Comparision of 'Stopping By Woods On A Snowy Evening' and 'The Chalk Pit'

Comparision of 'Stopping By Woods On A Snowy Evening' and 'The Chalk Pit'

Length: 914 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The poems 'Stopping By Woods On A Snowy Evening' by Robert Frost and 'The Chalk Pit' by Edward Thomas both convey a sense of place in their meaning. 'Stopping By Woods On A Snowy Evening' is about how the narrator stops outside the snow-filled woods to admire the scenery along with his horse. The narrator does not stay for long as he has 'promises to keep'.
'The Chalk Pit' involves the conversation of two people about a chalk pit nearby. Speaker A adds a lot of imagination to the conversation while Speaker B is more plainspoken and mundane.

The theme of the two poems is of nature and place. In 'Stopping By Woods On A Snowy Evening' the narrator is captivated by the scenery of the woods in Winter time. The conveys an image of beauty to the reader. In 'The Chalk Pit' the speakers discuss the chalk pit. Speaker A finds the place to be filled with wonders where as speaker B finds the place to be an ordinary chalk pit that is overgrown with weeds.

'Stopping By Woods On A Snowy Evening' is made up of four quatrains and is in the form iambic tetrameter. The rhyme scheme is AABA BBCB CCDC DDDD. This is a clever rhyme scheme and the repetition of the penultimate line illustrates that the poem is ending and the narrator is leaving the snowy landscape that he was drawn to on his travels.
Where as, 'The Chalk Pit' is made up of one stanza and is in the form iambic pentameter. There is no noticeable rhyme scheme. Having only one stanza keeps the conversation between the two speakers flowing which conveys a more natural image of the place to the reader.

The tone of 'Stopping By Woods On A Snowy Evening' is rather light and smooth in the first three stanzas and the rhyme scheme makes it flow pleasantly. In the fourth stanza the ton...

... middle of paper ...

... and then suddenly everything stops. For example, 'the drop of an axe and the smack' and 'a silent place that once rang loud'. The first speaker in the poem is more deeper and imaginative than the second speaker, for example when speaker A says, 'as if just before It was not empty, silent, still, but full of life of some kind, perhaps tragical.' The second speaker is more down-to-earth and certain, for example when speaker B says, 'Not that I know of. It is called the Dell.' This conveys two different images of the place to the reader, an imaginative one and a realistic one. Speaker B's reaction to Speaker A conveys to the reader that Speaker A is too pensive and thinks in to things too much. Speaker A's reaction to Speaker B conveys to the reader that Speaker A wants to keep his imaginations alive and that he doesn't want to know the truth surrounding the chalk-pit.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Nature of Place in ‘The Chalk Pit’ by Edward Thomas and ‘The Woodpile’ by Robert Frost

- ‘The Chalk Pit’ by Edward Thomas and ‘The Woodpile’ by Robert Frost are both about being transported to a specific place and these places have an effect on the speaker(s). The setting of ‘The Chalk Pit’ is most likely at the foot of Wheatham Hill in Hampshire and nearby is an abandoned chalk mine. ‘The Woodpile’ is set in a frozen swamp/wood in wintertime. Both of the poems have similar settings and this verifies the fact that Frost and Thomas were both very similar people, both in poetry and in real life....   [tags: Chalk Pit, place, Edward Thomas, Woodpile, Robert ]

Better Essays
2121 words (6.1 pages)

Essay about The Magic Chalk, by Abe Kobo

- Magic, as defined by Merriam-Webster, is a power that allows people to do impossible things by saying special words and performing special actions. When looking at the context of this definition, one can then define the term magical realism. Magical Realism is defined as a literary genre in which the author creates two conflicting positions, one rooted in logic and the other rooted in mysticism. In Kobo Abe’s short story, The Magic Chalk, Abe effectively creates a binary between the creator and the creation through the narrative style of magical realism and through the narrative techniques of characterization, irony, and symbolism where the protagonist alters the world to become his own crea...   [tags: Kobo Abe, The Magic Chalk]

Better Essays
1087 words (3.1 pages)

Essay The Caucasian Chalk Circle

- There were many different options to choose from for this essay, and I chose to attend the play,The Caucasian Chalk Circle. It was a great experience to have seen a play like this. There are many different aspects of a play that have to work together to have a successful overall outlook. A few major aspects that contribute to the overall outlook are; the quality of the acting, if the plot is enjoyable, how the characters present themselves and how the lighting ties in with the mood....   [tags: Caucasian Chalk Circle Essays]

Better Essays
1337 words (3.8 pages)

Euthanizing Pit Bulls Essay

- The of Euthanizing Pit Bulls Americans have been debating the morality of euthanizing animals for decades, including an impassioned argument about the quickness to kill the Pit Bull breed. Advocates that support euthanization of pit bulls use their aggression and danger to justify the killings. The perception of danger is not based in reality, but rather comes from media exposure. Most pit bulls do not exhibit aggressive behavior and those that do are trained to do so by irresponsible owners....   [tags: Pit Bull, American Pit Bull Terrier]

Better Essays
1028 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on My School Activity: Chalk the Block

- ... I turned and there they were; both of my partners staring flabbergasted at my work, not making a single move to collaborate. I wondered how long they had been there, just staring blankly at my working hands. After a few seconds of frowning at their clueless faces, I stood up, gathered a couple pieces of chalk, and handed each a chunk. The original design on paper was resting right in the middle of the tile, so they got to work. I kept my focus on the specific segment of the painting I had already started, oblivious to what the other girls were doing until I finished my part and looked at the rest....   [tags: chalk painiting on concrete tiles]

Better Essays
576 words (1.6 pages)

Persuasive Speech : Pit Bulls

- ... Don’t get me wrong I have always been terrified of pit bulls because of all the negative press about pit bulls. I would always hear about a pit bull attacking someone or something. I would watch a show called “Good dogs gone bad.” I never heard anything positive. If wasn’t for my dad getting Jack 2 years ago I would still have a negative perspective. IV. My rival makes numerous definite opinions about pit bulls. Today I will address the myths about pit bulls and how loving and caring they are....   [tags: American Pit Bull Terrier, Pit Bull]

Better Essays
865 words (2.5 pages)

Essay The Problem With Pit Bulls

- ... The research states that Pit bulls make up 6% of the dog population, however they were responsible for 68% of the attacks and 52% of the dog- related deaths since 1982. Charlotte also found that Merritt’s job is to log fatal attacks and disfigure the attacks as well. According to Charlotte and Merritt, the CDC has confirmed that the Pit Bull breed is responsible for more dog-related deaths than any other breed. Charlotte states that Pit bull attacks are becoming more common and they are receiving more attention on social media more than ever....   [tags: Pit Bull, American Pit Bull Terrier]

Better Essays
724 words (2.1 pages)

The Pit Bulls Are Dangerous Essay

- ... Since the build of a pit bull is much stronger than any other dog as previously stated, one may think that their bite would cause more damage or harm to a human or another animal. As a result of this many doctors and scientists are examining the jaw of a pit more closely, to see if what everyone is talking about appears to be true. According to those from the ASPCA the only reason pit bulls seem to have such a strong bite may be due to the fact that they come from a hunting and more aggressive ancestry....   [tags: Pit Bull, American Pit Bull Terrier]

Better Essays
717 words (2 pages)

The Pit and the Pendulum Essay

- The Pit and the Pendulum "The place where you die is where you become young again." The accused in "The Pit and the Pendulum" is obviously being persecuted. For what religion or practice we do not know. For what crime it is not said. The prisoner does not even question his guilt or innocence. The accused in this story, to whom Poe does not give a name, is subjected to three life threatening situations. Poe, along with other English Romantics believed that being born was actually coming to the end of another existence....   [tags: Pit and the Pendulum Essays]

Free Essays
698 words (2 pages)

Contrasts in Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening Essay

- Contrasts in 'Stopping by Woods' The duality of the narrator's response to the woods is caught in the contrast between the relaxed, conversational idiom of the first three lines (note the gentle emphasis given to ‘think', the briskly colloquial ‘though') and the dream-like descriptive detail and hypnotic verbal music ('watch . . . woods', 'his . . . fill . . . with') of the last. Clearing and wilderness, law and freedom, civilization and nature, fact and dream: these oppositions reverberate throughout the poem....   [tags: Stopping Woods Snowy Evening]

Free Essays
667 words (1.9 pages)