Comparing and Contrasting Mudie's Peom My Father Began as a God and the Movie Freedom Writers

Comparing and Contrasting Mudie's Peom My Father Began as a God and the Movie Freedom Writers

Length: 981 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Good Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The poem ‘My Father Began as a God’ by Ian Mudie is about how a boy (probably him) changes his views on his father, as he grows older. As a child, he saw his father as a ‘god’ whose laws were ‘immutable’. He was a fearless hero, able to do anything: “He fearlessly lifted me to heaven by a mere swing to his shoulder”. However, by the time he was an adolescent, his father had become a ‘foolish small old man’. He was no longer superhuman, but a father, just like any other: “With silly and outmoded views of life and morality”. The cause for this change of perspective was specifically puberty. In consequence, he and his father would have drifted apart, since they would have clashed on many occasions. As he grew even older, he noticed that his father’s “faults scaled away into the past, revealing virtues such as honesty, generosity, integrity”. He noticed this because he matured even further – from an adolescent to an adult. This change would have probably improved their relationship. The composer’s final change in perspective occurred after his father died. As time went by, he began to realize that he was just like his father, and like every other man: “...the more I see myself as just one more of all the little men”. Since this poem is about a general situation, it is safe to assume that this change came about after the composer had kids of his own. Resulting from this change was probably a deeper knowledge about life. He realized that the path he will follow in the future will be the same one his dad followed.
Ian Mudie has written his poem in chronological order. He has done this to make the changes that occurred clearer to the responder. The style of the text is a prose poem. The composer has written it in this form because it giv...


... middle of paper ...


...e advancing through school while in the poem, the boy and his father are advancing through life. In ‘Freedom Writers’, the kids do not want an education because they feel it is irrelevant in their lives. They think that surviving until 18 years of age is an achievement. Their change of perspective is related to school and their lives. This is different from the poem in which the change of perspective is about the boy’s father. In ‘Freedom Writers’, the teacher brought about the kids’ change of perspectives, so it was induced. However, in the poem, time brought about the change, so it was inevitable.
The biggest difference between the two texts is that one is about gangs and racism while the other is about the way a boy’s perception of his father changes as he grows up. However, both texts cleverly use techniques to convey messages that are relevant to our society.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Tomorrow When The War Began And The Movie Essay

- The Differences between the book Tomorrow When the War Began and the movie The film Tomorrow When the War Began is a film based on the novel of the same title. John Marsden’s Tomorrow When the War Began is the story of seven teenagers who return from a camping trip to find their home town has been invaded. The producer of the film has excluded several settings from the book and also changed parts of the plot and the character’s characteristics. These differences occur to show the character’s development, to limit the duration of the film and to keep the audience engaged....   [tags: Character, Fiction, Novel, Narrative]

Good Essays
908 words (2.6 pages)

Essay Analysis Of The Movie ' Father Of The Bride '

- Father of the Bride ( 1950 ) Cast: Spencer Tracy (Stanley T. Banks), Joan Bennett (Ellie Banks), Elizabeth Taylor ( Katherine “Kay” Banks), Don Taylor (Buckley Dunstan), and others Director: Vincente Minnelli Synopsis: The movie is in both comedy and romance when it was released on June 16, 1950. The film tells the tale of a father who is very set in his old ways and stereotypes. His twenty year old daughter is ready for things to change and very unconventionally tells them she is going to get married....   [tags: Wedding, Marriage, Vincente Minnelli]

Good Essays
1352 words (3.9 pages)

What Is A Father? Essay

- What is a father. A father, according to Oxford Dictionary, is a man in relation to his natural child or children. While this may seem like a simple definition to many people, the true definition of a father has gradually changed over time. As the number of children born out of wedlock continues to increase, the chances of a father being present in their lives is very slim. As this occurs, the view of a father’s role continues to drift away from the dictionary definition. My belief on fathers has been altered because of personal experiences that permanently changed my life....   [tags: Father, Family, Mother, Parent]

Good Essays
719 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about The Trip Of Europe Began

- July 1st 2014, the trip to Europe began. After 20 minutes of trying to books seats on the machines we still didn 't have seats because my mom is technologically challenged, so finally we just went up to the counter and within 10- 15 minutes we had our seats and started to check our luggage. We then walked to our terminal and waited for what seemed like forever to load the plane. We loaded the plan found our seats, started a movie and we were off to our first destination, Paris. We landed in Paris and after getting off the plane my mom went to purchase the tickets for the train to take us further into the city....   [tags: Paris, Eiffel Tower, Breakfast, Bed and breakfast]

Good Essays
1556 words (4.4 pages)

The Day My Father Began to Understand the Colors of My World Essay

- The world is full of color. It has to be. Where else would we find depth and meaning and purpose. Color comes together to make shape. The vibrancy of blues, reds and yellows all wash over us as we experience life. Everything ruptures with color, even music with its bright highs and dark lows or language spoken with meaning and clarity. Existence is an art and the freedom to express your art a privilege we all hold dear. I discovered the power of expression when I was young. Crayons and scissors filled my mind....   [tags: Personal Narrative, Autobiographical Essay]

Free Essays
2132 words (6.1 pages)

Essay about Movie Review : ' The Movie '

- This movie is the certainly a one of a kind. The premise of this movie is how this boy, Mason, changes throughout his life and how he combats them. The timeline for this movie is from when Mason is around the age of six or seven, until he graduates high school and goes to college. What is so crazy about this film is that the actor that plays Mason is the same boy the entire way through, which means it took the film crew about twelve years to shoot the full picture, which is about two hours and forty-five minutes in length....   [tags: Family, Father, Mother, Parent]

Good Essays
705 words (2 pages)

Essay on I Was A Child My Father

- When I was a child my father meant the world to me. We had a strong unique bond that only a father and son could possibly have. Although there were moments where we annoyed one another and argued we still loved each other dearly. Since my father was the pastor he would drag me and the rest of my family with him to every church service being held at our church. As you can probably imagine the idea of waking up early on a day off from school wasn’t all that appealing to me. So every Sunday morning I would reluctantly go to each church service....   [tags: Family, Parent, Mother, Father]

Good Essays
947 words (2.7 pages)

Big Daddy: A Movie Depicting a Father and Son relationship Essay

- Adam Sandler used bad manners and used profanity in front of his son. His values were messed up. He didn't have any conscience what so ever and he had very few morals if any. His son picked a lot of bad habits from his father; like laughing when someone got hurt, urinating in public, and bad manners. His father also argued with people in front of his son. Adam Sandler’s emotion, passion, determination, perseverance made him a good father. He gave his son a lot of experiences that helped go through a lot that will make his son stronger mindset good or bad....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
553 words (1.6 pages)

Essay on History of the Drive-In Movie Theater

- History of the Drive-In Movie Theater The story of the drive-in movie theater begins with one man. That man was Richard Milton Hollingshead, Jr., born on February 25, 1900, the "father" of the drive-in. The drive-in got its humble beginnings in the driveway of Hollingshead’s Riverton, New Jersey home, at 212 Thomas Avenue. This is where his first experimentations took place. Setting a 1928 Kodak projector on the hood of the family car, he projected the film onto a screen he had nailed to a tree....   [tags: Movie Film Essays]

Good Essays
1804 words (5.2 pages)

Where America Began Essay

- Where America Began On May 6, 1607 three ships, Susan Constant, Godspeed, and Discovery , sailed in search of treasures, among other things. On April 26, 1607 they found " The New Land ," where they decided to settle in, the settlers named this new land "Jamestown" in honor of their king, King James the I of England. Jamestown was the first English settlement in America. The site of Jamestown in which the settlers decided to built their colony was a inadequate choice. The area was swampy, saturated with mosquitoes, and the drinking water was impure, Jamestown was a unhealthy and dangerous place to live in....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
399 words (1.1 pages)