Comparative And Contrastive Analysis Of Films Rabbit Proof Fence Essay

Comparative And Contrastive Analysis Of Films Rabbit Proof Fence Essay

Length: 1027 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Comparative and Contrastive Analysis of the Films Rabbit-Proof Fence and Trudell:
Hidden Genocide and Stolen Generations
“This people... make me sick!” (Rabbit-Proof Fence). Although these words expressed by young Molly Craig in Rabbit-Proof Fence are not considered grammatically correct, they reveal the true feelings of the aboriginal people around the world toward the dominating settlers of their land. Trudell and Rabbit-Proof Fence tell a similar story in different ways. John Trudell, in the documentary Trudell, explains his life fighting for Native Americans’ rights during the Alcatraz Takeover, whereas in Rabbit-Proof Fence, Philip Noyce tells a story of the lives of the Aboriginal People during the enactment of the Aboriginal Protection Act. Trudell supports his explanations by describing the conflict between Native Americans and the government during the 1970’s. Noyce supports his telling in Rabbit-Proof Fence by illustrating the escape of three aboriginal girls from a native settlement where they were forced to live, back to their home in Western Australia during the 1930’s. The purpose of these two movies is to point out the aboriginals struggles in order to reveal the social injustice around the world. Trudell writes in a direct tone as Noyce approaches his film in an expressive manner; however, both target a mature audience. The films Trudell and Rabbit-Proof Fence depict the lives of native cultures dominated by Western ideology; however, the disruption of “fixity,” prejudice, and the governments fear of aboriginals is intricately illustrated in Rabbit-Proof Fence, allowing viewers to empathize with the people who struggled to keep their traditional ways in spite of the Eurocentric philosophy takeover.
The document...


... middle of paper ...


...gle of American Indians in the 1970’s against a racist government, proving that determination is a universal language that transcends all subjectifications. The true story of Rabbit-Proof Fence illustrates how a corrupt and ignorant government can lead three girls to defy all alleged characteristics of their people, the Aboriginals, and become what the government feared most: free. Rabbit-Proof Fence depicted a heart-wrenching story of young girls and, as a result, enlightened minds more effectively than Trudell. Granted all beings are created equal, one must not allow the stereotypes devised on others dictate their beliefs on a particular group or place. In the grand scheme of things everything is connected. Just as the philosopher Allen Watts reasoned, “You are something the whole universe is doing in the same way that a wave is something the whole ocean is doing.”

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Contrastive Analysis : A Comparative Study Of A Pair Of Languages Essay

- Contrastive analysis ( CA ) is the systematic study of a pair of languages with a view to identifying their structural differences and similarities between the first language and the target language . Contrastive Analysis was extensively used in the 1960s and early 1970s as a method of explaining why some features of a Target Language were more difficult to acquire than others. Contrastive analysis is concerned with the comparison of two languages for the purpose of translation and foreign language teaching ....   [tags: Linguistics, Language acquisition, Second language]

Better Essays
1696 words (4.8 pages)

The Tale of Peter Rabbit and Voices in the Park Essay

- Moebius’ definition of intangible and invisible includes the vast array of human emotion and experiences from love to death through to responsibility and truth beyond the individual. His ideas are corroborated by Bader’s comment that they are about sensations and emotions, which provoke a shift in the reader’s paradigms (Moebius, 2009). This essay will look at how Potter and Browne convey these ideas using Moebius’ codes and exploring the concept of relationships concluding with how Potter and Browne illustrate their views on childhood....   [tags: The Tale of Peter Rabbit]

Better Essays
1655 words (4.7 pages)

Analysis of Beatrix Potter's The Tale of Peter Rabbit Essay example

- The Tale of Peter Rabbit was a fictional story for children written by Beatrix Potter. The main character of the story was Peter Rabbit, who had three sisters by the names of Flopsy, Mopsy, and Cotton-tail. The four bunnies lived with their mother, Mrs. Rabbit, underneath a huge tree in the woods. All the characters displayed the element of anthropomorphic because they are dressed in human clothing and display human characteristics such as walking straight up on their hind legs. The three sisters were wearing a pink to reddish cloak, Peter Rabbit a blue jacket with brown shoes, and the mother a blue chambermaid dress....   [tags: tale of peter rabbit]

Better Essays
509 words (1.5 pages)

A Rabbit Who Never Stood a Chance Essay

- In Lab Rabbit Strongly Recommends Cover Girl Waterproof Mascara For Sensitive Eyes published in The Onion, the author who remained unknown, does a splendid job in mocking the Cover Girl magazine in respect to the way they cruelly treat animals to test their products, not caring what the after effects are. The author writes the article in the rabbits point of view, as if it were the rabbit telling the story, this gives the article a more personal feel as it is read. The author’s purpose for this piece of literature is to inform as well as entertain the reader, given the way the article was narrated, in addition to some particularly funny but also gory details....   [tags: cover girl, lab rabbit, animal testing]

Better Essays
659 words (1.9 pages)

The Rabbit Proof Fence Is A Symbol Of Love, Home, And Security Essay

- The Rabbit-Proof Fence to some was a source of employment, others was a division to keep rabbits from continuing to reproduce but “For the three runaways, the fence was a symbol of love, home, and security” (109). These three runaways were half-caste children, meaning their mothers are Aborigines and their fathers are white. The Australian government believed they were doing the right thing by removing these half-caste children from the Aborigine community, and stripping them from their families....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Rabbit-Proof Fence]

Better Essays
1120 words (3.2 pages)

The Tale of Peter Rabbit by Beatrix Potter and Voices in the Park by Anthony Browne

- Moebius’ definition of intangible and invisible covers the vast array of human emotion and experiences from love to death through to responsibility and a truth beyond the individual. Corroborated by Bader’s comment they are about sensations and emotions provoking a shift in the reader’s paradigms (Moebius, 2009). This essay will look at how Potter and Browne convey these ideas using Moebius’ codes and exploring the concept of relationships concluding with how Potter and Browne illustrate their views on childhood....   [tags: Tale of Peter Rabbit]

Better Essays
1528 words (4.4 pages)

The Game of Life in Rabbit, Run Essay

- The Game of Life in Rabbit, Run       Perhaps all our lives are simply a game, a game to which society sets the rules and to which we adapt.  In John Updike's novel, Rabbit, Run, the protagonist, Harry "Rabbit" Angstrom lives his life by the rules of the game of basketball.  Rabbit is a man who has, until the beginning of the book, played by society's rules.  But Rabbit's ambivalence is different from that of those around him; he has trouble communicating, and as a result he is often misunderstood and is constantly frustrated by the actions and expectations of others (Regehr).   In high school, Rabbit was a first rate basketball player and now, in his late twenties, is a middle-class man;...   [tags: Updike Rabbit Run Essays Papers]

Better Essays
2399 words (6.9 pages)

Updike's Rabbit Essay

- Updike's Rabbit As the gap between homo sapiens and their uncivilized ancestors widens, reproduction looses its value as the most important means to continuing the species. For humanity to progress in an increasingly modern and complex world, men must be required to think of themselves in broader terms. Rabbit Angstrom cannot understand that he could find meaning in life if he devalued the importance he places on sex. He is unable to accept the realities of life in twentieth century America and the role he must accept....   [tags: Updike Rabbit Run]

Better Essays
761 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Search for Freedom in John Updike's Of the Farm and Rabbit, Run

- Search for Freedom in John Updike's Of the Farm and Rabbit, Run John Updike is often celebrated for his novels that depict men struggling against responsibility or enduring personal endeavors. These characters represent a family of weak individuals facing serious emotional turmoil. They are indecisive and self-indulgent, juggling their problems with their personal duties. Two excellent examples are Joey Robinson, a thirty-five-year-old advertising consultant in Of the Farm, and Harry "Rabbit" Angstrom, a gadget salesman in Rabbit, Run....   [tags: Rabbit Run Essays]

Better Essays
2512 words (7.2 pages)

Essay on The Representation of Youths in Contrasting Films

- The Representation of Youths in Contrasting Films All media text contain messages. These can be positive or negative. A positive message is a true-to-life representation, where individuals and groups are given a positive image. A negative message is a untrue and exaggerated stereotype, often see the individual or group from a poor perspective. An example of a positive message demonstrated by media text is the speech given by Tony Blair during the suicide bomb attack on London on Thursday 7th June 05....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1114 words (3.2 pages)