Comparing Three Nathaniel Hawthorne Stories

Comparing Three Nathaniel Hawthorne Stories

Length: 854 words (2.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Nathaniel Hawthorns short stories, such as, Dr. Heidegger’s Experiment, Rappaccini’s Daughter and The Birthmark all have an underlying meaning and demonstrate a similar recurring theme. Hawthorne uses his stories to clarify his beliefs on the competition between nature, religion, and science in everyday life. In all three of his short stories he refuses the concept of science coming before religion or nature. Hawthorne clearly thought if nature or religion was tampered with using science it could only end badly, but more specifically with death. In each of his stories there is a scientific experiment that defies both nature and religion ending harmfully. Nathaniel Hawthorne’s beliefs conclude that God and nature to ultimately be more powerful then science.
In Dr. Heidegger’s Experiment, Nathaniel Hawthorne creates a fictional experiment that resists both God and natures intentions. Dr. Heidegger gathers a few old acquaintances who seem to be unhappy with their lives and they all wish to be young again. They also hope having their wisdom from over the years, will allow them not to make the same mistakes that resulted in their unhappiness. Since they were so desperate, they joined a unpromising experiment, which turned out to be an illusion. Once the old friends started hallucinating their youth, they began to act out as they would have a decade prior. As well as forgetting all of their insight, as the narrator explains, “The fresh gloss of the soul, so early lost, and without which the worlds successive scenes had been but a gallery of faded pictures, again threw its enchantment over all prospects”(6). Clearly god did not intend the experiment subjects to be given a second chance and painfully strips them of their young age once again, “The delirium which it created had effervesced away. Yes! they were old again. With a shuddering impulse, that showed her a woman still, the widow clasped her skinny hands before her face, and wished that the coffin-lid were over it, since it could be no longer beautiful”(8). The fatal outcome in this story was the hope the old people once had in science. Therefore proving science is incapable of defying God’s power.
In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s, The Birthmark, he uses unperfected beauty to confirm that if God’s creations are meddled with the product is harmful. A scientist, Alymer is married to a beautiful women named Georgiana whose only flaw is a birthmark on her left cheek.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Comparing Three Nathaniel Hawthorne Stories." 19 Feb 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Analysis Of Nathaniel Hawthorne 's `` Young Goodman Brown `` And `` Masque Of The Red Death ``

- Accepting Sin The popularity of modern dystopian stories is rooted in its dark themes and settings, but this interest goes back to the early stages of American Literature. Two of the most well-known American authors, Nathaniel Hawthorne and Edgar Allan Poe, delved into the sinfulness of human nature and presence of evil in mortal lives through symbolic journeys of their characters. In the short story “Young Goodman Brown”, Nathaniel Hawthorne’s main protagonist, Goodman Brown, takes a journey through a forest with a mysterious man, who shows him the sinful nature of his townspeople....   [tags: Young Goodman Brown, Nathaniel Hawthorne]

Research Papers
1898 words (5.4 pages)

The Hawthorne 's The Scarlet Letter Essay

- The forest is generally sought out as a place where no good happens in many stories such as Things Fall Apart, by Chinua Achebe. It is no different in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter. It is where many mysterious things reside in the wilderness. The town in the book can contrast the forest as a sanction where people are are immune from the darkness. They differ, but they also aid in conveying the bigger themes of the story. Some people might see the forest as a “happy place” for Hester and Pearl, but it should really be looked upon as a place of sin when comparing it to its foil, the town, which in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter contrasts to aid in the themes of the nature...   [tags: Nathaniel Hawthorne, The Scarlet Letter]

Research Papers
837 words (2.4 pages)

Greasy Lake by T. C. Boyle and Young Goodman Brown, by Nathaniel Hawthorne

- How “bad” can one be when put in a seriously “bad” situation. “Greasy Lake,” written by T. Coraghessan Boyle, depicts some rebellious characters getting into situations that are too rebellious for them to handle. These various situations, as well as the characters themselves, tell the reader something more than what is actually happening in the story. This makes “Greasy Lake” an allegory, because it can be read at a literal level, but interpreted on a second, more meaningful level. The story of “Young Goodman Brown,” written by Nathaniel Hawthorne, can be considered an older parallel to “Greasy Lake.” The main character, an adventurous young man, sets out to do an evil deed and finds himself...   [tags: Comparing Two Allegories]

Research Papers
1926 words (5.5 pages)

Essay on The Cathedral, By Raymond Carver And Nathanial Hawthorn

- ... The husband shares that the blind man is staying with him and his wife and and that he is not looking forward to it. “A blind man in my house was not something I looked forward to”, this shows that the husband was already uncomfortable with the man because he was blind, he hadn’t even met him yet and he was showing some sort of discomfort with this man (32). Another perfect example of this is when the husband is left alone with the blind man when his wife goes up stairs. While sitting down around the television the husband begins to feel uncomfortable with being alone with the blind man, according to the husband “I didn’t want to be left alone with the blind man” (38)....   [tags: Nathaniel Hawthorne, Short story]

Research Papers
1208 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about Poe versus Hawthorne, Comparing Writers

- There have always been comparisons ranging from players, books, and etc... One comparison spoken about by sports reporters is between Michael Jordan and Kobe Bryant and who was the best in their prime. Many reporters say Jordan because he was clutch and was the most competitive athlete they have ever seen. Other reporters say Kobe because he has a better jump shot than Jordan at his age and has to play along another superstar. Jordan never had to go through what Kobe is going through right now....   [tags: Literature Edgar Allen Poe Nathaniel Hawthorne]

Research Papers
1812 words (5.2 pages)

Allegory, Symbolism, and Madness – Comparing the Demons of Edgar Allan Poe and Nathaniel Hawthorne

- Allegory, Symbolism, and Madness – Comparing the Demons of Edgar Allan Poe and Nathaniel Hawthorne As contemporaries of each other, Edgar Allan Poe and Nathaniel Hawthorne endeavored to write about man’s dark side, the supernatural influence, and moral truths. Each writer saw man as the center-point in his stories; Poe sees man’s internal struggle as madness, while Hawthorne sees man as having a “secret sin.” Each had their reasons for writing in the Gothic format. Poe was not a religious man; he was well educated and favored reading the German Gothic literature, which would become the basis for his own writing....   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Research Papers
3827 words (10.9 pages)

Young Goodman Brown and The Fall of the House of Usher Essay

- While reading “Young Goodman Brown” by Nathaniel Hawthorne, I couldn’t help but feel a constant overwhelming sense of dread. The root of this could have come from the story’s dark setting deep within an “haunted forest” or from Brown’s mysterious “Devil”-esque companion. While I read, another story came into my mind; the story of the “Fall of the House of Usher” by Edgar Allan Poe. In Poe’s tale the same heart pounding emotion can be felt as he describes the reunion of two friends within “the House of Usher.” With the manors “eye-like windows” and “sorrowful impression,” Poe wastes no time in setting the Gothic mood....   [tags: Comparing Literature, Nathaniel Hawthorn]

Research Papers
980 words (2.8 pages)

Nature in Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Birth-Mark and Wilfred Owens" Disabled

- ... Both of the stories use nature to make a valid point. Nathaniel Hawthorne uses nature to talk about his wife’s birth-mark. Aylmer thinks his wife birth-mark is interrupting the nature of man. Similar to the poem Disabled, the poet believes that war interrupts nature. For example, when people think of the sun, the sun helps facilitates man’s growth. The sun is a force that guides the universe. The poet believes that war disrupts nature's concern with life and death. Nature needs to take its course in the world....   [tags: Concern, Birthmark, Perfection]

Research Papers
1431 words (4.1 pages)

Essay about Comparing History for Hawthorne and Brent

- Understanding History for Hawthorne and Brent Knowing and understanding social, political, and cultural history is extremely important when reading many novels, especially Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl by Linda Brent and any short story written by Nathaniel Hawthorne. Both of these authors had many extinuating circumstances surrounding their writings that should be noted before reading their works. Without knowing what was happening both in the outside world and in the respected author's life, one cannot truly grasp what the author is trying to say or what the author truly means by what he or she is saying....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
1490 words (4.3 pages)

Essay Comparing Hawthorne's and Melville's Works

- Similarities in Hawthorne's and Melville's Works Insanity can be a dark descent into the strange, nightmarish unknown realms of the mind unable to return to the known world of reason. This is a major theme in literature, and is particularly evident in the works of Nathaniel Hawthorne and Herman Melville. The nightmarish undertones are one of the main similarities in Hawthorne's and Melville's works. Another similarity is writing style. Both men write very descriptively, and their writing is based more in intellect than emotion....   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Research Papers
918 words (2.6 pages)

Alymer challenges God and attempts to make his wife the single most perfect being. Alymer says to his wife, “There is no taint of imperfection on thy spirit. Thy sensible frame, too, shall soon be all perfect”(22). When the birthmark is removed it is known that Georgiana is dead because of it, “The fatal hand had grappled with the mystery of life, and was the bond by which an angelic spirit kept itself in union with a mortal frame”(23). Alymer learns that God’s creations cannot be interfered with or else it may be deadly.
In Rappaccini’s Daughter, Nathaniel Hawthorne introduces a scientist who’s only concern in life is science. Rappaccinis daughter, Beatrice unfortunately has no choice but to live her life also conquered by a lethal science that ultimately ends in her death. Rappaccini ignorantly rationalizes his reason for experimenting on his daughter and the plants in his garden by saying, “What do you mean, foolish girl? Dost thou deem it misery to be endowed with marvelous gifts against which no power nor strength could avail an enemy, --misery, to be as terrible as thou art beautiful? Wouldst thou, then, have preferred the condition of a weak woman, exposed to all evil and capable of none?”(59). This quote shows that Rappiccini is blinded by science and can not see the heartache his daughter is feeling because of his obsession. One could say science made him a bad father by destroying Beatrice’s future. Beatrice drinks a supposed antidote obtained by science which kills only her and not Giovanni, as shown in this quote, “To Beatrice, --so radically had her early part been wrought upon by Rappaccini’s skill, --as poison had been life, so the powerful antidote was death; and thus the poor victim of man’s ingenuity and of thwarted nature, and of the fatality that attends all such efforts of perverted wisdom, perished there, at the feet of her father and Giovanni”(59). Rappiccinis addiction to science resulted in his own daughters fatality. This story proves that Nathaniel Hawthorne believed if nature is messed with then it becomes corrupt and deadly.
Nathaniel Hawthorne’s three short stories, Dr. Heidegger's Experiment, The Birthmark, and Rappaccini's Daughter all reveal his strong belief in God’s will or the simplicity of mother nature. He represents science with a mad scientist and a lethal end product showing how unnatural and dangerous science can become. Hawthorne also allows the reader to see the tragedy behind science and its abnormality. Each of his stories have a different plot but they all prove the same point, science should not intervene with Gods plan.
Return to