Comparing Scientific Theories Essay

Comparing Scientific Theories Essay

Length: 1458 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Carl G. Hempel was of the most influential proponents of what is now regarded as the classic view of explanation in science. In his work, Philosophy of Natural Science, he created the deductive-nomological model which is the following account of scientific explanation, where an explanation is set out as a formalized argument. This is the principle format for works such as Aristotle’s Physica, Ptolemy’s Almagest, Newton’s Principia and Opticks, Franklin’s Electricity, Lavoisie’s Chemistry, and Lyell’s Geology. Thomas Kuhn calls these achievements Paradigms. Through these paradigms normal science developed. In Kuhn’s book, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, he argues that normal science in a way hinders the development of new phenomenon. He says that there must be a change in a paradigm to create a scientific revolution. Throughout this essay I will explain what Hempel’s model consists of and how it relates to Kuhn’s view.
Hepel explains the process of explaining atmospheric pressure by starting from the beginning with Galileo’s interest in the limitations of a simple suction pump. Galileo’s observation was that a simple suction pump, which draws water form a well by means of a piston that can be raised in the pump barrel, will lift water no higher than about 34 feet above the surface of the well. After Galileo’s death, his pupil Torricelli pursued this dilemma. Torricelli argued that the earth is surrounded by a sea of air that exerts pressure on the surface below, and that this pressure upon the surface of the well forces water up the pump barrel when the piston is raised. The maximum length of 34 feet for the water column in the barrel thus reflects simply the total pressure of the atmosphere upon the surface o...

... middle of paper ... four of hearts. When these cards were first exposed briefly they were almost always identified as normal. So the cards were immediately fitted into one of the conceptual categories based on prior experience. However, when the subjects were exposed to the anomalous cards more often however, they began to hesitate. After having become aware of the anomaly it was not uncommon for the subjects to get irritated and distressed. Further increase of exposure resulted in sill more hesitation and confusion until finally most subjects produced the correct identification without hesitation.
There is really no possible way I could contradict Kuhn’s view. I think his ideas are true and could dramatically increase the possibilities of scientists’ ability to create new advances in science. I believe that all scientists should view their work in kuhn’s perspective.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Evaluating Kuhn´s Theory of Scientific Development Essay

- ... Kuhn claims that the new paradigm cannot build on the one that precedes it but can only supplant it. It therefore explains how Einstein's theory of relativity could challenge Newton's concepts of physics, Lavoisier's discovery of oxygen could erase earlier ideas about phlogiston, the imaginary element believed to cause combustion and also Galileo's supposed experiments with wood and lead balls dropped from the Leaning Tower of Pisa could banish the Aristotelian theory that bodies fell at a speed proportional to their weight (Kuhn, 1996)....   [tags: scientific revolution, theoretical anomalis]

Powerful Essays
1534 words (4.4 pages)

Comparing and Contrasting Scientific realism and Phenomenology Essay

- The objective of science is elucidate some sort of “truth” with regard to the world and how it works. But how do we arrive at this concept of “truth”. Epistomology, or the study of the origin, nature and limits to the production of human knowledge, provides a multitude of frameworks from which to work from. These approaches address the creation of knowledge and provide the scientist or observer with a reference from which to test the limits and validity of the knowledge that are created from research....   [tags: knowledge, epistomology, philosophy]

Powerful Essays
953 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Creationism versus Evolutionary Theories

- ... - 1990 B.C., Abraham to the Exile 1990 B.C. - 1450 B.C., The Exile to the Monarchy 1450 B.C. - 1045 B.C., The Unified Monarchy 1045 B.C. - 930 B.C., Israel 930 B.C. - 725 B.C., Judah 725 B.C. - 590 B.C., Exile in Babylon 590 B.C. - 440 B.C., and The Intertestamental Period 440 B.C. - 6-4 B.C. . We say 2014, because that is the time that has elapsed since Jesus Christ was born (Congelliere). Evolution Theory argues that the timeline is shaped in this way: 3.8 billion years of simple cells (prokaryotes), 1 billion years of multicellular life, 500 million years of fish and proto-amphibians, 360 million years of amphibians, 200 million years of mammals, 65 million years since the non-avian d...   [tags: comparing and contrasting, religion vs science]

Powerful Essays
1220 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Comparing and Contrasting Utilitarianism and Kantianism

- ... Good is equated to happiness (satisfaction) and alternatively bad only comes close to sadness (dissatisfaction) and brings no pleasure. Utilitarianism is used to identify the best and satisfactory course of action based on a program that clearly points at the most advantageous channel. Maximized goods consider among others people in the society affected by the chosen course of action in the present circumstance. b) Cost-Benefit Analysis: Utilitarianism breaks down moral law into different quantifiable units that interact to define an ethical decision: Entire pleasure- Entire Pain= Total Utility (Lukas 47)....   [tags: theories on ethics]

Powerful Essays
2126 words (6.1 pages)

Essay about Political Theory versus Scientific Theory

- Political Theory versus Scientific Theory Theory is ubiquitous. Everyone is a theorist. A theory is generally stated to be an idea or belief one has formulated that is to be tested by others. Theory abstracts and generalizes from specific circumstances, and enhances the accessibility of experience. They are often more general and abstract then the facts they attempt to explain, therefore, alluding to more than just facts. Theories are functions of indirection, whereas facts are a matter of direct transcription of their contents....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
876 words (2.5 pages)

Theory of Scientific Development Essay

- Introduction The scientific revolution started in the 16th and 17th century with development of the scientific theories (Hatch, n.d.). These Scientific theories are detailed explanation of some aspect of the natural world, based on knowledge that has been repeatedly duplicated through observation and experimental procedures. The understanding or the attempt to understand the human’s perspective of the world through scientific theories is the birth to the philosophy of science (Okasha, 2002). Several perspectives of scientific theories have been postulated by many on the history and philosophy of science....   [tags: Science, Kuhn]

Powerful Essays
1533 words (4.4 pages)

The Scientific Revolution Essay

- The Scientific Revolution When comparing the views presented by both Aristotle and Copernicus, one must consider the circumstances under which these men lived to understand the differences. The most obvious of these is the time in history. Aristotle came almost 2000 years earlier in the astronomy field. While Copernicus had set out to glorify the great religion of his time, Aristotle's views came 200 years before Christ was even born. Although the book gives the impression nothing of significance in astronomy happened in the time between Aristotle and Copernicus, professional astronomy was a developing institution during that time....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1172 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about Charles Darwin and the Scientific Revolution

- In the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, a new way of thinking resulted from the Scientific Revolution. It was an important time in which many people turned away from the church and looked towards logic and reason for the answers to questions about life, death, and the universe. The Scientific Revolution was the key to new discoveries and it allowed many scientists such as Charles Robert Darwin to continue thinking and striving for the truth as other scientists, such as Galileo and Newton, had done before him....   [tags: Natural Selection, Evolution Essays]

Powerful Essays
1076 words (3.1 pages)

Nursing Theories Essay

- As nurses enter into the practice of nursing, they recognize the importance of using their education to guide their actions within the clinical setting. “Theories are pattern that guide the thinking about, being and doing, of nursing” (Parker, 2006, p.8). Comparing theories allows the core structure of the theories to be brought to light, as well as display the merits of using a particular theory while practicing nursing. The theories of Martha Rogers and Betty Neuman were developed at roughly the same point in time, which means that different theories can arise out of the same general world situation....   [tags: Nursing Essays]

Powerful Essays
1206 words (3.4 pages)

Comparing Piaget and Vygotsky Essay

- Cognition is the process involved in thinking and mental activity, such as attention, memory and problem solving. In this essay on cognitive development I will compare and contrast the theories of Piaget and Vygotsky, who were both influential in forming a more scientific approach to analyzing the cognitive development process of the child active construction of knowledge. (Flanagan 1996 P.72). I will then evaluate the usefulness of these theories in understanding a child's development. Both Piaget and Vygotsky agreed that children's cognitive development took place in stages....   [tags: Theories on Cognitive Development Process]

Free Essays
2169 words (6.2 pages)