Comparing Odysseus And The Odyssey Essay

Comparing Odysseus And The Odyssey Essay

Length: 806 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview





The Odyssey’s protagonist, Odysseus, King of Ithica, husband of Penelope and father of Telemachus was reknown for his craftiness. When Helen is abducted and Menelaus calls upon his allies to honour their oaths and help him to retrieve her. Odysseus tries to avoid going to war by feigning lunacy and starts sowing his fields with salt, as an oracle had prophesied a long-delayed return home for him if he went. However, Palamedes, sent by Menelaus’s brother Agamemnon places his infant son Telemachus in front of his plow. Odysseus, rather than eviscerate his son with rudementary farm equipment, Odysseus reveals his deception and joins the Greeks in their conquest of Troy.
The version of Odysseus in the Illiad is much more flawed and realistic than his role as an archetypal hero in the Odyssey. In the Illiad, Odysseus’s brains are juxtaposed against the mighty brawn of Greek champions like Ajax and Achilles, but Odysseus hubris and selfishness are much more apparent in the Illiad. The story of Odysseus and the Odyssey, the hero and his quest respectively, displays many of the motif’s outlined by Vladmir Propp.
Propp’s first motif, that of extrodinary circumstances surrounding the heroes childhood, is not immediately apparent, but can be applied to a prophetic scene in Book 19 of Homer’s Odyssey. He is named by his maternal grandfather, the legendary thief Autolycus the son of the messenger god Hermes and Chion. Odysseus ' name is derived from the Greek verb odussomai (to cause pain or to bear a grudge against.) Furthermore, Odysseus’s paternal grandfather Arceius has divine parentage that varies from source to source, the son of Cephalus or Zeus and grandson of Aeolus.
Propps’s 2nd, 3rd, 5th and 6th motifs are very apparent i...


... middle of paper ...


...not driven by a hunger for power or lust, but from Odysseus’s desire to get his old life back and to return to the family that he was torn away from. Kalypso offers Odysseus power and immortality which he rejects, instead choosing to leave Ogygia to reclaim his throne and family.
Propp’s 10th motif knowledge through suffering, while present in both Homer’s work and the BBC series, is laid out quite clearly by his great grandfather Aeolus the god of wind in the BBC series. Aelous describes Odysseus as “the first mortal to think, you (Odysseus) know there is always something to be learned from a challenge.” Odysseus’s quick thinking and guile saves his life many times, but his hubris ultimately instigates many of his struggles. However, Odysseus’s ego is not due to an inflated self worth, but from his ability to think on his feet and mentally outmanuever his opponents.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparing and Contrasting the Journeys of Odysseus’ and Telemachus’ in The Odyssey

- Odysseus’ and Telemachus’ journeys or nostos were both very similar and different. They parallel each other in some ways but they are also completely different at other times. Telemachus starts as a younger, less mature boy, and without the presence of his father during his childhood, he becomes a timid, shy and spineless boy who is greatly pampered by his mother. He has even more to achieve, being the son of a world-famous father, and this is a very difficult reputation to live up to. His journey, and after that the killing of the suitors who took advantage of him really show how his journeys and problems throughout the book mature him from being a shy, timid boy into a mature man....   [tags: The Odyssey, compare and contrast]

Better Essays
856 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Homer's Odyssey - Comparing Odysseus and Telemachus

- The Parallel between Odysseus and Telemachos in Odyssey       In Odyssey, Homer creates a parallel between Odysseus and Telemachos, father and son. The two are compared in the poem from every aspect. One parallel was the quest of Telemachos, in correlation with the journey of his father. In this, Odysseus is developed from a childish, passive, and untested boy, to a young man preparing to stand by his father's side. This is directly connected to the voyage of Odysseus, in that they both lead to the same finale, and are both stepping-stones towards wisdom, manhood, and scholarship....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
968 words (2.8 pages)

Comparing Odysseus And Thor ( Film ) Essay

- Throughout history the themes of literature has stayed relatively the same; the situations have been updated to appeal to a modern audience. One common trait in great movies and literature is the presence of a heroic figure. Odysseus can be classified as a hero, because he departed from his home Ithaca the day his son Telemachus was born and leaving his wife Penelope to fight in the Trogon war. Odysseus starts out his journey with six hundred crewmen and twelve ships. Through a series of unfortunate events Odysseus looses all his ships and crewmen....   [tags: Odyssey, Odysseus, Penelope, Hero]

Better Essays
979 words (2.8 pages)

Comparing The Book ' The Odyssey ' Essay

- Journal Book 17 : Argos Compare and Contrast: In the epic novel, The Odyssey, by homer, Odysseus is trying to return back home after 20 years of being away. When he first left, he had a dog named Argos. It was told that if you were around when Odysseus was still home, “‘you would be much surprised to see his speed and strength’”(Homer 215). When Odysseus is disguised as a beggar, and he comes to his palace after a long time, he meets a dog lying there, “Argos it was, the dog of hardy Odysseus, whom long ago, he reared but never used… but towards his master he had not strength to move” (Homer 215)....   [tags: Odyssey, Trojan War, Odysseus, Homer]

Better Essays
1201 words (3.4 pages)

Comparing The Aeneid And Homer 's The Odyssey Essay

- We have read two myths of great heroes this semester, Virgil’s The Aeneid and Homer’s The Odyssey. In both of these tales we get to go along with two great heroes on their journey home and all of the troubles that they face. Although these stories tell us about two great heroes and their journey there are a lot of differences. In this paper I will compare and contrast scenes from both myths and suggest a reason that this borrowing was appropriate for what Vergil was trying to do with his version of the myth....   [tags: Odyssey, Odysseus, Trojan War, Poseidon]

Better Essays
3056 words (8.7 pages)

Comparing Homer And Virgil 's ' The Odyssey ' Essay

- Homer and Virgil were two poets that came from differing societies. Homer, a Greek poet, is most famous for his epic poem The Odyssey. It tells the story of the hero Odysseus’ journey back to back to his homeland of Ithaca after 10 years abroad. He is in a race against time to oust the suitors of his wife Penelope from his court. The Aeneid tells the tale of Aeneas, who is a hero of the Trojan war that is traveling to Italy after the conflict has ended in order to establish a new empire. Aeneas and Odysseus were actually on opposite sides of each other during the Trojan war....   [tags: Odysseus, Odyssey, Roman Empire, Trojan War]

Better Essays
1256 words (3.6 pages)

Comparing Two Heros - Beowulf and Odysseus Essay

- Comparing Two Heros - Beowulf and Odysseus Reading through Beowulf I began to compare it to the last great epic I read, Homer’s Odyssey. While the Odyssey and Beowulf are each examples of both historic and modern ideas of heroism, the acts of Beowulf’s hero seem to fit better within its context. Beowulf exhibits many obvious heroic qualities, such as his strength and confidence in battle. These along with more subtle diplomatic actions serve to define him as both a great warrior and leader. Beowulf shows both wit and patience in his swift retort after Unferth challenges his skill....   [tags: Homer Odyssey Epic Compare Contrast]

Better Essays
622 words (1.8 pages)

Essay about The Iliad And The Odyssey

- Around 850 BC, there was a major discovery when Homer was introduced. Through his poetry, he relinquishes two stories called the Iliad and the Odyssey. Homer narrated a cultural norm where women were idolized and held great power over men in some ways, but were still found as property in their eyes. Homer acquaints us with two characters in each parable. From the Iliad, we receive a character of great beauty who is married to King Menelaus of (place) named Helen. The readers also learn of a diligent ad passionate wife of Odysseus named Penelope....   [tags: Trojan War, Iliad, Odyssey, Odysseus]

Better Essays
921 words (2.6 pages)

William Shakespeare 's The Odyssey Essay examples

- A suitor is defined in Oxford Dictionary as a man who pursues a relationship with a particular woman, with a view to marriage. In the epic novel The Odyssey, there are a number of suitors after the same woman, Penelope. Penelope is the wife of the famous Odyssey, and the mother of Telemachus. Telemachus is not fans of the suitors that remain in his house waiting to see which his mother will chose, her husband who has been gone for twenty years or one of the new suitors in the house. Antinous is suitor that cannot be missed in the house....   [tags: Odyssey, Odysseus, Difference, Marriage]

Better Essays
1019 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of Homer 's ' The Odyssey '

- Violence in The Odyssey Violence in literature may take any form, whether it be natural disaster like and earthquake or a human based disaster like war (Campbell). In Homer’s The Odyssey both types are found… whether it’s Odysseus’s hardships like making it home or dealing with the wrath of the god Poseidon. Every violent scene has its own reasons, some are more reasonable than others. For instance, the gods were angered by the disobedience of the mortals. This is more reasonable than the killing of the Cyclops....   [tags: Odyssey, Odysseus, Trojan War, Penelope]

Better Essays
1470 words (4.2 pages)