Comparative Theory Essay: Ethnohistory and The Postcolonial Perspective

Comparative Theory Essay: Ethnohistory and The Postcolonial Perspective

Length: 1410 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In The Houses of History, selected and introduced by Anna Green and Kathleen Troup, the different theories of the twentieth century are broken down and specifics are introduced about each theory. Historians use these theories to study certain aspects of history and to be able to compare two theories to each other and the problems each theory addresses must be identified. With all aspects of history having some sort of connection, it would be better to take a holistic approach to the history of different eras. As we first read in Arnold earlier in the semester, "History is above all else an argument (Arnold 13)." Therefore, to compare two theories of history, the argument must begin with the facts of the theory and what that theory is used for, and then argue where it might have flaws or not connect history together.
Beginning with ethnohistory, which includes anthropology, the beginnings of the different studies of mankind are introduced, when the book then jumps to a postcolonial perspective the views of the future are pointed to the mistakes of the past. Each theory has a purpose to explaining the views and studies of different historians around the world. This essay will compare my views on ethnohistory combined with anthropology versus the views of postcolonial history. To start with anthropology, and outlining the timelines of mankind, one can start cumulating the facts around how humans have evolved throughout hundreds and thousands of years. Using anthropology as a theory of history is the ability to understand the social and cultural behaviors that connect the concept of human culture. As historians there are many benefits from using anthropology, studying the behaviors of human kind and all of its variations is a true...


... middle of paper ...


...d the study of linguistics has allowed postcolonial historians to get a view point from theses Indigenous cultures about the European influences they have encountered. Both of these theories benefit from each other, and are able to help historians elaborate on finding the facts and presenting them as a primary source. To consider these theories not to be main factors for historians would be a false statement, as historians in the twenty-first century, we must enable ourselves to use such theories because there are always issues to argue about and pulling from the past and engaging in it can complete our argument.



Works Cited

Arnold, John H. History a Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford UP, 2000. Print.
Green, Anna, and Kathleen Troup. The Houses of History: a Critical Reader in Twentieth-century History and Theory. New York: New York UP, 1999. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Comparative Perspective : International Child Abuse

- Comparative Perspective: International Child Abuse Social, Cultural, political, and legal aspects of other countries/ societies On the international spectrum, different parts of the world deal with child abuse on a different stand point. In some Caribbean countries such as Jamaica, there is not many laws against child abuse, because it is inherited into their culture. The differences, as shown in the article Fostering Resilience in Children at risk through a cultural therapy intervention in Kingston, Jamaica by Robertson-Hickling, H., Paisley, Guzder & Hickling, Frederick W, DM....   [tags: Child abuse, Domestic violence, Neglect, Abuse]

Powerful Essays
1059 words (3 pages)

The Article Rights Protection – Comparative Perspectives Essay

- The Article Rights Protection – Comparative Perspectives by Brian Galligan and Emma Larking explores the rights and protections that are sheltered by Australia’s various political institutions and whether the rights in Australia are adequate. It also explores the question on whether changes need to be made. Galligan and Larking discuss the UN’s charters as they relate back to Australia, going on to discuss the various Legislative and Judicial means of rights protection, as well as asking the question: Does Australia need a Bill of Rights....   [tags: International Law]

Powerful Essays
1143 words (3.3 pages)

Postcolonial Ideas And The Concept Of Decolonization Essay examples

- Nowadays, the global division of labour between countries, followed by the resource extraction in the Third World countries, specificity of the world’s economy and migration are showing largely inherited contours of the old colonial order. Thus, a debate regarding the question of whether a contemporary world is postcolonial or not is arising. The purpose of this essay is to critically discuss and analyse the debate, focusing firstly on a brief summary of postcolonial ideas and the concept of decolonization; secondly, the question will be discussed from the perspectives of neo-colonialism and new imperialism as those theories maintain the existence of the new forms of colonialism and argue...   [tags: Colonialism, Postcolonialism, Neocolonialism]

Powerful Essays
1911 words (5.5 pages)

Bhabha's Contribution to Postcolonial Theory Essay

- Colonialism is and has been a reality during previous centuries. As a political and economical reality it entailed significant consequences in the colonized country's politics, geographical maps, and people's lives, fates and temperaments. As the consequences are hard to ignore the writers of the formerly colonized countries never forgot to write about it and their people's lives before, during and after their country's colonization. As Emecheta is one of these writer who is born and brought up in Nigeria, a colony of British Empire until 1960, postcolonial approach is one of the most appropriate critical methods to deal with her narratives....   [tags: Sociology ]

Powerful Essays
2600 words (7.4 pages)

Essay about Postcolonial Criticism Of Postcolonial Literature

- Postcolonial Literature In Postcolonial criticism, it draws attention to issues of cultural differences in literary texts. It is one of the critical approaches that are considered to focuses on specific issues. These specific issues include gender, class, and sexual orientation. Postcolonial critics reject the claims to universalism and seek to show its limitations. It examines the representation of other cultures in literature and it shows how such literature is often silent on matters concerned with colonization and imperialism....   [tags: Colonialism, Postcolonialism, Culture]

Powerful Essays
778 words (2.2 pages)

Diverse Perspectives On Bureaucracy : A Comparative Book Review Essay

- Diverse Perspectives on Bureaucracy: A Comparative Book Review Intellectual History of Public Administration PADM 6610, Fall 2014 Instructor: Matthew S. Mingus, Ph.D. The Assignment of Comparative Book Review Li Cheng, Ph.D. Student in Public Administration Western Michigan University October 28, 2014   Diverse Perspectives on Bureaucracy: A Comparative Book Review Ackoff, L. R., & Rovin, S. (2005). Beating the System: Using creativity to outsmart bureaucracies. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler, 144 pages, $14.95 softcover, ISBN: 978-1-57675-330-9....   [tags: Bureaucracy, Max Weber, Public administration]

Powerful Essays
2278 words (6.5 pages)

A Radical- Socialist Feminism with a Postcolonial Approah Essay examples

- ... Through colonization and globalization this system of domination seeks to convert the more egalitarian societies. An example of this spread of domination is the white settler’s attitude towards conquering and taming the nature, which was forcefully embedded in the Native American culture. I am interested in exploring how the foundation of the issue, which is tied to women’s sexuality, plays out in the colonial context. To examine this, I will look at the institution of marriage and prove that it is a form of patriarchal colonization of women....   [tags: theory, oppression, revolution, education]

Powerful Essays
1266 words (3.6 pages)

Postcolonial Literature: Uncovering Western Myths Essay

- ... Earlier, I mentioned that most of the colonizers saw Africa as an opportunity to do good on their lives, to follow their beliefs of helping those in need in order to be closer to God. They felt this need for the people of Africa as well, and they wanted to help them educate themselves and become civilized by converting to Catholicism. The way in which the European white man does this is exactly how Derek Walcott (1986) refers to in his metaphore when he states “The violence of beast on beast is read as natural law, but upright man seeks his divinity by inflicting pain.” In other words, they manage to cause an extreme damage to the lives of African communities....   [tags: Ahebe's Things Fall Apart]

Powerful Essays
1296 words (3.7 pages)

Hybridity and National Identity in Postcolonial Literature Essay

- Hybridity and National Identity in Postcolonial Literature        Every human being, in addition to having their own personal identity, has a sense of who they are in relation to the larger community--the nation. Postcolonial studies is the attempt to strip away conventional perspective and examine what that national identity might be for a postcolonial subject. To read literature from the perspective of postcolonial studies is to seek out--to listen for, that indigenous, representative voice which can inform the world of the essence of existence as a colonial subject, or as a postcolonial citizen....   [tags: Literature Essays Literary Criticism]

Powerful Essays
2599 words (7.4 pages)

Postcolonial Advancements Essay

- From the 17th through 20th centuries Western Empires experienced increased ascendency, a result of industrial, technological, and medical advancements. The aggregation of these innovations fostered territorial domination in areas previously inaccessible. The expropriation and commodification of health care and biomedicine occurred under the imperial regime. Once global conflict brought the colonial era to an end, a human rights regime was introduced. Postcolonial health’s bureaucracies were ideologically distinct from previous hegemons, yet their approaches were comparable....   [tags: Industrial, Technological, Medical]

Powerful Essays
1033 words (3 pages)