Comparing George Washington Irving 's ' The Devil And Tom Walker ' And Rip Van Winkle '

Comparing George Washington Irving 's ' The Devil And Tom Walker ' And Rip Van Winkle '

Length: 984 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


Comparing two similar stories by Washington Irving
Many times in our lives we are compared to our siblings. On many occasions, I am compared to my brother. People say that we have the same physique facial features, and height. Although these traits run in the family, I truly only want to be my own person. Just the other day someone called me “Michael.” The burn from my anger showed on my face. “I am NOT Michael,” I screamed; I am my own person. Just as we see similarities in family members, people also see similarities in stories written by the same author. In “The Devil and Tom Walker” and “Rip Van Winkle” we see similarities in setting, male protagonist, a female antagonist, and a mystic character.
Both of these stories are set in similar areas. Both stories take place in forests. We see Tom walking through a wooded area covered in “gloomy pines and hemlocks.” Similarly, Rip trudges up a mountain “for many a mile of rich woodland.” Both men apparently like the forests as means of escape from their wives. We also see similarities in the fact that both men live near bodies of water. Tom walked for “miles into the interior of the country from Charles Bay.” Also we see Rip looking down into the “Hudson.” These men enjoyed the water areas near where they lived. Washington Irving obviously used these settings in his stories for he was reared in the Hudson Valley area where rivers run free and woods abound everywhere.
Not only do these stories include similar settings, they also include similar male protagonists. Both men seem to be lazy. We know Tom was lazy because he did not take care of his “ miserable horse with ribs that stuck out like a gridiron.” We also know that Rip is lazy because his “estate dwindled away u...


... middle of paper ...


...im with a good tasting beverage. The drink they gave him the drink caused him to sleep twenty years of his life away. Irving probably chose these mystic character stereotypes to show how the British tricked colonists into providing them with the things they needed in exchange for rum and other idle pleasures.
It is only natural that there be similarities in different stories that an author has written. Even though the stories are different authors draw upon personal experiences in their writings. They used the same character types because they are used to seeing people with those characteristics. Once the reader gains an understanding of the points an author is trying to make in one story it helps the reader predict the meaning in the next. Irving wrote in a time of revolution due to the conflicts surrounding him. Conflict became a central theme in his writings.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparing Irving's Rip Van Winkle and The Devil and Tom Walker Essay

- An Analysis of Irving's Rip Van Winkle and The Devil and Tom Walker Washington Irving was one of the first American writers to write any kind of fantasy story or writing. At first he tried to pass his stories as real life accounts found in a dead mans dresser. The start of one states that it is real and has been deemed so by collages and some museums. After he saw how much people liked his stories he published all of them in " The Sketch Book of Godfred Crayon, Gent."....   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Free Essays
501 words (1.4 pages)

Essay Irving's Portrayal of Women in His Novels

- In his stories the women were not portrayed as nice. Women were usually nagging and would fight with their husbands. Some critics felt that Irving took an anti-feminism approach to his writing. However some critic feel that The Legend of Sleepy Hollow shows importance of marriage. Some critics also argue the quality of his work. Some pieces of his work are considered remarkable. While other pieces of his work are considered not to be that good. Irving’s health was also not very good and he had tuberculosis....   [tags: sleepy hollow, RIP van winkle]

Free Essays
649 words (1.9 pages)

The Life Of Rip Van Winkle Essay

- The Life of Rip Van Winkle In Washington Irving’s Rip Van Winkle, the main character Rip represents the United States. Throughout this entire story Mr. Winkle is having a tremendous amount of trouble struggling to find himself. He left home and came back to the same problems he was dealing with before he left. One of his main reasons for leaving was to get away from his nagging wife. Rip’s biggest problem was that he was very lethargic. While Mr. Winkle was a pleasant man, his laziness affected many areas in his life such as his family, the farm, and also society....   [tags: Rip Van Winkle, Washington Irving]

Strong Essays
842 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Rip Van Winkle

- "The outline for each story, although based on native history, can be found in legend and myth." Robert M. Meyers, a famous critic, said this about Washington Irving's amazing talent in writing short stories in literature. "Rip Van Winkle" is one of Washington's most famous short stories. Washington does a fantastic job in the story using the themes of martial conflict and American Revolution. Throughout the story, both seem very noticeable. "Rip Van Winkle" covers many literary elements, all of which are very noticeable to the reader....   [tags: Rip Van Winkle]

Strong Essays
2536 words (7.2 pages)

The Message of Rip Van Winkle Essays

- Rip looked, and beheld a precise counterpart of himself, --[It appears Rip has seen an exact mirror-image of himself--the way others have always perceived him]-- as he went up the mountain--[This was the way he was before his "sleep," or journey up the mountain]--: apparently as lazy, and certainly as ragged--[Before he encountered the party on the mountain, he was a casual, rough and lazy person]--. The poor fellow was now completely confounded--[It appears to everyone that Rip Jr. was confused in his thoughts, however, just as Rip Sr....   [tags: Rip Van Winkle Essays]

Strong Essays
1037 words (3 pages)

Rip Van Winkle and Romanticism Essays

- Rip Van Winkle and Romanticism In the world of literature, there are many types of writing that an author can take to express his ideas. Their topics can be explained through life experiences, biographies, poetry, or other forms of literature. One of the forms that authors use is Romanticism. There are many qualities that define the different viewpoints of Romanticism. Rip Van Winkle, “Thanatopsis,” and “The Cross of Snow” are all examples of writing from the period of Romanticism....   [tags: Rip Van Winkle Essays]

Free Essays
1453 words (4.2 pages)

Transformation and Freedom in Rip Van Winkle Essays

- Transformation and Freedom in Rip Van Winkle Washington Irving's, "Rip Van Winkle" presented a tale of a "dreamer." Rip Van Winkle was a family man who worked odd jobs around town, but managed to slip away from doing his own work around his farm. He was "one of those happy mortals...who take[s] the world easy." (pg. 404). He constantly struggled with the "henpecking" of his wife. Van Winkle found refuge and comfort going squirrel shooting with his dog. "Rip Van Winkle" depicts a story of a man longing to be free, and of the transformation that occurs to him and the town....   [tags: Rip Van Winkle Essays]

Free Essays
719 words (2.1 pages)

Rip Van Winkle and the American Dream Essay

- In Rip Van Winkle, Irving shows his doubts in the American Identity and the American dream. After the Revolutionary war, America was trying to develop its own course. They were free to govern their own course of development; however, some of them had an air of uncertainties on their own identity in this new country. Irving was born among this generation in the newly created United States of America, and also felt uncertainty about the American identity. Irving might be the writer that is the least positive about being an American....   [tags: Rip Van Winkle Essays]

Strong Essays
649 words (1.9 pages)

An Analysis of Irving's Rip Van Winkle Essay

- An Analysis of Irving's Rip Van Winkle Rip Van Winkle had grabbed his gun and his dog, Wolf, and headed out to the woods. He rested under a tree where evening came on quickly. As Rip was getting ready to journey back home, he heard a voice calling his name. He went to see who was calling his name. He discovered an old man carrying a keg on his back. Rip and the old man walked to a ravine in the mountain. There they found a band of odd-looking people. Rip and the old man drank from the keg the man was carrying on his back....   [tags: Rip Van Winkle Essays]

Free Essays
784 words (2.2 pages)

Essay about An Allegorical Reading of Rip Van Winkle

- An Allegorical Reading of Rip Van Winkle In Washington Irving’s “Rip Van Winkle,” an allegorical reading can be seen. The genius of Irving shines through, in not only his representation in the story, but also in his ability to represent both sides of the hot political issues of the day. Because it was written during the revolutionary times, Irving had to cater to a mixed audience of Colonists and Tories. The reader’s political interest, whether British or Colonial, is mutually represented allegorically in “Rip Van Winkle,” depending on who is reading it....   [tags: Rip Van Winkle Essays]

Strong Essays
1509 words (4.3 pages)