Comparing the Democratic Progress in Taiwan and Hong Kong Essay

Comparing the Democratic Progress in Taiwan and Hong Kong Essay

Length: 1436 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Internal factors: The political system and the public involvement
Progress of development of the political system
The different progress of development of the democratic system in Taiwan and Hong Kong can be attributed to their internal and unique political structure and role of political parties.
First of all, it should be noted that there are fundamental differences in the design of government structures in Taiwan and Hong Kong. In Taiwan, as long as the boss of the party won the presidential election, he or she will be granted the legitimacy to rule the country, no matter the KMT, DPP or any party he or she comes from. Also, the president was elected by representatives of the National Assembly indirectly. He or she would be responsible for organizing the government. Thus, in the National Assembly, the power to rule the country rested on the political party who controls the majority seats. In contrast, the political system of Hong Kong was highly deviated from Taiwan. In Hong Kong, before 1997 it was the British who appointed the Governor to maneuver the administrative power, but after the handover the Chief Executive was elected by 400 people who are eligible to being in the Election Committee (Kwok, 2003). The British or the Chinese government had never intended to share the power to the local government which was made up by election. Even though direct elections had been introduced by the British government in 1991, administrative power was still strictly held in the hands of the Hong Kong government and the essence of the governance simply did not changed (Kwok, 2003). This can be reflected by the existence of opposition parties and the inability of them to get the ruling power despite they could reach a simple majority in ...

... middle of paper ...

Hu, C. F. (2005). Taiwan’s Geopolitics and Chiang Ching-Kuo’s Decision to
Democratize Taiwan. Standford Journal of East Asian Affairs, 5(1), 26-44.
Kwok, K. K. (2003). A Comparative Study of Democratization of Taiwan and Hong
Kong (Doctoral dissertation, University of Hong Kong).
Lee, T. H. (1999). The Road to Democracy: Taiwan’s Pursuit of Identity. PHP
Institute, Tokyo.
Martin, M. F. (2012). Prospects for Democracy in Hong Kong: Results of the 2012
Elections. CRS Report for Congress. Retreieved from Congressional Research Service.
Wong, K. Y. (2004). More balancing than Bandwagoning: Hong Kong and Taiwan’s
Responses to the Mainland China Factor in Electoral Politics. Twenty First Century Review, 81, 20-25. Retrieved from the Chinese University of Hong Kong. Institute of Chinese Studies.
Yahuda, M.(1996). Hong Kong: China’s Challenge. Routledge, London.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Copyright in Taiwan

- Copyright in Taiwan Introduction The economic structure of Taiwan has been undergoing rapid changes in the recent thirty years. Taiwan has moved offshore from a labor-intensive industrialized country to an export-oriented economy. With the concentration of capital and technology, and the rapid diversification of hi-tech professional services, the structure of Taiwan industries has also changed greatly since late 1970s. The total annual production value accounted for by technology intensive industries has increased from 60 percent in mid 1980s to 75 percent in mid 1990s....   [tags: Taiwan Copyright Essays]

Free Essays
3045 words (8.7 pages)

Essay on The Issue Of Censorship Of Hong Kong

- The issue that I have been following is the issue of censorship in Hong Kong. China has always had very strict censorship laws but recently with the Chinese government taking more control over Hong Kong, the typically lenient Hong Kong censorship laws have been becoming stricter and the Hong Kong public is not reacting well to it. The recent democracy riots in Hong Kong have been partially sparked by this major issue that does not seem to be getting any better anytime soon. Since October, Hong Kong has seen more requests to have things taken off the web than they have in the past four years combined....   [tags: China, Hong Kong, Mainland China]

Powerful Essays
778 words (2.2 pages)

The Health Association Of Hong Kong Essay

- ... 1. Care and acceptance from others: Care from others is crucial for people with ID, and others should treat them normally too. Personal performance is useful to them, as they can build up their confidence through self-actualization. Moreover, friends and social life are also essential in their lives. Apart from friends, general public needs to show their care and acceptance towards people with ID too, they can increase the understanding towards them by attending events hosted by us, which will probably make them show more care and acceptance towards people with ID....   [tags: Special education, Disability, Hong Kong]

Powerful Essays
1619 words (4.6 pages)

Balancing Democracy and Reality in Hong Kong Essay

- Since the handover of Hong Kong from being a British colony back to a special administrative region of China in 1997, it has suffered from a series of political turmoil in which the executive found great difficulties in exerting public support on its rule while failing to build a cooperative relationship with the legislature. The existing political system is criticised greatly by the society for its outdated design that fails to cope with the rising demand from the public and to achieve any constructive progress in political development in Hong Kong....   [tags: Hong Kong Politics]

Powerful Essays
2715 words (7.8 pages)

Essay on The Causes and Future of Taiwan and Hong Kong's FDI in Mainland China

- ... The building industrial parks, and other transfers of economic development experience, have showed the Mainland Chinese a viable model for economic development and technological advancement, which have significantly contributed to China’s unprecedented economic growth. Another way in which China specifically tried to attract engagement with Taiwan, Hong Kong and other ethnically Chinese regions was through the creation of Special Economic Zones (SEZ). SEZs helped facilitate economic investment and FDI from Taiwan, Hong Kong and overseas regions with ethnic Chinese minorities....   [tags: foreign direct investment, global finance]

Powerful Essays
858 words (2.5 pages)

Racial Foreign Employment in Taiwan Essays

- Taiwan’s economy is speedy growing for 50 years; it has a constant price and divides the fairness of income. The industrial development has been growing speedy between 1980 and 2000, and got the credit as one of the “tiger” economics of Asia (Ubarra 553). In current years, industrial growth obliges more foreign workers. There were 465 thousand foreign workers in Taiwan in 2013; the most population was from Indonesia, which had more than 200 thousand people and another was from Thailand with 62,500 people (Xin 1)....   [tags: taiwan, foreign workers, job discrimination]

Powerful Essays
860 words (2.5 pages)

Taiwan Overview Essay

- Taiwan Overview Taiwan is a small island country located east of China. It is also commonly known as the Republic of China, Taiwan is best known for overthrowing communist Chinese rule and becoming an independent, democratic country. While many Americans do not possess much knowledge about his island, its history and other facts can be truly interesting. The modern history of Taiwan begins in the last decade of the 16th century when a Portuguese ship passed the island and the crew dubbed the island "Ilha Formosa" which translates into "beautiful island"....   [tags: History Anthropology Taiwan]

Powerful Essays
1498 words (4.3 pages)

Essay about Taiwan: The Silicon Island Society

- Taiwan: The Silicon Island Society Silicon Island is a nickname given to the island of Taiwan because of its technological hub located in the city of Hsinchu, which is a near replica of Silicon Valley in California. Hsinchu is located on the Northwest coast of the island and is bordered by mountains and the ocean. The city has a population of 370,000, which is made up of various ethnicities ( Hsinchu is comprised of indigenous Taiwanese, Southern Fujianese (Chinese), Hakka immigrants, Japanese and a few Dutch and Spanish immigrants....   [tags: Technology Industry Taiwan]

Powerful Essays
2203 words (6.3 pages)

Taiwan Perspective Essay

- Taiwan Perspective As United States policy states we support the "one China" idea but we will defend Taiwan if mainland China begins to attack. Thereby putting us at war with China. Taiwan would then be a free state, assuming we control and win the war, but at what cost to America. And for how long. Taiwan's future should be dependent upon Taiwan. Taipei possesses a huge financial reserve; Washington should help the island spend it by selling them the arms they need to properly defend itself from an invasion or attack by China....   [tags: Foreign Policy, Politics]

Free Essays
319 words (0.9 pages)

Essay on Taiwan

- Taiwan is an island located about 100 miles from China. It was originally part of China. But in 1949, the communists seized Mainland China forcing the nationalists to retreat to Taiwan. From then on, Taiwan is also known as Free China. The leaders of Republic of China, (Free China) hoped someday that the communists will be driven out of China. Therefore, they start to build Taiwan as a military base for such purpose. However, their dreams were never accomplished, instead, their efforts turned Taiwan into a economic powerful country....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1707 words (4.9 pages)