Community Power and Participatory Decision-Making Essay example

Community Power and Participatory Decision-Making Essay example

Length: 1394 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

At its first level of conception, the possibilities of a study focused on the community of Bautista appeared endless; it quickly became obvious that certain preferences would need to be supported over others. These preferences provided several points of reflection based on the limitations, details, and depth facilitated by methodological choices. It is no surprise that no researcher can do a thoroughly exhaustive study that can take into account all dimensions of a decision-making process. Indeed, many challenges were met over the course of evaluating the community within the current research. Theoretical assumptions have been made and discussed when necessary, and methodological limitations were acknowledged as needed: limitations of time, size, and scope as well as limitations of the research design.

There were several things that the researcher hoped to observe during this study. One of those was evidence that the community residents recognize their potential that they can have power. The researcher was convinced that the constituents wanted more than being a disenfranchised people but to become empowered members of their community.

This thesis makes a contribution to the ways in which the context of power is studied for their propensity to identify participatory processes in relation to decision-making. It has highlighted the critical understanding that participation in decision-making demonstrates power. The methodological, theoretical and substantive contributions are highlighted in the related literature; the core contributions are the in-depth insights bringing to light the controversial case of separating Bautista from Brgy. Sampalov IV. By unpacking a unique case of power research in a resettlement area, this th...


... middle of paper ...


...s was compared to the participatory mechanisms of the barangay officials which merely supported government views, the former can foster resistance to spur more people into action. The efforts of the power-holders to establish a meritorious participation of the silenced people in decision-making were very debilitated and subjugated. A closer look at the legal aspect of participation in decision-making revealed that it was discriminatory and participation in general, was exploited to mobilize participation during implementation processes. In a positive light, even though inequality of power exists, there is more active participation when a controversial issue is at stake. Bargaining power for the purposes of decision-making between the powerful players allows the less powerful voices to be clamorous by popular pressure alongside collaborative forms of participation.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Community Power and Participatory Decision-Making

- The study was qualitative in nature as it helped in understanding and giving interpretations to behaviors, emotions, beliefs, texts, talk and relationships of the individuals in the community studied. The case study design, one of the formats used in qualitative research, was used to primarily determine the potentials of participation in decision-making to demonstrate power. The ability to describe and explain in detail aspects of processes in a social unit in their real social context is the main reason why this research adopted the case study design (Feliciano, 1994)....   [tags: Analysis, Dahl, Decision Approach]

Strong Essays
729 words (2.1 pages)

Community Power and Participatory Decision-Making Essay examples

- Attempts to define power have been traditionalistic, contentious and mundane despite the concept’s widespread use. Two salient features were presented for the controversial assumptions in defining power: power as domination and power as empowerment. In seeking to comprehensively reconcile the “contestedness” about power, Steven Lukes (2005) observes that how we conceive of power makes a difference to how we think and act in general especially in social contexts. The views of power can be a personal process where the interviews and the focus group served as helping the participants grapple with the controversy and discomfort surrounding the concept....   [tags: Power in Business]

Strong Essays
2295 words (6.6 pages)

Community Power and Participatory Decision-Making Essay example

- Critical theory appears unpopular probably because of its ideological bias as claimed by Pease, Form and Rytina (1970). Liebert and Imershein (1977) similarly assert that a common theoretical tendency in community research is a distinctly “political theme that tends to find the greatest efficacy and power, and indeed the most universal structure of power, to lie in a certain organized diversity, a pluralist state of subsystems within an integrated system of elites” (pp. 191-192). The primary aim of critical theory, as James Bohman (2005) notes, is to thwart oppression....   [tags: Karl Marx, Social Constructionism]

Strong Essays
1225 words (3.5 pages)

Decision Making For The Organizational Behavior Community Essay example

- Decisions are faced everyday, by every person. We take into account risk in assessing how to react to these decisions. Yet each person’s motivation will dictate how much risk one is willing to accept, and how much one is willing to pass onto others. This is the essence of decision making. It is not as simple as simply going right or left; often times the choices are vast and the consequences can be far greater than imagined. In order to answer our decisions in good faith, and with hopes of personal benefit, one must first assess how they are looking at the world....   [tags: Motivation, Decision making, Decision theory]

Strong Essays
1234 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on The On Aeronautical Decision Making

- Pilots generally do not think about the model of decision-making they wish to follow when they are at the controls. They instead worry about key items that have a direct correlation to the safety of those onboard and the safety of the aircraft. In this article, O’Hare is concerned that a lot of effort has been put into educating and training pilots to make the right decision, but very little or none has been put towards aeronautical decision-making (ADM). This stems from the fact that as an aviation community we do not fully understand the ADM process, though we comprehend quite well the “prescriptive models of ADM” and can effectively train to them (O’Hare, 1992, p....   [tags: Decision making, Cognition, Risk]

Strong Essays
1083 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about Personal Decision Making : Advance Directives

- Advance Directives It is most important part of ethical decision making. Advance directives are the legal documents that are used by the patient to record future events if in case the patient lacks ability to make any kind decision regarding his/her health. There will be bunch of documents like living will, durable power of attorney for health care, advance health care directive or health care directive, Physician Orders for Life Sustaining Treatment (POLST) form, mental health advance directive, etc....   [tags: Ethics, Health care, Decision making]

Strong Essays
1124 words (3.2 pages)

Personal And Societal Morals And Ethical Decision Making Essay

- Moral Management is the application or implementation of personal and societal morals/ethical codes to decision making providing the maximum moral outcome. With that there is a method for ethical decision making that is called “the Moral Compass”. This method has four lenses. First is purpose, “will this action serve worthwhile purpose”. Second is principle, “is this action consistent with relevant principles”. Third is people, “does this action respect the legitimate claims of the people likely to be affected”....   [tags: Decision making, Ethics, Cognition, Morality]

Strong Essays
1060 words (3 pages)

Risk Assessment Tools In Decision Making Essay

- Risk Assessment Tools in Decision Making Article Review Risk assessment is a tool especially used in decision-making by the scientific and regulatory community. In Making Good Decisions, Peter Montague discusses the use of risk assessment, points out its lack of usefulness in his opinion, and posits that the current use of risk assessment today is largely unethical. He states that "Risk Assessment is one way of making decisions, but it is not the only way, and it is not the best way." (Montague, date unknown, p.1) Decision making in itself carries a substantial amount of risk because decisions are made in a less-than-perfect world....   [tags: Decision Making Analysis]

Free Essays
1572 words (4.5 pages)

The Power of Rational Decision Making Essay

- Rational decision making is one of the most common problem solving methods and can be used to solve almost all problems. Rational decision making and problem solving processes can be explained in a logical manner. Effective leaders use rational decision making processes to identify the problem, think up solutions, evaluate alternatives along with select a solution, implement and evaluate the final solution. In rational decision making leaders analyze the problem to achieve the most efficient choice through different possible alternatives from different scenarios before making a selection....   [tags: School Leadership]

Strong Essays
1454 words (4.2 pages)

Decision-Making Models Essay

- Decision-Making Models      There are several decision-making models to choose from in any given situation. Some of these models available on the Internet are the Responsible Decision-Making Model, the Ethical Decision-Making Model, the Ethics Toolkit PLUS Model, the Vigilant Decision-Maker Process, and some basic ones as well. In general, all decision-making models are the processes we use to make well-thought out decisions. There are three major elements of all decision-making models. These three elements are: how are criteria determined, how are alternatives generated, and how are alternatives evaluated against criteria (Scholl, p....   [tags: Responsible Decision-Making Model]

Strong Essays
807 words (2.3 pages)