Comparing Mill's Representative Government and Locke's Second Treatise Essay

Comparing Mill's Representative Government and Locke's Second Treatise Essay

Length: 1825 words (5.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Even though academic study has frequently engaged with the question as to what form of government is ideal and what should be the goal of the government , there cannot be one absolute answer to this question , not merely because there has been no consensus among the scholarly community but because these questions cannot be detached from the polities which will bear the implications of the answer. Hence , it is pertinent that they must be looked at in a particular context. Mill argues for a representative government where sovereignty is vested in the aggregate of the community while Locke advocates majoritarian rule where legislative is supreme, though he prescribes certain limitations on it, and is coupled with a powerful executive. At the first glance representative government and majoritarian rule might appear to be similar , but after reading their texts it can be certainly be deduced that they did not had the same form of government in mind because it is evident that both envisage different goals of a government and therefore the means to achieve those ends are also different.

Mill, in his consideration on representative government, says that purpose of a good government is two fold. First is that how far the government machinery takes advantage of the existing good faculties of the people (protective goal) and second how to what extent does it contributes to the improvement of those qualities(educative goal). Thus for him it is essential that the government must ‘improve’ the masses and make them active participants in the national discourse. So if a government forces the citizens to be only passive recipients of its actions it is a bad government. On the surface it may seem a very noble idea to pursue but it can also impl...


... middle of paper ...


...ideal , but it is the right form of government for people who have not reached a certain level of development. Locke believes that absolute monarchy is unfit for civil society because property is not safe under it and can be taken at the monarch’s whim. It is strange how Mill only talks in terms of two extreme forms of government representative and despotism , and does not tells a way from moving from despotism to government. However though his model of government is not bereft with defects it does provide some extremely fine framework and is more forward looking than Locke’s model in which the government doesnot aspires any intellectual or political thought but only maintains the status quo.
In conlclusion, Mill’s notions of the government’s paternal role is praiseworthy but if looked at more closely it can create a lot of problems which Mill maybe overlooked.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Locke and Publius: Comparing Their Views on Civil Government

- Throughout history there have been significant debates, theories and agendas set forward as to what the best form of government is. Many of those individuals and groups who have written on the topic have their critics because they offer points that are highly controversial in theory and problematic when put into practice. John Locke and Publius, which is the collective name for Alexander Hamilton, James Madison and John Jay, both published essays with regards to the nature of government and largely championed the notion of democracy....   [tags: Second Treatise on Civil Government]

Powerful Essays
1499 words (4.3 pages)

John Locke's Second Treatise, of Civil Government: Putting Sovereignty Into the Hands of the People

- Locke's "Second Treatise, of Civil Government" has the main idea of putting sovereignty into the hands of the people, and this was one of the main ideas behind the constitution. It plays in very well, the framers built the government around the people, by making it a republic. On the national level all people are represented, and as it is divided down to state, county, city, etc. the people gain more power. Albeit, there are many differing theories of the motives of the founding fathers, from God's hand on their minds to the Burkean conservatives they are....   [tags: Second Treatise of Civil Government]

Powerful Essays
565 words (1.6 pages)

John Locke's Second Treatise on Civil Government Essay examples

- Locke's The Second Treatise of Civil Government: The Significance of Reason The significance of reason is discussed both in John Locke's, The Second Treatise of Civil Government, and in Jean-Jacques Rousseau's, Emile. However, the definitions that both authors give to the word “reason” vary significantly. I will now attempt to compare the different meanings that each man considered to be the accurate definition of reason. John Locke believed that the state “all men are naturally in ... is a state of perfect freedom” (122), a state in which they live “without ......   [tags: Second Treatise on Civil Government]

Powerful Essays
1358 words (3.9 pages)

John Locke's Second Treatise on Civil Government Essays

- Locke's Second Treatise of Government, by far, is his most influential and important piece of writing. In it he set forth his theory of natural law and natural right. He shows that there does exist a rational purpose to government, and one need not rely on "mysticism and mystery." Against anarchy, Locke saw his job as one who must defend government as an institution. Locke's object was to insist not only that the public welfare was the test of good government and the basis for properly imposing obligations on the citizens of a country, but also that the public welfare made government necessary....   [tags: Second Treatise on Civil Government]

Powerful Essays
1183 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on The Second Treatise Of Civil Government

- This theory bears a lot of significance with regard to our political system and the role of government. The American political system was largely founded on the philosophical writings of John Locke. The assumption that much of his political philosophy was founded on, and in turn our governmental system, was that human nature is moral and virtuous. In his book The Second Treatise of Civil Government he speaks of the actions of men saying that “in transgressing the law of nature, the offender declares himself to live by another rule than that of reason and common equity, which is what measure God has set to the actions of men, for their mutual security.” (Locke Sec....   [tags: Political philosophy, Government, Thomas Hobbes]

Powerful Essays
1097 words (3.1 pages)

John Locke and Government's Purpose Essay

- In my high school government class senior year, my teacher made the class recite and repeat the rights that are clearly stated in the first amendment of the Constitution of the United States. “The right of speech, the right of the press, the right to petition, the right to religion, and the right to assemble…” we rattled off the list, then started again. When I stepped out of high school and into the real world, I realized just how grateful I was for the rights that I had and the fact that I had a government that allowed me to live in liberty and observe these rights....   [tags: Second Treatise on Civil Government]

Powerful Essays
905 words (2.6 pages)

Representative Democracy and Compromise Essay

- A representative democracy can be defined as a form of government where the people would elect their leaders who would then have to rule and make laws. This allows laws to be made intelligently by specialists. While the people still get a say in who makes those laws, they have no power to influence them directly. The power is therefore split. The people retain some power while the rest is held among the elected representatives. This form of governance is held by the United Kingdom where representatives such as the Members of Parliament meet in the House of Commons to to discuss and pass laws....   [tags: Government, Representatives, Leaders]

Powerful Essays
1904 words (5.4 pages)

Mill´s Construction on Representative Government Essay

- ... By valuing the passive quality of political participation over its active quality, he underhandedly undermines the practice of democracy; education need not amount to any influence on the exercise of authority. Surreptitiously, Mill claims democratic influence on the exercise of authority is great theoretically, but only theoretically; practical influence on the exercise of authority must be left to the “specially trained and experienced few” of “superior minds.” Mill openly champions representative government – government in which people rule through their representatives – as the best form of government....   [tags: democratic, government, authority, political]

Powerful Essays
1005 words (2.9 pages)

John Locke’s Two Treatises of Government and Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s Social Contract

- The Enlightenment was an astonishing time of transformation in Europe. During this time in the eighteenth century there was a progressive movement that was labeled by its criticism of the normal religious, social, and political perceptions. A number of significant philosophers, with new philosophies, had inspired creativeness and change. These thinkers had many different thoughts and views on people and the way they act, and views on the government. Two well-known and most influential thinkers of this time were the English political philosopher John Locke and the French political philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau....   [tags: Two Treatises of Government]

Powerful Essays
1348 words (3.9 pages)

Comparing Morality in The Prince, Second Treatise of Government, and Utilitarianism

- Comparing Morality in The Prince, Second Treatise of Government, and Utilitarianism Niccolo Machiavelli, John Locke, and John Stuart Mill present three distinct models of government in their works The Prince, Second Treatise of Government, and Utilitarianism. From an examination of these models it is possible to infer their views about human nature and its connection to the purpose of government. A key to comparing these views can be found in an examination of their ideas of morality as an intermediary between government and human nature....   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Powerful Essays
2060 words (5.9 pages)