Comparing George Orwell 's ' Stranger ' And ' Shooting An Elephant ' Essay

Comparing George Orwell 's ' Stranger ' And ' Shooting An Elephant ' Essay

Length: 1121 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


James Baldwin and George Orwell Comparison
The essay “Stranger in the village” by James Baldwin, and “Shooting an Elephant” by George Orwell, share a similarity in their experience in a new environments. Orwell a British officer he was not warmly welcome, the Burmese people hated. As for Baldwin it is more of racism than hated. Both essays happen in unfamiliar places where there were racism and discrimination. They do not fit in with the natives and is judged because of their nationalities. However, the themes of these writing differ.
Baldwin being visits an unfamiliar place that was mostly populated by white people; they were very interested in the color of his skin. The villagers had never seen a black person before, which makes the villager question if he is a real person. The village is quiet not many activity, they had no moves, bank, and no library, only a few radios. He feels like he was an outsider because no one stops to talk to him, everyone just minding their own way, but they still criticize on how Baldwin appeared looks.
Orwell had a similar experience to Baldwin where he was in an unfamiliar place as an officer in Burma. He started his essay by claiming a perspective on British Imperialism. He said that it is evil and against oppressors. He feels hatred and guilt toward both himself and “The evil-spirited little beasts” as he refers to the Burmese people. (195) His essay was base around his experiences with the people and the shooting of an elephant. As he face the elephant and the Burmese to show his courage as an officer.
In the Swiss village Baldwin feels like he is discriminated. His feels lonely toward the Swiss villager. After leaving the village during the summer, he returns in the winter to find out t...


... middle of paper ...


...ne the right thing, for a mad elephant has to be killed, like a mad dog, if its owner fails to control it.”(199). Orwell knows that it was unnecessary to harm the elephant, but he did it anyways, that’s what the crowd wanted.
Both Orwell and Baldwin have a very much similarity in their experiences, as for Baldwin he was called name and made fun at because of his skin color and how he look, but that did not stop him he was upset when the villager called him name, but sooner or later people realize Baldwin is not just a “living wonder” people became interested in him more afterward. Orwell also felt and realizes that he was just trying not to be a fool when Orwell says “I often wondered whether any of the others grasped that I had done it solely to avoid looking like a fool” (Orwell 200). He felt that his whole experience was just an act to impress the Burmese people.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

George Orwell 's ' Shooting An Elephant ' Essay

- Symbolism and Imperialism in “Shooting an Elephant” George Orwell dramatically writes about his time in Burma as an Imperial Officer in his essay “Shooting an Elephant”. He communicates in detail how he disagrees with the concept of imperialism but likewise dislikes the taunting Burmese community. Orwell goes on to recount the time an elephant rampages the village and how enlightening of an experience it was. Symbolism is a heavy orchestrator in this essay, with Orwell relating the concept of imperialism to several events such as the elephant’s rampage, the dead coolie, and the actual shooting of the elephant....   [tags: Burma, George Orwell, Shooting an Elephant]

Better Essays
800 words (2.3 pages)

Essay about Analysis Of George Orwell 's ' Shooting An Elephant '

- Symbolism in "Shooting an Elephant" George Orwell dramatically writes about his time in Burma as an Imperial Officer in his essay "Shooting an Elephant". He communicates in detail how he disagrees with the concept of imperialism but likewise dislikes the taunting Burmese community. Orwell goes on to recount the time an elephant rampages the village and how enlightening of an experience it was. Symbolism is a heavy orchestrator in this essay, with Orwell relating the concept of imperialism to several events such as the elephant 's rampage, the dead coolie, and the actual shooting of the elephant....   [tags: Burma, George Orwell, Shooting an Elephant]

Better Essays
749 words (2.1 pages)

Analysis Of George Orwell 's ' Shooting An Elephant ' Essay

- George Orwell is a novel writer, born in India and have only spent five days there. Ida Mabel Limouzin, his mother, brought him and his sister too England while his father stayed in India. The novel Shooting an Elephant, that George wrote, took place in the bottom of Burma in the middle of Moulmein. The story is about George Orwell hesitating to kill an Elephant that has killed a man. All George planned to do was to test the elephant to see if it really meant any harm. George feels pressured by the crowd following him because they expect him to kill the elephant....   [tags: Burma, George Orwell, Shooting an Elephant]

Better Essays
763 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on George Orwell 's Why I Write

- In Why I Write, by George Orwell, actual elements of Orwell’s personal life are explained with respect to the development of his writing career. Unlike Shooting an Elephant, which could easily be a representation of Orwell’s real Burmese experiences in 1936, Why I Write is explicitly about his writing career, and it is justified to claim that Orwell is the speaker. In the early stages of his writing, Orwell emphasizes that he wrote for everyone but himself; the styles and techniques that he chose for his short stories and poems were tailored to an audience who loved flowery, thrilling writing....   [tags: George Orwell, Writing, Writer, Burma]

Better Essays
1469 words (4.2 pages)

Shooting an Elephant Essay

- In his essay, Shooting an Elephant, George Orwell illustrates his experiences as a British police officer, and reflects it to the nature of imperialism. He hates his job as a police officer in Moulmein because an “anti-European feeling was very bitter” due to British Empire’s dictatorship in Burma. Therefore, Orwell, a white man is being treated disrespectfully by the Burmese which allows him to hate his job and British Empire, the root of everything. However, the incident of shooting of an elephant gives him a “better glimpse … of the real nature of imperialism – the real motives for which despotic government act” (13)....   [tags: Analysis, George Orwell]

Better Essays
1357 words (3.9 pages)

Literary Analysis of “Shooting an Elephant,” by George Orwell Essay example

- ... Part five is the last paragraph, he tells us about why that he had to kill the elephant. At the beginning, Orwell claims that he is fully against the Imperialism and he describes it as “devil”. O well’s point is to use the image of the elephant as a metaphor to demonstrate the destructive and unethical power of the Imperialism. We can see the destruction of imperialism when Orwell depicts “An elephant was ravaging the bazaar” ()and “It had already destroyed somebody’s bamboo huts, kill a cow and raided some fruit-stalls and devoured the stock;” ()....   [tags: metaphor, imperialism, imagery]

Better Essays
1146 words (3.3 pages)

Shooting An Elephant By George Orwell Essays

- “Shooting an Elephant” by George Orwell “Shooting an Elephant” By George Orwell reveals the story of events during Orwell’s service as a sub-divisional police officer with the India Imperial Police, in Moulmein, Burma. “Shooting an Elephant” By George Orwell reflects Orwell’s emotions of hatred, bitterness, and guilt felt due to oppression of Imperialism. The story begins with Orwell explaining his deep hatred for the role he took place in during his service as a police officer in Burma. He was not happy within his daily routine and began to feel intense hatred towards the empire, he served, the Burma people (yellow faces) and with his deep smoldering emotions within himself....   [tags: George Orwell, Burma, Shooting an Elephant]

Better Essays
872 words (2.5 pages)

Shooting An Elephant By George Orwell Essay

- Shooting an Elephant In George Orwell’s story, “Shooting an Elephant,” he goes through numerous emotions. It is a very thought provoking work that takes the reader inside his mind. He goes through many emotions throughout the text, he experienced humiliation, evil, and confliction. In “Shooting an Elephant,” Orwell experiences humiliation. “When a nimble Burman tripped me up on the football field and the referee looked the other way, the crowd yelled with hideous laughter” (p.323) His profession of being a police officer made him an enemy and a target to most people in town....   [tags: George Orwell, Burma, Shooting an Elephant, Musth]

Better Essays
854 words (2.4 pages)

George Orwell 's Shooting An Elephant Essay

- “Shooting an Elephant” by George Orwell “Shooting an Elephant” By George Orwell reflects Orwell’s emotions of hatred, bitterness, and guilt felt due to oppression of Imperialism in Moulmein, Burma; During Orwell’s service as a sub-divisional police officer with the India Imperial Police. The story begins with Orwell explaining his deep hatred for the role he took place in during his service as a police officer in Burma. He was not happy within his daily routine and began to feel intense hatred towards the empire he served, the Burma people (yellow faces) and with his deep smoldering emotions within himself....   [tags: George Orwell, Burma, Shooting an Elephant]

Better Essays
784 words (2.2 pages)

George Orwell's Shooting an Elephant Essay

- George Orwell's "Shooting an Elephant" In 'Shooting an Elephant,' George Orwell finds himself in a difficult situation involving an elephant. The fate of the elephant lies in his hands. Only he can make the final decision. In the end, due to Orwell's decision, the elephant lay dying in a pool of blood. Orwell wins the sympathy of readers by expressing the pressure he feels as an Anglo-Indian in Burma, struggling with his morals, and showing a sense of compassion for the dying animal. Readers sympathize with Orwell because they can relate to his emotions in the moments before the shooting....   [tags: George Orwell Shooting Elephant]

Better Essays
792 words (2.3 pages)