyond merely the individual.... [tags: Philosophy Science Essays]
1784 words (5.1 pages)
- Authors' Conceptions of Human Nature Philosophers, politicians, and writers throughout all of the western world and across all of our written history have discovered the importance of knowing human nature. Human nature is responsible for our definitions of abstract concepts that are surprisingly universal across the western world like justice, equity, and law. Human nature must also be carefully studied in an effort to understand, obtain, or maintain power within society. Finally, human nature must also be carefully understood so as to protect it from being manipulated and to understand its place in society.... [tags: Human Nature Philosophy Essays]
3888 words (11.1 pages)
- The increasing complexities of present diverse societies have led parliaments to develop various types of laws and regulations on the basis of the establishment of these intricate notions of rule of law, separation of powers and responsible government in order to maintain social order and harmony between police, citizens and the government. These implementation have distinctive application within contemporary society and the way in which they are applied to policing, as they all aim to achieve civilized and agreeable laws to prevent anarchy and chaos.... [tags: Law]
1694 words (4.8 pages)