Comparison of The Shining and Maus I Essay

Comparison of The Shining and Maus I Essay

Length: 981 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Shining is a 1977 horror novel by Stephen King that is based on events at the Overlook Hotel where the Torrance family is snowed in for the winter which leads to some unfortunate events. Maus I: a Survivor’s Tale: My Father Bleeds History is a 1986 graphic novel by Art Spiegelman about the story of his father during the Holocaust. Both of these novels are good stories that are filled with episodes and events that are demonstrated differently. Although the plots of The Shining and Maus 1 bear some minor similarities, the difference between them are more clear, which includes whether the plot is linear and sequential, and the use of stream of consciousness, foreshadowing, and flashbacks. The novel Maus I is story within a story so it goes back and forth from the present and the past, which means the plot is not completely linear and sequential. In the other hand, the novel The Shining is more linear and sequential than Maus I. Both of the novels contains flashbacks and has foreshadowing but The Shining has more foreshadowing than Maus I but less flashbacks. The Shining clearly includes stream of consciousness while in Maus I it is not.
In The Shining, the plot is sequential and linear. The plot is a typical pyramid structure with a steeper falling action. The novel starts with the exposition which states who the novel is about, which in this case is the Torrance family, their background, their characteristics, the setting of the story, and what the problem might be. This goes on until they start to settle in the Overlook Hotel. Then it goes on to the rising actions, which are the supernatural events that happened like the shining with Danny and Holloran, room 217, the hedges, and the elevator incident. Then it reaches the cli...


... middle of paper ...


...th from the past and present it gives the reader a better understanding of how not only it has effected him but also his son Artie and Anja. A stream of consciousness was not very much used in Maus I because everything was told as a story.
Maus I and The Shining are completely different types of novels, one graphic and the other horror. The differences between the plots of both are more pronounced. One of them has the typical pyramid structure plot while the other has more of a half pyramid and being continued in Maus II. The Shining is sequential and linear and Maus I is not sequential and non-linear. Flashbacks are more essential to Maus I and foreshadow is more to The Shining.



Works Cited
King, Stephen. The Shining. New York: Doubleday, 1977. Print.
Spiegelman, Art. Maus I: a Survivor’s Tale: My Father Bleeds History. New York: Pantheon Books, 1986. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Maus and the Holocaust

- The Holocaust is known to all of us in some manner. Maybe we know someone who survived this terrible event in history, or one has learned about it in school, either way, everyone has had some kind of knowledge about the horrible things that the Nazi party did to the European Jews during the Holocaust. The Holocaust took a great toll on many lives in one way or another, one in particular being Vladek Spiegleman.  Vladek's personality underwent a huge change due to his experiences during World War II.  His personality is so dynamic and it was the experiences that he made during the Holocaust that changed him so dramamtically....   [tags: Maus]

Better Essays
839 words (2.4 pages)

Analysis Of The Book ' Maus I And Maus ' Essay

- Stereotypes have a way of arranging items or things in an arrangement to comprehend them in a perfectly systematic way. A frightening notion would be, saying that something will not fit and that it would be an entrance that is unsure of the world that we are occupying. Using art we can recognize different stereotypes without thinking and as a reader, we can react identically. Theater philosopher and play biographer Bertolt Brecht states, “It is well known that contact between audience and stage is normally made on the basis of empathy” (136)....   [tags: Maus, Art Spiegelman, The Reader, Stereotypes]

Better Essays
1699 words (4.9 pages)

Contrasting Interactions with the Environment Depicted in Alice Munro's The Shining Houses

- How is our character revealed through our interaction with the natural world around us. Do we adapt to fit in with nature, or do we force the landscape to conform to our ideals of lifestyle. In the short story “The Shining Houses”, Alice Munro addresses the contrast in lifestyle ideologies between two generations through their interactions with the natural environment they populate. The older generation is content to live in harmony with the existing natural world and develop its infrastructure amongst the present landscape....   [tags: The Shining Houses]

Better Essays
677 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on `` Maus `` By Art Spiegelman

- Art Spiegelman, the author of “Maus”, portrays the suffering and the survival that meant to be Jewish during the Holocaust by describing the experience of his own family as a graphic memoir. Vladek narrates moments of cruelty that he had to go through in the Nazi concentration camps where many Jewish people were targeted like him and his wife, Anja. However, he always had a survival instinct that made him found a way to overcome adversities. Even in the present time of the book, Vladek suffers when he remembers people that are not alive like his son Archieu, who was killed as a child, and Anja, who killed herself....   [tags: Maus, Art Spiegelman, White]

Better Essays
1874 words (5.4 pages)

Editing In The Shining Essay

- Editing in The Shining In his classic horror film, The Shining, Stanley Kubrick utilizes many different elements of editing to create unique and terrifying scenes. Kubrick relies on editing to assist in the overall terrifying and horrifying feel created in the movie. Editing in the movie creates many different effects, but the most notable effects created add to the continuity of the film as well as the sense of fear and terror....   [tags: Film Shining Analysis Effect]

Free Essays
1182 words (3.4 pages)

Analysis Of Spiegelman 's ' Maus ' Essay

- In Art Spiegelman’s Maus, the audience is led through a very emotional story of a Holocaust survivor’s life and the present day consequences that the event has placed on his relationship with the author, who is his son, and his wife. Throughout this novel, the audience constantly is reminded of how horrific the Holocaust was to the Jewish people. Nevertheless, the novel finds very effective ways to insert forms of humor in the inner story and outer story of Maus. Although the Holocaust has a heart wrenching effect on the novel as a whole, the effective use of humor allows for the story to become slightly less severe and a more tolerable read....   [tags: Humour, Comedy, Maus, Art Spiegelman]

Better Essays
1269 words (3.6 pages)

The Complete Maus : Homework Task Essay

- The Complete MAUS: Homework Task 1. What did you think was the message of the book. Why. Make reference to details from the book in your answer. The author clearly states in the graphic novel that “I-I never thought of reducing it to a message I mean. I wasn’t trying to CONVICE anybody of anything.” Spiegelman represents a struggle to create meaning out of both the Holocaust and what happened to his father afterwards. Art says to Francoise at one point: “I can’t even make any sense of out my relationship with my father...How am I supposed to make any sense out of Auschwitz?...of the holocaust?” (p....   [tags: Nazi Germany, Antisemitism, Jews, Maus]

Better Essays
1304 words (3.7 pages)

The Swastika in MAUS Essay

- The Swastika in MAUS The image of the swastika pervades Arthur Spiegelman's graphic novel MAUS. In a work where so much of the Holocaust has been changed in some way - after all, there are no humans in this version, only cats, mice, dogs, and pigs - we must wonder why Spiegelman chooses to retain this well-known emblem. To remove it entirely or replace it with another, invented symbol would completely disorient the reader; but some might claim that this is the effect at which Spiegelman is aiming....   [tags: Maus Essays]

Better Essays
826 words (2.4 pages)

Stanley Kubrick's The Shining Essay examples

- Stanley Kubrick's The Shining (1980) initially received quite a bit of negative criticism. The film irritated many Stephen King fans (and King himself) because it differed so greatly from the novel. The Shining also disappointed many filmgoers who expected a conventional slasher film. After all, Kubrick said it would be "the scariest horror movie of all time."1 Kubrick's films, however, never fully conform to their respective genres; they transcend generic expectations. In the same way that 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968) is not just another outer-space sci-fi flick, The Shining is not a typical horror movie....   [tags: Kubrick Shining Horror Essays]

Better Essays
2480 words (7.1 pages)

Genre Criticism of Stanley Kubricks The Shining Essay examples

- Genre Criticism of Stanley Kubricks The Shining The true measure of success for any film lies in its ability to establish a relationship with its audience. Perhaps more than in any other genre, the horror film must be aware of this relationship and manage it carefully. After all, the purpose of a horror film is not necessarily to invoke thought, but rather to evoke an emotional reaction from its audience. Horror films of all types have used frightening images, disturbing characters, and thrilling sequences to inspire fear....   [tags: Shining Stanley Kubricks Essays]

Better Essays
1815 words (5.2 pages)