Essay Comparison Of Nepenthe And Jant Depict The Possible And The Impossible

Essay Comparison Of Nepenthe And Jant Depict The Possible And The Impossible

Length: 1816 words (5.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


Nepenthe and Jant Depict the Possible and the Impossible
With similar approaches of showing the reader the distinctions between the impossible and the possible, Alphabet of Thorn and The Year of Our War are more alike than at first glance. In these two fantasy novels each author treats and explains to the reader the question of what is possible and what is impossible very similarly. With each author employing the use of a first person narrator the reader is able to see through their eyes the ways in which things are possible or not possible in these other worlds. In a fantasy story, like each of these novels, the author shows the reader the impossible in the text and then continues to engage the reader but does not try and explain and render the impossible as something that is plausible and possible. Patricia McKillip and Steph Swainston both use these techniques in their novels.
In Alphabet of Thorn Patricia McKillip presents an alternate world that uses a magical library and an ordinary orphan to develop a plot and setting. At first glance the reader begins to realize that this world is unlike their own because the reader does not have a community and society that functions and is arranged like the one in the novel. From a definition standpoint, cognition of the impossible is established where “we realize, usually early on in fantasy, that the accepted ground rules of our reality are in some significant way being contravened.” McKillip portrays the setting as a world unlike reality and adds aspects of things the reader is able to understand while at the same time makes it known and obvious that it is a world unlike the one the reader is living in. For example, in reality there may be orphans and libraries and translators, but a...


... middle of paper ...


...o see the restrictions of the world. Through Nepenthe’s thoughts and ponderings about the order of history we learn about the realm in which she lives. In Jant’s life we get a first person narrative with many flashbacks that include details that help show the reader what is expected and normal and therefore possible in his world. Through the Shift and Jant’s drug use the reader is given a view of things that are abnormal and impossible in Jants “real world.” Each author is unique in delivering of these boundaries, but each uses a similar device to tell the reader what is impossible and what is possible in these other worlds. From both of these authors the reader can learn more about fantasy and the ways in which authors develop intense and unique settings with diverse characters that challenge the readers to think about their own world and the laws and beliefs in it.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Comparison of Film Techniques Used to Depict the Omaha Landing Essay

- A Comparison of Film Techniques Used to Depict the Omaha Landing “Saving Private Ryan” & “The Longest Day” In this assignment I will be comparing two scenes of the landings on the Omaha Beach during the Second World War. The first film is “The Longest Day” and the second film is “Saving Private Ryan”. The Longest Day was shot in 1962 compared with the more recent filming of Saving Private Ryan which was shot in 1998. I will be focussing on the camera angles, special effects, sound effects which includes the music used to depict certain scenes and the audiences reaction to this....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1040 words (3 pages)

Essay on Women Of The Classical World Depict Women

- Although many plays of the classical world depict women in lead roles, because they are written and performed by men, the female characters have no agency. Societal restrictions in antiquity forced women to remain in the house, to tend to children, and to support their husbands. As early as the Homeric stories, women were defined by the men in their lives. Helen of Troy defined by Menelaus and Paris, Briseis by Achilles and Agamemnon, and so forth exemplify the male dominance in Hellenic social structures....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Sophocles, Man]

Strong Essays
1247 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on The World Working Together - is it Impossible?

- The World Working Together – is it Impossible. The world is today at a very peculiar balance, a balance at which it has never been before. Statistics reveal that the richest fifth of the population use up over 80% of the world’s resources. This makes an important question and a very central topic for debates worldwide. In contemporary times, as the richest countries have so much wealth, it is general consensus that some should be given to poorer countries, as a form of assistance, to help them build a well-functioning society and to improve the quality of life in poorer areas....   [tags: wealth, conflict, corruption]

Strong Essays
1011 words (2.9 pages)

Essay Democracy Is An Impossible System Of Governance

- Essay Topics Please select one of the following topics. Democracy is an impossible system of governance. Discuss. Former U.S. president Abraham Lincoln defined democracy as: “Government of the people, by the people, for the people”. The idea of democracy looked great on paper, and was utilized as a primary government system for generations, but has democracy really proven to be effective. Are democratic systems really forms of government where power is ‘in the hands of the people’. We can only tell by going over the main assets that democracy represents and stands for....   [tags: Democracy, Elections, Voting, Election]

Strong Essays
1532 words (4.4 pages)

Essay about Summer Reading Comparison

- Over the long period of summer I read two books that, despite their Genre are based on the same theme. Both “The Radioactive Boy Scout” by Ken Silverstein and “The High Lord” by Trudi Canavan are both about a protagonist fighting to achieve an almost impossible goal. Ken Silverstein brings forth an obsessive character, “David Hahn”, utilizing science, to enlighten the reader of the unique characteristics of a true whiz kid and a scientist, on the other hand, Trudi Canavan, produces a black magician's era to tell a story of one (Sonea) who fights to better society....   [tags: Literary Comparisons]

Strong Essays
639 words (1.8 pages)

Comaparison of The Crucible and Sommersby Essay

- Sometimes two things may seem like they have nothing in common but when analyzed more critically one may find many similarities. A good example of this would be between The Crucible and Sommersby. These two stories may seem like they have nothing in common; one, The Crucible, is about the Salem witch trials, the other, Sommersby, is about a POW returning home after six years. These two stories may appear to be totally different but they do in fact share many similarities. Three of the characters in The Crucible are very similar to three characters in Sommersby....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
796 words (2.3 pages)

Social Comparison Research Essay

- Social comparison is primarily known as determining our social and self-worth by associating other’s into the equation. In other words, it is common that we make evaluations about our self and others most of the time. A majority of individuals, however, have the power to hold back our judgments and take control of jealous feelings that might spring up. The social comparison theory is how we discover ourselves and the characteristics we possess by comparing those traits with others’. This theory is much more complex than simply comparing one another - consisting of three types of comparisons and times when these evaluations are necessary....   [tags: Social comparison theory, Comparisons, Comparison]

Strong Essays
850 words (2.4 pages)

How Do the Makers of "Trainspotting" Depict British Youth Sub-culture? Essay

- "Poison or Pearls, Reality or Fantasy?" (Street 110): How do the makers of Trainspotting depict British youth sub-culture and what methods of filming do they use to communicate their message in the surrealist way the film is famous for. Trainspotting (1996) is a "depiction of the squalid depravities and exploitative self interest that characterises the everyday life of heroin addiction." (Petrie 90) Its' realistic style, use of language and unflinching portrayal of drug use was what first attracted me to look at it a bit closer....   [tags: Sociology]

Strong Essays
1004 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The Impossible World of M. C. Escher

- The Impossible World of M. C. Escher Something about the human mind seeks the impossible. Humans want what they don’t have, and even more what they can’t get. The line between difficult and impossible is often a gray line, which humans test often. However, some constructions fall in a category that is clearly beyond the bounds of physics and geometry. Thus these are some of the most intriguing to the human imagination. This paper will explore that curiosity by looking into the life of Maurits Cornelis Escher, his impossible perspectives and impossible geometries, and then into the mathematics behind creating these objects....   [tags: Mathematics Science Papers]

Free Essays
2079 words (5.9 pages)

Essay Comparisons

- Comparisons Gerard David and Mary Cassatt both are remarkable artists who has influenced artists today. Gerard David was born in 1455 in the Netherlands (Oudewater). Mary Cassatt was born in 1861 in Pennsylvania. Even though they were born at different times, their paintings show the relationship between mother and child. David painted Virgin and Child With Four Angels in 1510. The type of canvas used was wood with oil paint. The wood has a rectangular shape. The Virgin and Child characters that were reproduced from a painting by Jan van Eyck, who influenced David when he settled in Bruges in 1484....   [tags: essays papers]

Free Essays
742 words (2.1 pages)