Compare and Contrast Macbeth and Men of Respect Essay

Compare and Contrast Macbeth and Men of Respect Essay

Length: 1122 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Set in present day New York in 1991, "Men of Respect" is a story of New York gangsters, in particular a mad-dog thug, Mike Battaglia, and his ambitious, highly unscrupulous wife Ruthie. “Macbeth” created by William Shakespeare was re-created into this modern day movie version. The various warring kingdoms of the play become organized crime factions in the film: King Duncan becoming the padrino or godfather of the main family, Charlie Di'Mico; Banquo becomes his buddy, Bankie Como; Macduff becomes Irish capo, Duffy. Screenwriter Reilly makes Macbeth over into ambitious Mafia underling, Mikey Battaglia, who is King Duncan’s lieutenant chief driven by a fortuneteller's prophecy and the influences of his even more treacherous wife to knock off the head of the D'Amico crime family and claim the top title for himself. The most significant aspect of the film is its total loyalty and devotion to the text of the play. The film follows the play scene for scene, at times line for line. A closer analysis of the characters and lines will compare the many differences and similarities between William Shakespeare's "Macbeth" and William Reilly's "Men of Respect."
The personality of Lady Macbeth or Ruthie Bataglia remains instinctive yet ruthless in her goal to get Mikey to become the "padrino." Some lines are paraphrased to Shakespeare's original version word for word. For example, Ruthie rebukes her husband saying, "Show a little ambition," and "If I was the man, I'd know what to do." Other lines were brilliantly revised to better understand the audience. Lady Macbeth’s says in the play, " I had given suck, and know how tender 'tis to love the bebe that milks me: I would, while it was smiling in my face, Have pluck'd my nipple from his bon...

... middle of paper ... allows for much more accessibility in understanding the movie due to its rich and detailed text. The two mediums of exchange share a lot of similar aspects, but many of them are better understood in the context of the movie with having read and understood the play. Although the movie stays true to many occurrences in the play, however small changes have been made. The words or phrases used in each are the greatest difference because of the separate time frames. Phrases that are brought up from one to the other are for the purpose of better understanding the text. For example, the witches refer to Macbeth’s presence as “something wicked this way comes” which is altered in the movie as “It’s wicked out there.” Even though they have different meanings, the word “wicked” ties them together. The overall action of the movie follows right along with that of the play.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Men of Respect and Macbeth Essay

- Men of Respect and Macbeth      In 1991, William Shakespeare’s great play “Macbeth” was re-created into a modern day version titled “Men of Respect.” Was the plays textual fidelity lost in transition during the making of the film, or did the film show total loyalty and devotion to the text and the feelings of the play. A closer examination of the characters/lines, classification between good and evil, and the use of light and dark will compare the many differences and similarities between William Shakespeare’s “Macbeth” and William Reilly’s “Men of Respect.”      Set in present day New York (present as in 1991), the various warring kingdoms of the play become organized crime factions in t...   [tags: Compare Contrast Respect Macbeth Essays]

Better Essays
704 words (2 pages)

Essay on The Struggle between Good and Evil; in Macbeth

- Macbeth is without a doubt a play about evil. The play revolves around the bad and wicked qualities in human nature, but Shakespeare also contrasts this evil with the power of good. In this essay I will explore the ways in which Shakespeare contrasted good and evil in Macbeth. These contradictions start in the very beginning of the play, with the witches. In line 12, the witches say, “Fair is foul and foul is fair.” This is interesting as they are suggesting good and evil as being one. The witches’ line reflects on human nature as there are fair and foul parts to everyone....   [tags: macbeth, shakespeare, ]

Better Essays
1009 words (2.9 pages)

Essay Comparing Macbeth and Lady Macbeth

- William Shakespeare’s Macbeth tells the story of a general who commits regicide in order to become king. Early in the play, Macbeth is conflicted as to weather or not he wants to kill his kinsman the king. In the first two acts Macbeth is not portrayed as a ruthless killer; he is a sympathetic character who succumbs to the provocation of his wife and a prophecy foretold by three mysterious witches. In contrast, Lady Macbeth is a manipulative, immoral woman. Her ambition is so strong that she is willing to do anything to see her husband succeed....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Better Essays
1040 words (3 pages)

Compare and Contrast Rupert Brooke's The Solider with Wilfred Owen's Dulce

- Compare and Contrast Rupert Brooke's The Solider with Wilfred Owen's Dulce et Decorum Est. Although 'The Soldier' by Rupert Brooke and 'Dulce et Decorum Est' by Wilfred Owen are concerned with the common theme of war, the two poems contrast two very different views of war. 'The Soldier' gives a very positive view of war, whereas Owen's portrayal is negative to the extreme. Rupert Brooke's 'The Soldier' is very patriotic as Brooke loves his country and is ready to die for it. This perhaps is not surprising as it was written in the first few months of war when the whole country was swept by a tide of patriotic fervour....   [tags: English Literature]

Better Essays
1464 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on Comparing the Woman in A Woman to her Lover, and Lady Macbeth

- Macbeth’s and Lady Macbeth’s relationship is somewhat the reverse to the stereotypical relationship. Lady Macbeth is the dictator and Macbeth follows all her orders. Perhaps this is out of love for her or to keep her love or respect for him. Their so-called ‘love’ for each other is not that of a typical relationship. Lady Macbeth spoon-feeds her husband, telling hm what to do all the time, but this switches suddenly after the murder of Duncan. The woman in ‘A Woman to her Lover’ and Lady Macbeth are alike in many ways....   [tags: compare contrast]

Better Essays
2116 words (6 pages)

Macbeth vs. the Soviet Macbeth Essay

- Thesis: In Rupert Goold’s PBS version of Macbeth, he compares and contrasts the original Shakespearean play with the communistic dictator Macbeth of the modern day Soviet Union as portrayed by Sir Patrick Stewart. We can compare the Macbeth and the Soviet Macbeth in their vocal deliverances of their personal soliloquies. Both of their delivers are persuading and make you feel an emotional connection with the character. These soliloquies show that both men are thinking and are forming personal ideas....   [tags: Literacy Analysis ]

Better Essays
1010 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Fate in Beowulf, Grendel, and Macbeth

- Fate in Beowulf, Grendel, and Macbeth         Fate plays a significant role in the Old English epic poem Beowulf and William Shakespeare's play Macbeth.. The major events of the poem, such as the three killings by Beowulf and his own death, are said to have been predestined. In Macbeth, fate is so significant that it is personified by the Weird Sisters, who drive the action of the play. But if predestination exists, then there must be an agent that determines destiny. In Beowulf, God plays this role, and fate is generally accepted as God's will....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Better Essays
2183 words (6.2 pages)

Essay on Oedipus the King and Macbeth

- Oedipus the King and Macbeth Who would have thought that being a king would be so difficult. Oedipus and Macbeth are both kings that seem to have a lot of trouble staying king. The similarities do not stop there. Macbeth and Oedipus are similar in a variety of ways. The interesting thing is that they are also very different but still suffer the same fate. These similarities and differences teach us a valuable lesson about power. Oedipus and Macbeth have one main similarity ­they are kings who take a fall through faults of their own....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
643 words (1.8 pages)

Essay Comparing Washington and Macbeth: The Fate of a Nation

- Comparing Washington and Macbeth: The Fate of a Nation George Washington and MacBeth were two historic figures who were influential in determining the fate of their nation. Both were ambitious men living during perilous times, yet each charted a different course for himself and his country when faced with the lure of power. Washington fulfilled his ambitions by devoting his life to creating a nation, while MacBeth was ignorant his responsibilities to his country, in turn destroying it and himself....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Better Essays
502 words (1.4 pages)

Comparing The Murder of Duncan in Macbeth and The Assassination of Kennedy

- Comparing The Murder of Duncan in Macbeth and The Assassination of Kennedy There is a man who is a head of state. He is a very powerful man and is well liked by his subjects. The people love him. Then he is suddenly, inexplicably murdered. Someone is blamed for the murder, but the entire country knows the accused are innocent and are tools used in a cover-up. Does this situation sound bizarre. Does it sound like some work of fiction. Well, it is. It is the beginning of William Shakespeare's Macbeth....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
1778 words (5.1 pages)