Comparative Analysis of A Catcher in the Rye by J.D Salinger and Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson

Comparative Analysis of A Catcher in the Rye by J.D Salinger and Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson

Length: 970 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

It is amazing that two completely different characters could not only be faced with an identical dilemma, but also both react in such comparable ways. The resemblance of the characters’ struggles because of alienation in the popular novels The Catcher in the Rye and Speak is astonishing. Alienation can be caused by many factors and result in many consequences. But it is interesting how the situations individuals face can be quite similar. Within Salinger’s novel, The Catcher in the Rye, and Anderson’s novel, Speak, both protagonists are alienated by those around them. As a result, they must endure the negative effects of this isolation and, ultimately it leads both these individuals to alienate themselves.
The alienation experienced by the main characters of The Catcher in the Rye and Speak are alike in the fact that they are alienated by similar types of people, and for the same reasons. Holden and Melinda are both alienated by their peers. They do not fit in to any of the groups amongst the adolescents their age. The feeling of being isolated is shown in Holden’s quote, “Everybody sticks together in these dirty little goddam cliques. The guys that are on the basketball team stick together, the Catholics stick together, [...]” (Salinger, 170) and again in Melinda’s quote, “We fall into clans: Jocks, Country Clubbers, [...] I am clanless” (Anderson, 14). Their statements are so similar that there is no doubt they are being tortured with the same feelings of loneliness from being isolated. The two characters are alienated for the same reasons: they both do not know how to properly function within society. They were not properly educated in socialization; therefore do not fit in amongst the others their age. Holden demonstrates his ...


... middle of paper ...


...nderson, 107). The novels demonstrate that humans react to alienation by choosing to alienate themselves rather than allow others to alienate them. The protagonists intentionally withdrew themselves from society before society could hurt them by denying them acceptance. They equally fear rejection which is common among human kind.
The theme of alienation has been depicted by two different characters in a resembling series of events. The two protagonists were alienated by their peers, inflicting negative consequences they must undergo. Both characters are finally pushed to alienating themselves rather than being alienated. In conclusion, the struggles both characters undergo are practically identical to one another. They have experienced alienation in such similar ways that you must ask yourself: are all those who suffer from alienation alike in more ways than one?

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Heroes Are People Who Overcome Antagonism in a Mature Way, as in "Twisted" by Laurie Halse Anderson

- A person who overcomes antagonistic and unnecessary issues in a mature and powering manor. That is the definition of a hero to me. Someone who is being hurt and sees others hurt from the actions and takes charge and does everything in his power to change it. Someone who puts others before themselves and acts in the most chivalrous way. The definition of a hero is different for everyone. Some one might think of a hero as someone who can lift a car and put it on their back, or gives a dying person their kidney....   [tags: heroes, Twisted, Laurie Halse Anderson,]

Better Essays
915 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson

- Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson Speak, by Laurie Halse Anderson, is a story written in the first person about a young girl named Melinda Sordino. The title of the book, Speak, is ironically based on the fact that Melinda chooses not to speak. The book is written in the form of a monologue in the mind of Melinda, a teenage introvert. This story depicts the story of a very miserable freshman year of high school. Although there are several people in her high school, Melinda secludes herself from them all....   [tags: Anderson Speak Teenage Depression]

Better Essays
1740 words (5 pages)

Chains, By Laurie Halse Anderson Essay examples

- “The American Revolution was a beginning, not a consummation” (Wilson). The lives of New York slaves was worse than ever during the American Revolution. The Revolution was a successful but rough phase of America’s history. The Revolution began through British control so when the people wanted to become independent, war broke out. The life of Isabel in Chains represents the everyday life of a slave during this time period. In the novel by Laurie Halse Anderson, she focuses on two main characters and one main event....   [tags: American Revolutionary War]

Better Essays
1193 words (3.4 pages)

Chains By Laurie Halse Anderson Essay examples

- The era of civil unrest in the 18th century by the patriots, or rebels, to unseat the loyalists or king’s people and gain freedom and liberty, and henceforth; independence was clearly outlined by Laurie Halse Anderson in her book “Chains”. It is the aim of this paper to bring forth the contributions of the slaves or servants of that time in accomplishing this mission and the relevance of the teenage-aged group of modern society. Chains The novel Chains by Laurie Halse Anderson is about a young girl who went through a hard time being a slave during the Revolutionary war....   [tags: Slavery, British Empire]

Better Essays
753 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson

- What if you were raped and nobody knew about it. In the book Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson, Melinda was raped and she didn’t tell anyone. Before school started Melinda was at a party and she was drunk. She was raped in the woods that night by an older senior , Andy Evans. She called the police and she was blamed for calling the police on the party but, its because she never told anyone she was raped. Through many different events and people Melinda changes from being shy to feeling confident....   [tags: melinda, rachel, andy]

Better Essays
977 words (2.8 pages)

Overview: Twisted by Laurie Halse Andersone Essay

- Is choosing the wrong path to find the real you a bad thing. In a story generally the protagonist pulls on different types of archetypes to learn from their mistakes and be different with those strengths. In the novel, Twisted by Laurie Halse Anderson, the protagonist, Tyler needs to go through phases in order to ultimately achieve the goal of self-identity that not necessarily he wants but the society accepts. So the journey begins, with Tyler in the front seat, searching for a person he could be, he uses his friends, friends of friends, his physical surroundings, to be one person in all of his obstacles....   [tags: tyler, man, change]

Better Essays
1476 words (4.2 pages)

Use of Characterization in Laurie Halse Anderson's Books Essay

- Laurie Halse Anderson has written for all ages, but her most popular books are those written for young adults. These books include Speak, Catalyst, Prom, and Wintergirls. A common trait found in all of these books is her spectacular use of characterization. Some reviewers have criticized Catalyst and Fever 1793 for weaknesses in characterization and plotting but all of Laurie Halse Anderson's books remain highly popular with young readers, who identify with Anderson's honest portrayal of adolescence....   [tags: Speak, Catalyst, Prom, Wintergirls]

Better Essays
1511 words (4.3 pages)

Essay about Theme of Friendship in Chains by Laurie Halse Anderson

- On July 20, 1958, a doctor by the name of Artemio Bracho contemplated the idea of a World Friendship Day. The World Friendship is a foundation that honors friendship and fellowship among all human beings, regardless of race, color or religion. This day has been recognized in several countries and is used today. Friendship is established on loyalty and being there for your friend in their time of need. In Chains by Laurie Halse Anderson, the protagonist, Isabel, created several relationships with other characters that were constructed on loyalty....   [tags: Loyalty, Bond]

Better Essays
823 words (2.4 pages)

Wintergirls by Laurie Halse Anderson Essay

- Wintergirls is a book related to eating disorders. The author’s purpose of writing this book is to inform readers what a person with an eating disorder. It depicts the inner and outer conflicts that characters like Lia and Cassie face with disorder. It all began with a competition between two characters of who can be the skinniest. Cassie dies in the attempt of winning the game. Lia, the main character in this novel, always keeps track of her food consumption. For example, one breakfast morning, Lia said she didn’t want “a muffin (410),…orange (75),…toast (87),…waffles (180)” (Anderson 5)....   [tags: eating disorders]

Better Essays
1034 words (3 pages)

Laurie Halse Anderson's Speak Essay

- ... That’s why he used symbolism in the story to make it more interesting. In another example, Melinda says “I can see us, living in the woods, her wearing that A, me with an S maybe, S for silent, for stupid, for scared. S for silly. For shame” (Anderson 101). This shows that Melinda is emotionally unstable and thinks of herself in many bad ways such as her being dumb and afraid. It also shows that Melinda is kind of mad at herself for the person she is. For that, she makes herself feel ashamed....   [tags: novel, character analysis]

Better Essays
1275 words (3.6 pages)