Compare the Representation of Relationships in ‘Pride and Prejudice’ and ‘Rapunzstiltskin’

Compare the Representation of Relationships in ‘Pride and Prejudice’ and ‘Rapunzstiltskin’

Length: 1280 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Pride and Prejudice is a classic novel about love and the role of women. Though times have changed, there is still a struggle for female independence and respect, in both relationships and the work place, despite the past desperate efforts of the suffragettes in the early 1900s and the present work of feminists and strong female characters today. However, Jane Austen’s novel has forever been the dream world of women all over the world because it’s a real story of the hardships in romance and the oppression of the ‘weaker sex’. In contrast, Liz Lochhead’s modern poem Rapunzstiltskin is less impressed with these romantic notions and looks unkindly on fairytales and the like, with their clichéd characters and false intentions. But on closer inspection, the two pieces may not be as different as they first appear.
In lines two and four of Rapunzstiltskin, the maiden is described as being ‘good & used to her isolation’ and ‘had come to almost love her tower’. The tower is a metaphor for imprisonment, just like women in Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice and so, the women of that era – if they weren’t married, they were stuck at home under the rule of their fathers and without any life. But in the same way, the maiden’s acceptance of her fate is reflected in Mary Bennet. She is an example of an unmarried woman, though she’s perfectly happy with it. In line 15, an ‘old hag’ is mentioned and we learn that after her sisters’ marriages, Mary was left at Longbourn with Mrs Bennet. Another situation whereby a young, unmarriable woman is left with an ‘old hag’ is that of Anne de Bourgh, heir and sole companion of Lady Catherine, her mother.
Later, in line 33, the maiden ‘was keener than a TV quizmaster’. This links to Pride and Prejudice becau...

... middle of paper ...

...lationships are similarly presented in both the novel and the poem. Pride and Prejudice does describe more unrealistic romances, but it still puts across the idea that women were beneath their men, just as in the poem. Neither piece condoles this, however, and are very negative towards that idea, but whereas Jane Austen simply goes against the norm by writing about the perfect relationships, Rapunzstiltskin is sceptical and pessimistic. Women in the time of Jane Austen dedicated their lives to being good-looking (seen in the vanity of Lydia and Kitty especially) and accomplished to ensure they were marriage material, just as the maiden tried to be enchanting and desirable for The Prince. Both texts definitely illustrate an imbalance and struggle for equality within the oppressive rules and expectations that revolved around women’s lives, and so, their relationships.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Compare the relationships between Mr and Miss Bingley, Mr and Miss Darcy and any two of the Bennett sisters

- Compare the relationships between Mr and Miss Bingley, Mr and Miss Darcy and any two of the Bennett sisters, exploring the use Austen makes of sibling relationships in the novel. The core theme in Pride and Prejudice is the relationships between [MSOffice1] siblings. Austen had a large family and many siblings with whom she was close but with her sister Cassandra, was she especially so. These reflect the sibling relationships that, in my opinion, are central to the novel. Each character has more than one sibling relationship, whether related through blood, through growing up together or in the sense of a close friendship....   [tags: English Literature]

Strong Essays
1763 words (5 pages)

Pride and Prejudice: Contrasting the Relationships of Elizabeth and Jane

- One of the most commonly read and most devoted writers in the English literature, is novelist Jane Austen. Writer of Sense and Sensibility, Pride and Prejudice, Mansfield Park, Emma and two other additional novels, Northanger Abbey and Persuasion and lastly the novel Sanditon. Austen’s novels acted as witty, warm and consisted descriptions of the favored classes of the 18th- and 19th-century in England. Jane’s most finely known novels were Sense and Sensibility and Pride and Prejudice and Emma, all three became favorites in the world of Hollywood....   [tags: Pride and Prejudice, Jane Austen, relationships, ]

Strong Essays
1906 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on The Representations of Femininity in Pride and Prejudice

- Jane Austen, one of the most well-known 19th century novelists recognized today continues to captivate people with stories of love and romance through the transformation of her novels into film and television. All of her novels are about women dealing with romance, courtship, and marriage during a repressing period. Most of her characters and stories revolve around the lives of the upper class. It centers on the values, rituals, and manners of high society in England during the Regency Era. Her most popular novel, Pride and Prejudice published in 1813 maintains the interest of its audiences as it did almost two centuries earlier as evidenced by its frequent incarnations....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Strong Essays
897 words (2.6 pages)

Representations of Nature in King Lear Essay

- We are lucky, today, that the majority of the world’s nations are democracies. This has only been the case in very recent times. For the greater part of human history, society has subscribed to the belief that birth is the most important determinant of one’s future. In Elizabethan England, this was especially true. Those born into the nobility enjoyed a lifetime of privilege, while those born outside of their ranks mainly existed to serve them. A century later, the British encountered an even stricter form of this belief when they conquered India....   [tags: Representations of Nature in King Lear]

Strong Essays
856 words (2.4 pages)

Pride And Prejudice By Jane Austen Essay

- ... Elizabeth Bennet is one of very few characters in the novel who do not allow these restrictions to play as large of a role in the formation of her desired future. She scoffs at the idea of marrying someone solely for financial and political gain, as well as allowing a man to have complete control over every aspect of a her life. Instead, she embraces the suppressed notion that a woman has the ability to be fully thinking and expressive, while still maintaining her femininity. In Elizabeths case, her femininity gives her an insight and strength that she wouldn 't possess otherwise....   [tags: Pride and Prejudice, Elizabeth Bennet]

Strong Essays
1102 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Racism, Prejudice, and Discrimination in the Workplace

- Racism, Prejudice, and Discrimination in the Workplace The workplace, including its composition and internal organization, is subjected to extensive regulation by the state. The civil society and its voluntary associations, have in fact, an important function with regards to workplace matters. In particular, they serve as a buffer against the state and an autonomous domain. Without them, differences and individual voices can eventually challenge the prevailing political order. But civil society and associational life in particular, perform other crucial functions that depend not on separating and shielding individuals from the society at large but on linking them to each other...   [tags: Racism Prejudice]

Strong Essays
495 words (1.4 pages)

The Effect of Pride and Prejudice on Darcy and Elizabeth's Relationship

- The Effect of Pride and Prejudice on Darcy and Elizabeth's Relationship The novel 'Pride and Prejudice' was written in 1796. It was written by a writer who's name was Jane Austin. The book was first published in 1813, and has consistently been Jane's most popular novel. The original version of the novel was written in 1796, and was called 'First Impressions'. In the story there is a family called 'The Bennett's'. This is one of the main families in the book. The whole novel is almost based around this family....   [tags: Pride and Prejudice Jane Austen Essays]

Strong Essays
1359 words (3.9 pages)

Compare and contrast the roles and relationships of the following Essay

- Compare and contrast the roles and relationships of the following pairs of characters: George and Lennie (of Mice and Men) and Holmes and Watson (Sherlock Holmes stories). Compare and contrast the roles and relationships of the following pairs of characters: George and Lennie (of Mice and Men) and Holmes and Watson (Sherlock Holmes stories). Sherlock Holmes stories are short stories, which involve investigating and solving crimes. They include characters such as Sherlock Holmes and Dr James Watson, these are two main characters who are in each short story trying to solve case investigations....   [tags: English Literature]

Strong Essays
1300 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on Prejudice and Pride in Pride and Prejudice

- Prejudice and Pride in Pride and Prejudice          In any literary work the title and introduction make at least some allusion to the important events of the novel. With Pride and Prejudice, Austen takes this convention to the extreme, designing all of the first and some of the second half of the novel after the title and the first sentence. The concepts of pride, prejudice, and "universally acknowledged truth" (51), as well as the interpretation of those concepts, are the central focus of the novel....   [tags: Pride and Prejudice]

Strong Essays
1545 words (4.4 pages)

The Impact of Wealth on Love Relationships in Pride and Prejudice Essay

- In Jane Austen's novel Pride and Prejudice the effect of money propels the development of love relationships more than any other factor. There are three burgeoning relationships in the novel that can be closely studied to see the impact of money on love in Austen's time period. Three of the relationships, that of Charlotte and Mr. Collins, Lydia and Mr. Wickham, and Jane and Mr. Bingley only help to propel the most unlikely couple, Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy, together. Although Charlotte and Mr. Collins and Jane and Mr....   [tags: European Literature]

Strong Essays
1140 words (3.3 pages)