Essay about Comparing Seneca 's On Mercy And Machiavelli 's The Prince

Essay about Comparing Seneca 's On Mercy And Machiavelli 's The Prince

Length: 783 words (2.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Advice to Young Leaders Response Paper #4: Machiavelli and Seneca
Seneca’s On Mercy and Machiavelli 's The Prince come written in similar form. Both are advice books from prominent thinkers to individuals who recently came to power at the time. However, despite the parallels in their origin, the books these two philosophers present have vastly different teachings. Machiavelli and Seneca present two deeply divided views of the proper course of leadership, as they disagree on the nature of a great ruler and on the proper methods of ruling.
Machiavelli’s ruler maintains power for themselves, while Seneca’s maintains power for the good of a broader society. The Prince is essentially a handbook on how to maintain power, with the emphasis entirely upon how to achieve this to the greatest benefit for the ruler. To Machiavelli, glory is the ultimate goal for a leader, and maintaining power a means to this end. In Machiavelli’s conception, glory consists of greatness, of longevity of rule, rather than power alone. When writing of Agathocles, an exceptionally cruel ruler, he states, “it cannot be called virtue to kill one’s fellow-citizens, [...] to be treacherous, merciless, and irreligious; power may be gained by acting in such ways, but not glory” (Machiavelli 31). However, Machiavelli does not reject the behavior exhibited by Agathocles or others like him completely, asserting that “it must be understood that a ruler [...] cannot always act in ways that are considered good because in order to maintain power, he is often forced to act treacherously, ruthlessly, or inhumanely, and disregard the precepts of religion” (Machiavelli 62). Thus behavior that would typically be condemned as immoral is condoned by Machiavelli specifically in t...

... middle of paper ...

...avenge slight injuries, but not those that are very severe” (Machiavelli 9). Effective, stable rule requires the crushing of crime and dissent in a Machiavellian world, whereas mercy lessens the need for punishment in the first place in a Senecan conception of the world.
Machiavelli and Seneca advocate for two fundamentally different forms of leadership. The Machiavellian leader is unconstrained by typical morality, prioritizing individual goals over all. In contrast, Seneca casts his eye to the betterment of society through the moral virtue of the leader. They also present very different pathways for effective rule, with Seneca exposing the values of mercy and Machiavelli rejecting this same value wholesale. Ultimately, despite the similar goals of these works, to advise a newly borne ruler, they function as the philosophical opposites of each other in many senses.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Morality: Comparing Hobbes and Machiavelli

- One of the main premises of Leviathan and The Prince is morality. Where morality comes from, how it affects people under a political structure and how human nature contributes or doesn’t to morality. Hobbes and Machiavelli differ widely on each subject. Machiavelli’s views on morality, based upon a literal interpretation of the satire The Prince, is very much a practical and realistic approach to the nature of morality and human nature. Hobbes’ views, based in Leviathan, are of a more idealistic nature, and my views are a little in between the two....   [tags: Hobbes vs Machiavelli]

Better Essays
1216 words (3.5 pages)

Comparing Machiavelli and Hobbes Essay

- Machiavelli and Hobbes To be successful, one must have the appearance of virtuousness, but not necessarily be virtuous. At least, this appears to be true according to Niccolo Machiavelli's works. Machiavelli's idea of the virtuous republican citizen may be compared to Hobbes' idea of a person who properly understands the nature and basis of sovereign political power. Hobbes' ideas seem to suggest that most anyone can claim rightful authority as there is a belief in God, and one can under Hobbes, claim legitimate authority rather easily....   [tags: Machiavelli vs Hobbes]

Free Essays
1482 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on Commentary of The Prince by Niccolo Machiavelli

- In chapter 17 of The Prince, On Cruelty and Mercy, and Whether It Is Better to Be Loved Than to be Feared or the Contrary, Machiavelli continues his discussion of virtues that the modern reader might not consider as virtues. He considers mercy and cruelty as with generosity and ungenerosity. Machiavelli’s dark view of human nature is displayed in this chapter – a warning about those who tell you they love you in good times but desert you in bad times. He talks about how a prince should rather be feared than loved, if he cannot manage to be both loved and feared, but never hated....   [tags: mercy and cruelty]

Better Essays
956 words (2.7 pages)

Comparing Thomas Hobbes and Niccolo Machiavelli Essay

- Thomas Hobbes and Niccolo Machiavelli Two of the greatest philosophers of all time are Thomas Hobbes and Niccolo Machiavelli. Hobbes was born in 1588 in England, when absolutism was taking hold in Europe. His most famous work was 'Leviathan', written in 1651. Hobbes discussed the ideal state and innate laws of man and nature, among other things. Machiavelli was born in Italy in 1469, a time when his home country was ruled mostly by foreign powers. His hometown, Florence, was still independent....   [tags: Compare Contrast Hobbes Machiavelli Essays]

Better Essays
2258 words (6.5 pages)

Comparing Machiavelli's The Prince and Plato's The Republic Essay

- Comparing Machiavelli's The Prince and Plato's The Republic       Many people in history have written about ideal rulers and states and how to maintain them.  Perhaps the most talked about and compared are Machiavelli's, The Prince and Plato's, The Republic.  Machiavelli lived at a time when Italy was suffering from its political destruction.  The Prince, was written to describe the ways by which a leader may gain and maintain power. In Plato?s The Republic, he unravels the definition of justice.  Plato believed that a ruler could not be wholly just unless one was in a society that was also just....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Better Essays
1784 words (5.1 pages)

Niccolo Machiavelli's The Prince and The Discourses Essays

-      Niccolò Machiavelli thoroughly discusses the importance of religion in the formation and maintenance of political authority in his famous works, The Prince and The Discourses. In his writing on religion, he states that religion is beneficiary in the formation of political authority and political leaders must support and endorse religion in order to maintain power. However, Machiavelli also critiques corrupt religious institutions that become involved in politics and in turn, cause corruption in the citizenry and divisions among the state....   [tags: Machiavelli Prince Religion Religious Essays]

Better Essays
2286 words (6.5 pages)

A Man For All Season And Machiavelli's Doctrine: Reiteration Of History Essay

- A Man For All Seasons, a play written by Robert Bolt, in essence is both a moral play and a historical play. Sir Thomas More, a "man of the greatest virtue this kingdom has ever produced" (Dean Swift), is famous for choosing to suffer death rather than swearing to an oath that would counter his principles. Sir More had acquired a high position of Lord Chancellery under the reign of King Henry VIII, but stepped down since he could not do what the king had asked of him since this action would conflict with his beliefs and conscience....   [tags: Machiavelli History]

Better Essays
1869 words (5.3 pages)

Machiavelli's The Prince Essay

- The Prince Niccolo Machiavelli, Italian statesman and author and prominent figure of the Renaissance, was born on May 3rd, 1469. His father was Bernardo di Niccoli, who belonged to an impoverished part of an old Florentine family, and there is little recorded about his youth. It was in the independent city-state of Florence that he began an active career as a politician as a young man, becoming part of important diplomatic missions throughout Europe. He met with some of the most famous figures of his time and all history, such as Pope Alexander IV, and his son Cesare Borgia, as well as King Louis VII of France and Holy Roman Emperor Maximilian I....   [tags: Niccolo Machiavelli]

Better Essays
1404 words (4 pages)

Machiavelli Essay

- Machiavelli Machiavelli was born in Florence, in 1496. His father was a lawyer, and his family lived modestly, but was not rich. Florence in the 15th century was an independent city, owing political allegiance to no one. It was a center of learning and of considerable artistic creativity. In the 15th members of the Medici family ruled it. The Medici family was temporarily expelled from Florence in 1494, and was replaced by a friar named Savonarola who carried on with campaigns against corruption....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1016 words (2.9 pages)

Machiavelli Essay

- Machiavelli Some say that if one completes his/her studies at the University level without analyzing and understanding Machiavelli's work and theories, then that person has not fully utilized the "college experience." Machiavelli, by some, is said to be one of the greatest theorists and philosophers of all time. Most critics argue, '… that he (Machiavelli) is cynical- that he thinks the worst of people rather than the best of them." It is very understandable that one would come to that conclusion after reading just one of Machiavelli's pieces of work....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
857 words (2.4 pages)