Comparison of the Vietnam War and Trojan War

Comparison of the Vietnam War and Trojan War

Length: 1178 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
The Vietnam War and the Trojan War were two separate tragedies that took place in very different time periods yet. They have many things in common such as their senselessness, the brutality shown, and the way the soldiers were treated when they returned to their homeland. In this paper we will touch on those three topics explaining the petty causes of the war and how cruelly the opposing potencies attacked the enemy. Also, we will discover the great similarity in how the soldiers were treated upon returning from the war and how the war affected their lives.
Most historians view the nature of the Vietnam War as rooted in the history of the French colonies in Vietnam and the growing ethnic, political, and economical division between Catholic and Buddhist Vietnamese. (Brigham, Robert, Hoffman, Kenneth)
At the end of World War II, Japanese forces in Indochina turned over power to Vietnamese Nationalists. Japan had created an independent Vietnamese government. Japan allowed this government to be displaced by the Viet Minh under Ho Chi Minh. (The History Place, Beginner’s Guide)
The next month, a British force landed in southern Vietnam and occupied Indochina. (The History Place)
The French eventually gained back some control over parts of Vietnam. In early 1946, the French began a series of dual negotiations with the Chinese and Viet Minh over the future of Vietnam. After failed negotiations with the French over the future of Vietnam, Ho Chi Minh and his Viet Minh retreated into remote parts of the countryside to fight a small-scale insurgency against the French. (The History Place, Beginner’s Guide)
Though the U.S had no direct role in the return of the French to Indochina, Washington’s desire for a more uniform European economy and European cooperation on a variety of other things required French cooperation. Because successive French governments threatened to become more uncooperative in Europe if the United States refused to accede to their demands overseas, Washington committed itself to a policy of supporting the French in Indochina. (The History Place, Wikipedia)
In this way we can see that the United State’s involvement in the Vietnam War was manipulated and “arranged” by the French who needed help and knew that the United States would have no choice but to accede to their proposal.
The Trojan War was also manipulated although not in the same way. Eris or Strife, the goddess of discord, after not being invited to a wedding party for the gods devised a plan to spoil the wedding.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Comparison of the Vietnam War and Trojan War." 18 Aug 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparing Vietnam Soldiers During The Trojan War Essay

- Posttraumatic stress disorder is a psychological disorder that occurs after a person has been through a traumatic event, such as combat warfare. In this essay, I would like to compare Vietnam soldiers to soldiers in the Trojan War, and contrast the similarities and differences between the two, also analyze how soldiers’ lives have been affected similarly throughout two completely different wars. I would also like to show the irony of war, and how war doesn’t only dehumanize soldiers, but it also inspires valuable human qualities....   [tags: Iliad, Achilles, Trojan War, Greek mythology]

Research Papers
1104 words (3.2 pages)

Analysis Of The Book ' The Trojan War ' Essay

- Xenia, the ancient Greek concept of hospitality, was one of the foremost forces in Homer’s Iliad. The Achaeans respect it above nearly all else, and failure to adhere to its strict customs could lead to the forfeiture of countless souls. The Trojan War was incited by Paris’ theft of Menelaus’ wife. This is the first, and only, breach of xenia in all of the Iliad, with good cause. Paris was Menelaus’ guest but chose to steal Menelaus’ wife and much of his riches instead of honoring xenia as he should have....   [tags: Trojan War, Iliad, Homer, Odysseus]

Research Papers
938 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on The Epic Of The Trojan War

- Upon first glance, the Trojan War may not appear relevant to the world today, but with further thought, the epic starts connecting to the present. One of the epic’s elements, the gods as an abiding feature in the lives of humans, can be studied providing education about historical and current societies. Music, literature, and art allow people to study what individuals and societies believe or once believed about the existence of gods or a god, and people can determine if certain societies or civilizations believe or have believed that gods or a god have the capability to influence or control events that occur in the world....   [tags: Homer, Achilles, Trojan War, Iliad]

Research Papers
1308 words (3.7 pages)

The Tale Of The Trojan War Essays

- An Epic Love Triangle For years, Greek literature has transitioned from ancient scrolls, to school textbooks, and oftentimes to the big screen. Stories about Oedipus, Hercules, and the Titans have been told throughout the years captivating generation after generation. These classics never go out of style. Greek mythological characters make for perfect movie stars; however, Hollywood doesn’t always stick to the script when portraying these legendary figures or their glorified stories. The tale of the Trojan War, is one of the most profound works of art, written by Homer, in his poem the Iliad....   [tags: Trojan War, Iliad, Homer, Helen]

Research Papers
819 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on The Trojan War, And It Starts With The Achaean

- Book 1 Book 1 takes place during the Trojan War, and it starts with the Achaean (Greek) army during one of its many raids on the cities surrounding Troy. The army discovers two beautiful maidens, Chryseis and Briseis they then award the maidens to the commander and chief Agamemnon (AG) and Achaean’s greatest warrior Achilles (AC). Now Chryses Chryseis’s father shortly discovers his daughter is missing and demands AG return her at once, but AG says no. So Chryses prays for Apollo to send a plague down on the Achaean camp and he does....   [tags: Iliad, Trojan War, Greek mythology, Agamemnon]

Research Papers
713 words (2 pages)

Essay about The World Of The Trojan War

- At the time of the Trojan War, countries, as we know them today, did not exist. Instead, there were city-states. People lived in their homes and carried on their lives clustered behind the protective walls of their city. Powerful kings ruled the people. On the Greek mainland, King Agamemnon ruled over the city state of Mycenae and his brother, Menelaus, ruled over Sparta. On the mainland of present day Turkey, King Priam ruled over the magnificent city-state of Troy, its protective walls built by the gods....   [tags: Trojan War, Iliad, Greek mythology, Achilles]

Research Papers
1976 words (5.6 pages)

Women Of The Trojan War Essay

- Women are designated scapegoats of societies throughout history. Women are blamed for using seduction to trick men or are used as prizes for men to fight over; consequently, this allows men to begin wars or arguments over a single woman. In the case of the Trojan War, as depicted through Homer’s Iliad, women are the outright reason for encouraging and causing the greatest heroes to fight for nothing. The Trojan War begins with the abduction of Helen (McAllister 8), which is described through previous mythology where Aphrodite awards her to Paris for judging that Aphrodite is the most beautiful goddess, thus beginning the cycle that women are made prizes....   [tags: Trojan War, Iliad, Greek mythology, Achilles]

Research Papers
2461 words (7 pages)

The Ancient Trojan War Essay

- The ancient Trojan War would be hard to visualize without horses and chariots. In fact, in the Iliad, the most extensive account of the war, the word “horses” appears nearly 300 times, and “chariot” is not far behind. Homer features these chariots in many scenes, both on and off the battlefield, and, in the process, makes several points about warrior code and other values in ancient Greece. The uses of chariots in the Iliad illustrate some of the epic’s views of skill, sportsmanship, and honor. The primary use of chariots in the story is in battle....   [tags: Trojan War, Achilles, Iliad, Patroclus]

Research Papers
1052 words (3 pages)

Essay Perdurable Power in a Perpetual War

- Homer’s Iliad can be used as a lens through which to view Rambo: First Blood. The use of the Iliad’s protagonist Achilles as a comparison to Rambo further illuminates the complexities in the character struggle of Rambo. Whereas Achilles has eternal kleos glorified through Homer’s song to gain by taking vengeance and fighting, Rambo will never be seen as an honorable heroic veteran of war. Rambo is an ostracized and disillusioned man who struggles not for honor but for survival in the “civilized” United States just as he did in war torn Vietnam....   [tags: Homer, Iliad, Rambo]

Research Papers
932 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on The Vietnam War

- The Vietnam War Student unrest and the Vietnam War In the middle 1960s, every male in America had to register for Selective Service Draft at age 18. He would then be eligible for the draft and could be inducted into the Army for a period of two years. If you were a college student, you could receive a deferment and would be able to finish college without the fear of being drafted. However, once finished with college, a students name would be put to the very top of the draft list and could be deployed at anytime....   [tags: History Vietnam War]

Research Papers
1138 words (3.3 pages)

She threw a golden apple inscribed “for the fairest” in the midst of the wedding guests. Athena, Hera, and Aphrodite all wished to claim the apple for themselves. Not wanting the wrath of the goddesses the gods sent them to Paris, prince of Troy, so he could chose between them. Each of the goddesses promised to reward Paris if he chose her but Aphrodite won in promising him the hand of the most beautiful woman in the world (Helen of Sparta) in marriage. Because of this, Troy won the unequivocal wrath of Athena and Hera. They plotted to destroy Troy through Greece and through Helen’s suitors’ agreement. In this way, the Trojan War was begun and manipulated by the gods. (Jimmy Joe, Cinderella, McDougal)
Both wars led to the deaths of many innocent civilians caused by the brutality and cruelty shown by the attacking potencies. In Vietnam the number of casualties is estimated to be around 1.5 million people. The casualties in the Trojan War are not recorded in numbers for the entire city, men, women, and children, were killed. (Vietnam War Info)
In the Vietnam War many innocent people were killed in such massacres as the My Lai Massacre. Fighting against an almost invisible enemy mixed in the civilian population and suffering injuries and deaths from booby traps and attacks by soldiers who pretended to be civilians could not help but lead to fear and hatred. In 1969, U.S investigative journalist Seymour Hersh exposed the My Lai Massacre and its cover-up. It came to light that Lt. William Calley had been ordered to investigate and dissolve Viet Cong control in a village that was believed to be harboring the Viet Cong. Upon arriving at the village, Lt. Calley and his men discovered that it was populated mainly by women and children. Because the U.S intelligence had declared that the village was a Viet Cong hiding place Lt. Cong viewed all civilians as Viet Cong. Lt. Calley ordered his men to execute several Vietnamese civilians including women, children, and the elderly. The massacre was stopped only after three U.S soldiers noticed the carnage from their helicopter and intervened to prevent their fellow soldiers from killing any more civilians. (Wikipedia)
In the Trojan War, the Greeks had the element of surprise to their advantage. The Trojans were totally unarmed and unsuspecting. This helped the Greeks greatly in their quest to annihilate Troy. Because the gods had predestined Troy’s destruction and even though Athena was Troy’s protectress she was angry at Paris, the Greeks inevitably won the war and totally destroyed the Trojans….every last one. (Jimmy Joe)
Another thing the wars had in common was the way the soldiers were treated upon returning home. Though time periods differ significantly, the antiphon of society to the occurrences at war were much alike.
Soldiers who served in the Vietnam War were respected by some, shunned by others. Attitudes toward U.S involvement in the war affected their treatment. Many Vietnam veterans experienced social isolation in the years following the war. On October 3, 1987 Australian Vietnam veterans were honored at a “Welcome Home” parade in Sydney, and it was then that a campaign for a Vietnam memorial began. The Vietnam Forces National Memorial in Canberra was dedicated in 1992. In recent years, emotional distance from the war and a more dispassionate view of the war have brought about a more sympathetic and respectful attitude towards Vietnam War veterans. Ten years after the war the American soldiers were finally welcomed home. The Vietnam Veterans Memorial in Washington, D.C is located on the National Mall adjacent to the Lincoln Memorial. (Wikipedia, Leuhusen, Peter)
Returning Greek warriors were both treated as heroes and shunned, just as the Vietnam War veterans. Some though were merely forgotten or believed to not be returning at all. Such was the case of Odysseus, or Ulysses. Legend has it that the Greeks back home were already fighting over Odysseus’ wife, Penelope, believing that he was not returning. (Wikipedia, Homer)
As we can see, both the Trojan War and the Vietnam War were analogous. We have been able to view how both wars were manipulated by other influences and that both were very violent, killing many. We can also compare the way the soldiers were treated. Society had similar concepts of them though slightly different. Now though, we can see that the veterans are treated as heroes, the way the Greeks revered their warriors. Both wars relate to each other in significant ways and show how history can be relative to current events.
Return to