Compare Mill and Kant’s Ethics Essay

Compare Mill and Kant’s Ethics Essay

Length: 878 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Kant’s Ethics may best apply to modern business. Kant said right action based on a set of moral rules, and the right action is supposed to be the one that conforms with these rules, whereas certain other types of action are morally forbidden. He also suggests that people should be treated "with respect and as ends in their own right, not solely as means to other's ends." On the contrary, Mill’s ethics only concern about the happiness of majority instead of duty itself. Thus, the question how could Kant’s “austere” system do better for business needs than Mill’s flexible business ethics. I would say that although Mill’s Ethic is a functional system of moral analysis, but the decision is easily changeable when the consequence change and in business, decision are hard to change when had been made. Also, sometimes it is not possible to uncover all the pains and happiness when making a business decision.
Let me use an example to show how Kant’s ethic is best applied to decision making. A doctor sees the test data showing that the person has a disease that is incurable and have survive rate of lower than five percent. Should the doctor tell the truth or should the doctor tell something other than the truth? First, let us look at Mill’s ethic. As utilitarian, I will say telling the truth there will be a great deal of pain and hardly any pleasure at all. The person will be upset, their family will be upset, the doctor will be upset in informing the ill person that there is nothing that the doctor can do to alter their condition. The doctor's staff will be upset seeing the person come in for whatever treatment there may be. So the ethical solution will be to make makes up a story concerning the diagnosis and prognosis that is not t...

... middle of paper ...

...o imagine that the pain and suffering of the slaves would be greater than the centuries of benefits that would be enjoyed by billions of humans to come. However, the chance of Kantian change from an immoral decision to moral base on duty is none.
As I mentioned before, although Mill’s Ethic is a functional system of moral analysis is good, but an immoral action it is easily justifiable as long as an action produce the greatest happiness. We accept immoral action because they generate a little pain and great amount of happiness. Let’s take, for example, scientists use rats as test subject for medical development. It is acceptable because no harm is done to people and once new medicine is produced, it benefits the society in the long run. Perhaps, flexible and outcome oriented system is better when an action produces the greatest happiness and a little bit of pains.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Kant 's Argument On Kantian Ethics Essay

- IV. Objections to Kantian Ethics Interestingly, some critiques consider Kant’s theory to be constraining. Yet, the work of O’Neil suggests otherwise. She focuses on the second categorical imperative specifically to say that we need to ensure that we do not use someone as a mere means. More simply said, we do not coerce or deceive someone to reach our end (104-105). I would like to emphasize that she specifically points out we “cannot just claim that our intentions are good and do what we will” (105)....   [tags: Immanuel Kant, Ethics, Deontological ethics]

Better Essays
1155 words (3.3 pages)

Kant 's Philosophy On Ethics Essay

- Philosophical Ethics Analysis This paper is my analysis of two different philosophical, ethical systems and my attempt to compare and contrast each of them with a Christian perspective on ethics. I. Kantian Ethics Kant emphasizes duty. This ethic maintains that there is nothing praiseworthy in doing want we want to do. Value comes when we do our “duty,” whether we want to or not. By stressing duty, it would give more value to doing what we do not want to do than doing what we want when both create the same result....   [tags: Ethics, John Stuart Mill, Intrinsic value]

Better Essays
833 words (2.4 pages)

Ethics And Morals : Moral Decisions Essay

- To find our moral decisions, we need to use logical evidence and theories to decide if our ethics and morals will allow us to harm an innocent child to create more happiness in the lives of others and our own. There are many different theories of morality that we can use to make this ethical decision. In this paper, we will look at many of the options and see how they are structured. Utilitarianism, Virtue Ethics, and Kant’s moral theory will all be put to the test and a decision will need to be made....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Immanuel Kant, Human]

Better Essays
1542 words (4.4 pages)

Utilitarianism And Kantian Duty Ethics Essay

- There are a variety of ethical theories that put forth compelling and merit-based arguments. The two that I will highlight in this paper are utilitarianism and Kantian duty ethics. The leading proponents of utilitarianism were English philosophers John Stuart Mill (1806-1873) and Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832). Utilitarians were essentially social reformers, through their support of suffrage for women, abolition of slavery, and other social issues. The basic foundation of Utilitarianism can be explained through the Greatest Happiness Principle, which is simply laid out as follows: Happiness = pleasure, and the absence of pain Unhappiness = pain, and the absence of please Mill explained this...   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Immanuel Kant, Utilitarianism]

Better Essays
1341 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Psychological and Ethical Egoism, Mill vs Kant, and Ethical Relativism

- ... For example, if Jack wants to steal something to benefit himself, he should do so because it is the right thing for him to do. The main argument against psychological egoism is that people do in fact act to fulfill other’s desires. For example, Jack was playing video games and his mother asked him to help her with the dishes and he does so. He is doing this not to fulfill his desires, but to fulfill hers; he was already sitting down doing something that fulfilled his desires at the time but chose to help his mom....   [tags: philosophy exam]

Better Essays
910 words (2.6 pages)

The Importance Of Pleasure And Pain By John Stuart Mill Essay example

- Pleasure and pain are aspects of everyday life. To a utilitarian, an action that gives pleasure or the removes pains for the largest amount of people is morally right (John Stuart Mill, What Utilitarianism Is Pg. 182 Sec. 2) . As such, letting a murderer in your home would seem to be outlandish and would result in pain for yourself and those who are around you. Kantians would go against utilitarians (intending happiness) saying it is not the consequence but the motive that decides whether an action has moral worth (Immanuel Kant, Section I Pg.50 4:394)....   [tags: Immanuel Kant, Utilitarianism, Morality, Ethics]

Better Essays
1159 words (3.3 pages)

Consequentialist Ethics: Mozi Essay

- Introduction The change in demography, multiple chronic conditions, increasing infectious disease threats, and small healthcare budgets put healthcare systems under serious challenge. In addition, there is an increasing need to generate more knowledge to improve patient treatments. Reuse of patient health data is promoted as a means to generate evidence on the effectiveness, benefits, and harms of different treatments. Patient data are also reused for quality assurance, public health and commercial applications....   [tags: patient data, health insurance, ethics]

Better Essays
1217 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about The Ethical Theories Of Susie

- Susie works as an 8th grade science teacher in a title one school in San Antonio. She teaches co-teach classes which means she works with the students who are intellectually below average and need the extra assistance and extra push. With her, she has another certified teacher, Jenny, who aids her in the classroom. My mom, aside from her co-teacher, has a teaching partner that works in the same department as her, and they coordinate lesson plans and teaching principles. Dennis, her teaching partner, is a diligent worker and helps with preparing power points for him and my mom to utilize....   [tags: Ethics, Deontological ethics, Immanuel Kant]

Better Essays
1040 words (3 pages)

Understanding Aspects Of Ethical Reasoning Essay

- Timeer Mehta Professor McCrossin Intro to Ethics 22 December 2015 Understanding Aspects of Ethical Reasoning A Comparison of Kant & Mill Every day we are often faced with numerous different scenarios and decision-making opportunities which rely upon our own morals and values in order to figure out how to weigh the ethical content of our different choices and the consequences they entail. Being able to understand and develop a framework for these moral and ethical conundrums is an important way to be able to analyze and evaluate what our values are - or should be - and how our actions reflect our own ethical reasoning....   [tags: Ethics, Philosophy, Morality, Immanuel Kant]

Better Essays
1573 words (4.5 pages)

Are Monique 's Actions Ethical? Essay

- A twelve-year-old girl, Monique, comes from a low-income family. There are nights in which Monique does not eat dinner due to her mom never having the money to feed her. The mother always spends her last bit of money on drugs. Monique does not any type of family members that can help her and the mother financially out. One day, Monique goes to her after school program, StreetSquash, and decides to steal snacks from the cabinet so that she will not starve through the night. Are Monique’s actions ethical....   [tags: Ethics, Philosophy, Immanuel Kant]

Better Essays
1045 words (3 pages)