Essay on Comparison Between Chomsky 's Film, Catherine As A Frail Young Woman

Essay on Comparison Between Chomsky 's Film, Catherine As A Frail Young Woman

Length: 1052 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

This pushed her to seek the help of a British ambassador who would teach her the trade secrets of political work. It was through this ambassador that she would learn to buy allies and information. This was the first time the audience becomes explicitly aware of the political cunningness that Catherine is capable of wielding. She uses this time in her life to gather resources to make well-educated decisions that gain her the most amount of power in the court. This is a very different perspective that the audience is seeing compared to Chomsky’s version. In Chomsky’s film, Catherine is portrayed as a frail young woman who is in constant need of help from her advisors to make any large decisions that may have any political danger. Between the two films, the audiences develop two completely different images of the same historical figure because of how the directors of each movie decided to present their material. Even the contributing individuals within the films appear vastly different depending on how they are presented.
The third point of change among sources is how Peter is portrayed. In the first film, he is seen as a rich drunken playboy who may or may not be incapable of ruling Russia, but that is slightly overshadowed due to the maturity issues that Chomsky shows Catherine having that could also be a problem for her also ruling. In his film about the historical couple, neither was fit to rule because one was a hormonal teenager who could only make decisions if her advisors told her what she should do, and the other was only concerned with sleeping with his whore.
However, Davidson and Burgess take a different approach towards representing Peter to the audience. The directors present him as not being a drunken playboy, but a c...


... middle of paper ...


...Catherine’s story that was not addressed in the two films was her fascination with the Enlightenment period. Sumner goes into detail about how the Enlightenment period heavily influenced her reign, policies enacted, and reforms instituted.
The second point that is different compared to the two previous sources is that Catherine’s major concern is dedicated towards modernizing Russia instead of gaining a powerful political base or finding true love. Sumner uses many examples to illustrate this is her focus throughout her reign. The first example pertained to wars that were won under Catherine’s reign that expanded Russia’s borders far south to the shores of the Black Sea. This provided a larger amount of resources and new serfs to provide their country with more wealth and power. The second example of Catherine trying to modernize Russia was her infatuation with the

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparison of Letters to Catherine Beecher by Angelina Grimke and Ain't I A Woman? by Sojourner Truth

- The 19th century was a time of great social change in the United States as reflected by the abolitionist movement and the women’s suffrage movement. Two very influential women leaders were Angelina Grimke and Sojourner Truth. Grimke was born a Southern, upper class white woman. She moved to the North as a young woman, grew involved in abolitionism and women’s rights, and became known for her writing, particularly “Letters to Catherine Beecher”. Sojourner Truth was born into slavery as Isabella Baumfree; she escaped to freedom, changed her name, and became an active speaker on behalf of both the abolition and women’s rights movements....   [tags: Compare Contrast]

Better Essays
1727 words (4.9 pages)

Comparing Society's Influence in Pride and Prejudice and The Edible Woman

- Society's Influence in Pride and Prejudice and The Edible Woman       Throughout history, society has played an important role in forming the value and attitudes of the population.  Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice and Margaret Atwood's The Edible Woman are two novels which exemplify the negative effects of society's influence. Both Elizabeth Bennet and Marian McAlpin are strong women who rebel against society's influences in their lives.  They refuse to accept the pre-set roles and identities handed to them.  Both women realize that the individual's needs are not necessarily the same as what society imposes on them; they rebel against this very society in order to gai...   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Better Essays
1529 words (4.4 pages)

The Power and Influence of Catherine De Medici Essay

- ... This cause a lot of ruckus throughout France, they didn’t want an Italian woman to become their queen. Many even thought he would never have children and her time would be short but between 1543 and 1555 she gave birth to ten children, seven of which went on to adulthood. Throughout Henrys reign as king, he excluded Catherine participating in state affairs. “Catherine stayed in the background as there was no reason for her to grasp the limelight as her husband, the strong king and the nobility appeared to be tamed under his strong leadership”....   [tags: French Renaissance, Catherine the Great]

Better Essays
895 words (2.6 pages)

Comparison of Mr. Wickham's and Elizabeth's Attitude Towards Marriage in Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice

- Comparison of Mr. Wickham's and Elizabeth's Attitude Towards Marriage in Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice The novel, 'Pride and Prejudice' revolves around a mother of five daughters, Mrs. Bennet, whose sole purpose is to marry off her daughters to suitable men. Her eldest, Jane, is her most prized daughter. Mrs. Bennet is assured that Jane's beauty and meticulous manners will win her a prized husband. In the end Mrs. Bennet succeeds in marrying her to a husband and in addition she gets Lydia and Elizabeth married too; Jane to Mr Bingley, Lydia to Mr....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
857 words (2.4 pages)

Comparing Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night and After a Time Essays

- Comparing Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night and After a Time Dylan Thomas' "Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night" and Catherine Davis' "After a Time" demand comparison: Davis' poem was written in deliberate response to Thomas'. Davis assumes the reader's familiarity with "Do Not Go Gentle," which she uses to articulate her contrasting ideas. "After a Time," although it is a literary work in its own right, might even be thought of as serious parody--perhaps the greatest compliment one writer can pay another....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Better Essays
838 words (2.4 pages)

The Story of Saint Catherine’s Prison Essay

- The Story of Saint Catherine’s Prison “Near Famagusta is another city called Salamis, set on the seashore, where there was once a noble and wealthy city. It is there that St. Catherine was born and her tomb remains still.” ~ German priest Ludolf von Suchen of Westphalia In the 12th century, the story of the beloved St. Catherine was brought to Europe by the Crusaders returning from their battles in the East. She was from a noble blood line of Roman emperors and her father was Constantine, King of Salamis....   [tags: Saint Catherine]

Free Essays
446 words (1.3 pages)

Catherine the Great (Catherine II of Russia) Essay

- After Peter the Great’s death, Russia faced a long time period full of weak rulers who didn’t have any significant contributions to Russia (Farah). However, after 37 long years, a woman called Sophie Friederike Auguste, Catherine II or Catherine the Great, who had married the czar of Russia 17 years earlier, became the next great ruler of Russia. Catherine, a very intellectual woman, was interested in music and literature, knew German, French, and managed to learn Russian in a short period of time....   [tags: Intelligent, Monarch, Ruler]

Better Essays
923 words (2.6 pages)

Catherine The Great Essay

- Sophie of Anhalf-Zerbst was born on May 2, 1729 in the Germany city of Stettin (Szczecin, now Poland). She was born of a minor German prince, into a society that legally separated and isolated its female population. Though society was against her she was recognized by her father for her great ability to learn and remember concepts and ideas. After proving her ideas and abilities, she received a formal education. In 1744, at the age of 14, she married the Grand Duke Peter of Holstein who was heir to the Russian throne ....   [tags: Yekaterina Alexeevna, Catherine I]

Better Essays
1880 words (5.4 pages)

Essay Catherine The Great

- Sophia Frederika-Augusta, later known as Catherine, was born on May 2, 1729 in the Baltic seaport town of Stettin, then part of German Pomerania. She was born into the Anhalt- Zerbst family, one of the poorest and most obscure of all the German princely families. Her father, Christian Augusta, did not become the reigning prince of Zerbst until Catherine was thirteen years old. In 1743, at the age of fifteen, Catherine's mother, Johanna, found her a husband. She was to marry Grand Duke Peter III of Holstein, he was sixteen....   [tags: Biography Russia Catherine Great]

Free Essays
1808 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on Catherine The Great

- Catherine The Great Russian in full YEKATERINA ALEKSEYEVNA, byname CATHERINE THE GREAT, Russian YEKATERINA VELIKAYA, original name SOPHIE FRIEDERIKE AUGUSTE, PRINZESSIN (PRINCESS) VON ANHALT-ZERBST, German-born empress of Russia (1762-96), who led her country into full participation in the political and cultural life of Europe, carrying on the work begun by Peter the Great. With her ministers she reorganized the administration and law of the Russian Empire and extended Russian territory, adding the Crimea and much of Poland....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
2383 words (6.8 pages)