Comparing Hosanna And Top Girls Essay

Comparing Hosanna And Top Girls Essay

Length: 1489 words (4.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Comparison between Hosanna and Top Girls
In our society most men are likely to obtain higher paying jobs and are able to continue working even after becoming parents, whereas, majority of women obtain lower paying jobs and having to choose between being a parent and having a career. After reading the plays of Top Girls by Caryl Churchill and Hosanna by Michael Tremblay, I discovered that gender played a major role in how men and women are treated in society. The characters in these two plays challenges the gender norms, and therefore, I will argue that women are not treated equally in the workplace; that people who are of the queer community are considered to be inferior and less worthy of being accepted within the public sphere.
In Top Girls, most of women stepped out of the private sphere and went beyond the glass ceiling to obtain positions that are predominantly dominated by men. While, in Hosanna, it depicted men who are struggling with gender identity; who holds positions both within the public and private spheres that are originally held by women. Churchill talked about many women who seemed to be successful both modern and historical. Each of these women shared something in common; they ignored their own femininity and take on masculine roles and succeeded in a male dominated world. Women taking on masculine roles came at a price. For example, Marlene emulated a male’s role in order to be successful by forsaken her role as a mother in order to gain her position as a managing director of an employment agency. She gave up her daughter for adoption to her sister, Joyce, who was a working class woman. Marlene could not be a mother and be successful at the same time, due to society ideologies and expectations of gender r...

... middle of paper ...

...ghts” (58). This statement demonstrated that men are superior to women, and that promotion should have been given to a man and not a woman.
Men and women are created to behave and interact in ways that maintain their gender identities. However, gender should be understood as a social formation. The social dynamics shows that men tend to be more superior to women. They tend to be more competitive, intellectual, and stable while women tend to be more cooperative, sensitive, and inferior to men. In the plays, the men and women overcame many obstacles that leads to the acceptance of their gender identities. Certain masculinities promote the inequalities experience by males and females, and in order to achieve gender equality, they must be address. Although women are just as intelligent as men, they do not have the same rights as men do, and they are inferior to men.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Restaurant Scene in Top Girls

- Restaurant Scene in Top Girls The restaurant scene in Top Girls (TG) revolves around Marlene celebrating her promotion at work, it is purely female gendered, having no male actors present throughout the whole play. The significance of the five guests she has chosen to celebrate with promotes the hard work and sacrifices she has made in order to get where she is. This scene uses women of the past, to highlight struggles of women through the ages, encompassing the theme of women’s experiences and women at work, with motherhood being an important factor for most of them....   [tags: Top Girls Play Theater]

Strong Essays
1616 words (4.6 pages)

Feminism in "Top Girls" and "The Handmaid's Tale" Essay

- Both Top Girls and The Handmaid’s Tale relate to contemporary political issues and feminism. Top Girls was written by Caryl Churchill, a political feminist playwright, as a response to Thatcher’s election as a first female British Prime Minister. Churchill was a British social feminist in opposition to Thatcherism. Top Girls was regarded as a unique play about the challenges working women face in the contemporary business world and society at large. Churchill once wrote: ‘Playwrights don’t give answers, they ask questions’, [6] and I think she is proving it in Top Girls: she brings up many tough questions over the course of the play, including what success is and if women’s progress in the w...   [tags: Feminism]

Strong Essays
1644 words (4.7 pages)

Essay on Top Girls in the Predicament

- ¡°Top Girls¡± in the Predicament From the perspective of society, despite certain conditions it had established for women to move up to the top of their social careers through both the official efforts and the endeavors of women themselves, those British ¡°top girls¡± under the influence of Thatcherism in the late 1970s and early 1980s continued to live in a predicament resulting from the traditional gender bias, which was further enhanced by their fierce reaction towards it. I. Introduction II....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
3406 words (9.7 pages)

Manipulation of Time in "Cloud Nine" and "Top Girls" Essay

- The manipulation of time is important in the Cloud Nine and Top Girls, two plays by Caryl Churchill. In one, she manipulates the passage of time to create a connection between the oppression of women and the oppression of those living in the British colonies. In the other, she puts the present first and the past last, suggesting that the past is more important than Britain would like to admit. Like Patrick Wright, she is questioning the idea of a national identity or heritage that wants to continue class and racial discrimination but give it a different name....   [tags: Literary Analysis]

Strong Essays
2190 words (6.3 pages)

The Reality of World in Araby and Boys and Girls Essay

- Our perception about the world change as we grow up and experience the reality of life. This is the necessary and universal experience that we all must undergo to face the world successfully. The protagonists in James Joyce’s “Araby” and Alice Munro’s “Boys and Girls experience a common initiation of how different the world is, compared to how they would like to see. The reader is given a glance into the lives of two adolescents. The protagonists in both stories are of the growing age and their perceptions about the world change....   [tags: Boys and Girls, Araby Essays]

Strong Essays
1184 words (3.4 pages)

The Importance of Gender in Boys and Girls by Alice Munro Essay example

- The Importance of Gender in Boys and Girls   Since the beginning of time, gender roles have existed in society.  Women were assigned the tasks of child-care and food preparation.  Men performed most activities that required physical strength.  As society progressed, the role of women did not.  Although less emphasis is placed on gender roles today, gender roles still exist. In 1968, Alice Munro wrote, "Boys and Girls" to address the confusion that gender roles may cause in a modern society. "Boys and Girls" is a coming-of-age story about a young girl who is enjoying her tomboy years and is defiant about becoming a woman.  The theme in "Boys and Girls" is this transition from the childhood...   [tags: Boys and Girls Alice Munro]

Strong Essays
3414 words (9.8 pages)

Alice Munro's Boys and Girls Essay

- Alice Munro's "Boys and Girls" Alice Munro's short story, "Boys and Girls," has a very interesting detail written into it. The narrator's brother is named Laird, which was carefully chosen by the author. Laird is a synonym for lord, which plays a important role in a story where a young girl has society's unwritten rules forced upon her. At the time of the story, society did not consider men and women equal. The name symbolized how the male child was superior in the parents' eyes and in general....   [tags: Boys and Girls, Alice Munro]

Free Essays
1047 words (3 pages)

Alice Munro's Boys and Girls Essay

- Alice Munro's Boys and Girls In Alice Munro’s “Boys and Girls” she tells a story about a young girl’s resistance to womanhood in a society infested with gender roles and stereotypes. The story takes place in the 1940s on a fox farm outside of Jubilee, Ontario, Canada. During this time, women were viewed as second class citizens, but the narrator was not going to accept this position without a fight. Munro’s invention of an unnamed character symbolized the narrator’s lack of identity, compared to her younger brother, who was given the name Laird, which is a synonym for “Lord”....   [tags: Boys and Girls Alice Munro]

Free Essays
1063 words (3 pages)

Essay on Investigate notions of sisters and sisterhood within Top Girls

- Investigate notions of sisters and sisterhood within Top Girls In Act 1 the women at the dinner party, speak of their suffering in the past, but they all relate to Marlene and to each other as a sisterhood of the present, even though the women represent contemporary figures supposedly alive in the early 1980’s in England. Lady Nijo and Pope Joan are similar in that they both had babies in difficult situations, and both stood up for their rights as women. The portrayal of these women contrasts with the traditional and ‘classical’ representation of women in plays....   [tags: English Literature]

Free Essays
572 words (1.6 pages)

‘Gilmore Girls’ TV Show Getting Back Essay

- ‘Gilmore Girls’ TV Show Getting Back “Once a good show loses its way, can it ever truly regain it?” As I read that first sentence, I wondered what they were talking about, I didn’t know that one of my favorite shows; Gilmore Girls, wasn’t doing too good. As I read on, I saw that there are many daytime shows not doing as good as they used to. The West Wing is doing better than it was the past couple of seasons but its not as good as it was when it first came out. The writer compares crying because the show was so good when it first came out, to crying now because it’s not as good as it used to be and viewer miss that....   [tags: Gilmore Girls Television TV Essays]

Free Essays
964 words (2.8 pages)