Comparative Analysis of A Few Good Men Essay

Comparative Analysis of A Few Good Men Essay

Length: 1375 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The motion picture A Few Good Men challenges the question of why Marines obey their superiors’ orders without hesitation. The film illustrates a story about two Marines, Lance Corporal Harold W. Dawson and Private First Class Louden Downey charged for the murder of Private First Class William T. Santiago. Lieutenant Daniel Kaffee, who is known to be lackadaisical and originally considers offering a plea bargain in order to curtail Dawson’s and Downey’s sentence, finds himself fighting for the freedom of the Marines; their argument: they simply followed the orders given for a “Code Red”. The question of why people follow any order given has attracted much speculation from the world of psychology. Stanley Milgram, a Yale psychologist, conducted an experiment in which randomly selected students were asked to deliver “shocks” to an unknown subject when he or she answered a question wrong. In his article, “The Perils of Obedience”, Milgram concludes anyone will follow an order with the proviso that it is given by an authoritative figure. Two more psychologists that have been attracted to the question of obedience are Herbert C. Kelman, a professor at Harvard University, and V. Lee Hamilton, a professor at the University of Maryland. In their piece, Kelman and Hamilton discuss the possibilities of why the soldiers of Charlie Company slaughtered innocent old men, women, and children. The Marines from the film obeyed the ordered “Code Red” because of how they were trained, the circumstances that were presented in Guantanamo Bay, and they were simply performing their job.
The question of why these Marines obeyed the “Code Red” may be answered by Stanley Milgram’s conclusions from his experiment on obedience. When asked by Kaffee, while...


... middle of paper ...


...mi Moore. Columbia Pictures, 1992. Film.
Baumrind, Diana. “Review of Stanley Milgram’s Experiments on Obedience”. Writing & Reading for ACP Composition. Ed. Thomas E. Leahey and Christine R. Farris. New York: Pearson Custom Publishing, 2009. 224-229. Print.
Kelman, Herbert C., Hamilton, V. Lee. “The My Lai Massacre: A Military Crime of Obedience”. Writing & Reading for ACP Composition. Ed. Thomas E. Leahey and Christine R. Farris. New York: Pearson Custom Publishing, 2009. 266-277. Print.
Mcleod, Saul. Obedience in Psychology. Simply Psychology, 2007. Web. 6 November 2011.
Milgram, Stanley. “The Perils of Obedience”. Writing & Reading for ACP Composition. Ed. Thomas E. Leahey and Christine R. Farris. New York: Pearson Custom Publishing, 2009. 212-224. Print.
Powers, Rod. About.com, US Military. Military Orders: To Obey or Not to Obey? N.D. Web. 6 November 2011.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparative Analysis Of ' The Perils Of Obedience ' Essay

- Comparative Analysis Obedience to authority and willingness to obey an authority against one’s morals has been a topic of debate for decades. Stanley Milgrim, a Yale psychologist, conducted a study in which his subjects were commanded by a person in authority to initiate lethal shocks to a learner; his experiment is discussed in detail in the article “The Perils of Obedience” (Milgrim 77). Milgrim’s studies are said to be the most “influential and controversial studies of modern psychology” (Levine).While the leaner did not actually receive fatal shocks, an actor pretended to be in extreme pain, and 60 percent of the subjects were fully obedient, despite evidence displaying they believed wh...   [tags: Stanford prison experiment, Milgram experiment]

Strong Essays
1257 words (3.6 pages)

A Comparative Analysis of Lincoln's Gettysburg Address and Lee’s Letter to His Son

- Address Your Sons (A Comparative Analysis of Lincoln's Gettysburg Address and Lee’s Letter to His Son) Margaret Mitchell once said: “They knew that love snatched in the face of danger and death was doubly sweet for the strange excitement that went with it.” The Civil war was a trying time for the American people, whether they were on the battlefield or at home. Although the name is quite deceiving, there was nothing civil about this war.I was fought with the violence and brutality that would define a century....   [tags: emotionally, opposing positions, slavery]

Strong Essays
600 words (1.7 pages)

A Few Good Men Clip Analysis Essay

- Hundreds of movies are released every year. Filmmakers try to create the next jaw-dropping movie that audiences will stand in line for hours and pay top dollar to see. The key to success is finding ideas that appeal to a mass audience. Viewers are the lifeline of any production company so making something for everyone is a savvy business move for the film industry. To cover all bases, there are over fourteen different genres of movies. Film making is not a solo effort. It is a collaboration between the actors, directors, producers and other key contributors....   [tags: Film Analysis ]

Strong Essays
1129 words (3.2 pages)

Analysis Of ' A Few Good Men ' Essay

- How can one explain the atrocities of Abu Ghraib or the horrors of Auschwitz. How could enlisted men and women, most college aged, commit the inhumane abuse of Abu Ghraib and the genocide of Auschwitz. The average reader could not begin to understand the power given to authority in military life; this power is expressed as one of the main themes of the courtroom drama “A Few Good Men” . The story is laden with the idea of how power is given to rank; it follows the story of Lt. James Kafee as he begins to understand how much different military life is than civilian....   [tags: Marine, United States Marine Corps, Royal Marines]

Strong Essays
1243 words (3.6 pages)

Comparative Analysis of Local and Imported Mobile Phones Essay

- Comparative Analysis Between Local and Imported Mobile Phones in Terms of Feature and Functionality Mobile phones are abounded in the Philippines. Nowadays, most Filipinos, rich or poor, are hooked in mobile phones. Over the years, mobile phones have evolved and as of today, they have spectacular features that are useful to its users. Mobile phones become very essential to its users because it combines different features in one gadget only. Radio, camera, music player, television and other wonderful features were added by the phone makers to a typical texting phone making the mobile phone an all around gadget....   [tags: comparative analysis, feature, fuctionality]

Free Essays
1859 words (5.3 pages)

A Few Good Men Essay

- Obedience is a widely debated topic today with many different standpoints from various brilliant psychologists. Studying obedience is still important today to attempt to understand why atrocities like the Holocaust or the My Lai Massacre happened so society can learn from them and not repeat history. There are many factors that contribute to obedience including situation and authority. The film A Few Good Men, through a military court case, shows how anyone can fall under the influence of authority and become completely obedient to conform to the roles that they have been assigned....   [tags: Milgram experiment, Stanford prison experiment]

Strong Essays
1024 words (2.9 pages)

Comparative Analysis Of Cosmopolitanism And Communitarianism Essay

- Comparative Analysis between Cosmopolitanism and Communitarianism There are several different approaches to Human Rights expressed in society. Whether it 's Kant, Hegel, Arendt, Cosmopolitanism Or Communitarianism each one consist of its own unique perspective and share some similar values. Throughout this analysis comparing and contrasting both Cosmopolitanism or Communitarianism will be expressed moreover what they mean where they come from and how each one is analyzed between one another will all be written in this comparative analysis....   [tags: Morality, Law, Civil society, Human rights]

Strong Essays
1186 words (3.4 pages)

Analysis of 12 Angry Men Essay

- In viewing 12 Angry Men, we see face to face exactly what man really is capable of being. We see different views, different opinions of men such as altruism, egoism, good and evil. It is no doubt that human beings possess either one or any of these characteristics, which make them unique. It is safe to say that our actions, beliefs, and choices separate us from animals and non-livings. The 20th century English philosopher, Martin Hollis, once said, “Free will – the ability to make decisions about how to act – is what distinguishes people from non-human animals and machines 1”....   [tags: 12 Angry Men Essays]

Free Essays
1246 words (3.6 pages)

A Few Good Men Film Essay

- A Few Good Men Essay In the film, A Few Good Men, characters such as the lead role, Lieutenant Daniel Kaffee (played by Tom Cruise) are portrayed to be leaders in society. I believe the movie's main focus was actually on how different a person can be because of something one person says to them. I also believe that one of the movie's main ideas was how to work people with words. This is especially true when Colonel Nathan R. Jessup (Jack Nicholson) is interrogated by Cruise. The way that Nicholson answers Cruise's questions is with such sophistication and knowledge that even though you know that he had his speech written out for him, it was delivered with such eloquence that it allows the...   [tags: movie essays]

Free Essays
606 words (1.7 pages)

Analysis of ‘Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck Essay

- Analysis of ‘Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck ‘Of Mice And Men' by John Steinbeck is a classic novel, tragedy, written in a social tone. The authorial attitude is idyllic, however, as the story develops it changes into skeptic. It is evident that Steinbeck knew the setting and places he is writing about. In my opinion Steinbeck drew the subject matter from his own experience of working on ranches, he was interested in special kinds of relationships among men working on ranches with him....   [tags: Mice Men John Steinbeck]

Strong Essays
1483 words (4.2 pages)