Comparing The Book Cathedral By Raymond Carver And The Bastard Out Of Carolina

Comparing The Book Cathedral By Raymond Carver And The Bastard Out Of Carolina

Length: 1560 words (4.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


The book Cathedral by Raymond Carver and The Bastard Out of Carolina by Dorothy Allison have many similarities that make them unique because of the individuals living in similar homes with similar problems. Raymond and Dorothy both wrote about individuals either having a tough time or a good time, but soon turning to tragedy. These books speak a lot about the individual and how they overcome the problem that is set before them and how their house either helps them in their problem or not. It also shows which character the male or female is more determined to keep the relationship alive and burning.
In Cathedral, the individual either man or woman always has a problem set in front them and it always seems to be about the man and it also takes place in a home. The men in Carver 's stories have the most problems it seems like because he always wrote about men being alcoholics or getting laid off work. The women in is his stories played the part of the good wife until a problem occurred that happened to their husbands. The relationship always started well, but soon a situation arises and crushes something that was good into nothing anymore. Some examples of this comes from his short stories Chef 's House and Preservation. In Chef 's House the man, Wes, is a recovering alcoholic who is living in a house owned by a recovered alcoholic, Chef. Wes and his wife, Edna, are divorced and his kids have grown up and moved away. The woman in this story, Edna, left him 2 years ago and now is moving back in with him helping him recover. Chef the owner of the house comes one day and tells Wes that he needs to move out. The house is a key element for Wes to keep his relationship with Edna alive. Also Edna is the person trying to keep Wes ...


... middle of paper ...


...onomy was not good. They made the readers have to keep reading to see if there was ever a solution to the problem or just left them wondering what will happen. They used homes that were good, but soon turned to not being good. It is seen in both books where the home is where the individual loses it all or reclaims everything he or she has lost. Both authors showed how much the individual can take before he or she succumbs to hopelessness. Also in both books we see the men give up while the women take over and try to fix things. The women have the most significance in both books because they are the ones keeping the relationship alive while the men stay stuck in their rut and let everything fall into despair. Raymond Carver and Dorothy Allison wrote remarkable stories that have intrigued the reader to see if they can find any hope for the characters in their stories.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparing The Books Cathedral By Raymond Carver And The Bastard Out Of Carolina

- The books Cathedral by Raymond Carver and The Bastard Out of Carolina by Dorothy Allison have many similarities that make them unique because of the individuals living in similar homes with similar problems. Raymond and Dorothy both wrote about individuals either having a tough time or a good time, but soon turning to tragedy. These books speak a lot about the individual and how they overcome the problem that is set before them and how their house either helps them in their problem or not. It also shows which character the male or female is more determined to keep the relationship alive and burning....   [tags: English-language films, Short story, Woman]

Better Essays
1490 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on Love in Allison's Bastard Out of Carolina

- Love in Allison's Bastard Out of Carolina "Love" is a word, a signifier, tied to many meanings, all different in context, cultures, and ideologies. Love is used numerous ways in Allison's Bastard Out of Carolina, by many characters. In the character of Bone, love is a confused thing, always changing, as Bone uses it to fit her life on the fly. In relation to parental love, Bone wants Daddy Glen to love her. However, early in the book, Bone's conception of "love" is that of a child, obviously....   [tags: Bastard Out of Carolina Essays]

Free Essays
653 words (1.9 pages)

Bastard Out Of Carolina Essay

- Bastard Out Of Carolina “Pay Attention to Detail” ========================= One must consider a little history on Dorothy Allison in order to see how the directions that she takes the novel add up. When she was 24, Allison lived in a lesbian-feminist collective. The women there gave her the confidence she needed and the ability to see the value in her own writing (Amazon.com). During this time, she also found someone who seemed normal, yet she had experienced the same “incest” (Megan 74). This discovery removed some of her separation that she believed her abuse created between her and the world (Amazon 74)....   [tags: English Literature]

Better Essays
1801 words (5.1 pages)

The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian and Bastard out of Carolina

- The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian by Sherman Alexie and Bastard out of Carolina by Dorothy Allison, tell stories about troubled adolescents and their desire to live a life more meaningful than the one society had predetermined for them. On the surface, Junior and Bone seem very different but when they are analyzed through the themes of discrimination, poverty, and friendship, these two protagonists become reflections of each other. This paper will compare the struggles faced by the characters and the effects of social inequality on their lives....   [tags: Sherman Alexie, Dorothy Allison]

Better Essays
1532 words (4.4 pages)

Bastard Out of Carolina Essay

- One of the most complex and elaborate characters in Bastard Out of Carolina by Dorothy Allison is Bone. Throughout the story Bone has to live a life where she thinks that she is the leading mystery of the trouble being caused. She has numerous unhappy situations and is in no way self-satisfied with herself. She doesn’t appreciate who she is physically. She constantly thinks she is the most homely and dull person who causes the most inconvenience in the family. This sense of selflessness is mainly due to the physical and sexual abuse brought upon by Daddy Glen, Bone’s stepfather....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
1212 words (3.5 pages)

Child Abuse and it's Role in Bastard Out of Carolina by Dorothy Allison Essay

- While reading the semi-autobiographical, Bastard Out of Carolina, by Dorothy Allison, I was stunned by the explicit nature of the novel. We were introduced to a young narrator and protagonist named, Ruth Anne “Bone” Boatwright. Bone's family, like that of the author, experienced a impoverished life, all the while she tried to find her place in a society that had literally labeled her “illegitimate.” Merriam-Webster defines illegitimate as being: (1) not recognized as lawful offspring; specifically: born of parents not married to each other (2) not rightly deduced or inferred- illogical (3) departing for the regular- erratic (4) not sanctioned by law- illegal (5) not authorized by good usag...   [tags: sexual abuse, glen waddell, depression]

Better Essays
1530 words (4.4 pages)

The Bastard Of Istanbul Essay

- The Bastard Of Istanbul is, at heart, a story about coming to terms with one's identity. Almost all of the characters in this book face an identity crisis of some sort. This can be specifically followed by exploring the connection between the idea of the character's identity and their actual, concrete name. Some characters hide behind pseudonyms, while others have multiple names. The theme of names as a reflection of a character's identity is prevalent throughout the book. Characters in both the cybercafe and the physical cafe are only ever known by their pseudonyms....   [tags: Literature Review]

Better Essays
825 words (2.4 pages)

Cathedral by Raymond Carver Essays

- The story of Cathedral, by Raymond Carver, shows that you do not have to see someone or something in order to appreciate them for who or what they are. It is about a husband, the narrator, and his wife who live in a house. The wife, whose name they do not mention, has a very close friend who is blind. His name is Robert. Robert's wife dies, and comes to their house to spend a couple of days with the narrator and his wife. The narrator, whose name they do not mention as well, is always on edge because he does not really know Robert very well and he does not like blind people, but he is being friendly for his wife's sake....   [tags: Cathedral Raymond Carver Book Analysis]

Better Essays
1306 words (3.7 pages)

Cathedral by Raymond Carver Essay

- Cathedral: A Lesson for the Ages Raymond Carver’s short story, “Cathedral,” portrays a story in which many in today’s society can relate. We are introduced from the first sentence of the story to a man that seems to be perturbed and agitated. As readers, we are initially unsure to the reasoning’s behind the man’s discomfort. The man, who seems to be a direct portrayal of Raymond Carver himself, shows his ignorance by stereotyping a blind man by the name of Robert, who has come to stay with he and his wife....   [tags: Raymond Carver]

Better Essays
1102 words (3.1 pages)

Carver's Cathedral Essays

- The narrator, or storyteller, of Raymond Carver's short story "Cathedral" opens by saying, "This blind man, an old friend of my wife's, he was on his way to spend the night." The narrator goes on to explain that after the blind man's wife died while visiting her relatives in nearby Connecticut, he had called the narrator's wife from his in-laws' and made arrangements to visit. The narrator admits he is not excited about the visit. "He was no one I knew. And his being blind bothered me. My idea of blindness came from the movies....   [tags: Raymond Carver]

Free Essays
1903 words (5.4 pages)