Colonization and the True Historical Fact of Malintzin Essays

Colonization and the True Historical Fact of Malintzin Essays

Length: 767 words (2.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Camilla Townsend uses the book Malintzin's Choices to reject the false stories that concealed Malintzin's actual life. The book is used as a way to give insight into the issues of colonization and conquest. She tries to give the men and women who lived and died in those days their dignity back. Townsend wants to place a much-abused historical figure back into her proper historical context. The book makes Malintzin come alive as one who played an essential role through an epic transitional period in Mexican history. Townsend reminds us that the adolescent indigenous girl started her new life among the invaders as a slave. Townsend admits that a traditional biography of Malintzin is not possible, because there are not many sources. Although, the book does regularly pause for the consideration of Malintzin’s place and what her motivations may have been. This was shown along with the Spaniards and indigenous people who helped in the forces that grappled Moctezuma's power.
There are two problems Townsend writing about Malintzin encountered. First, the lack of sources. Secondly, her life was unusual. Townsend's approaches to these problems are worth considering. Her primary solution to the first problem is to place Malintzin's life in the context of her times, explaining how complex Malintzin's gender and ethnic identity was, her role in the conquest, and describing the lives of her descendants as well. A lot of the book examines the conquest process, emphasizing point of views and experiences from the indigenous people. Townsend takes a look at both the conquest historiography and sources.
Townsend organizes her narration of these events around the life and role of Malintzin. She takes the attention off of Cortes because she wants...


... middle of paper ...


...d does so where she applies 21st century values to the 16th century. So, she does tell a good story, and the introduced facts are interesting but this should either be read as heavily-researched historical fiction or by people who aren't too arguable about things like fact versus fiction.
In Malintzin’s Choices, Townsend displays expertise while pulling together the information she has gotten from published and archived accounts. It highlights the significance of a woman’s life in possibly its most complete and sensible illustration yet. Townsend repositions Malintzin to allow her historic episodes to be better understood, despite the myths that have been around for too long. In the process, Townsend discloses very real, completely human stories behind the trans-Atlantic conflict and accommodation that was inherent in the Spanish invasion and occupation of Mexico.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

True Knowledge or Bias and Selection? Essay

- In the past, as well as in current times, both historians and scientists have strived to present knowledge that is free of bias, a prejudice in favor or against one thing, and selection, the act of having a preference when carefully choosing the most suitable thing. In a nutshell, they try their best to present knowledge that is objective and impartial in nature. Nonetheless, there are times, in which the knowledge that they present to us contains certain hints of bias and selection. Hence, the knowledge is to be considered as subjective and representative....   [tags: Human Intellect ]

Strong Essays
1587 words (4.5 pages)

European Colonisation Of The Americas Essay

- How did European colonisation of the Americas affect the society and culture of the continent’s indigenous people up to 1650. Focus on colonial region of Mexico The European colonisation of the Americas is often portrayed as a definitive turning point in which the culture of the natives was instantly driven to extinction (or at least altered beyond recognition). While this is certainly true in some cases, such as for the natives living on Caribbean islands, in other cases it is fair to say that native culture saw relative continuation....   [tags: Colonialism, Spanish colonization of the Americas]

Strong Essays
1502 words (4.3 pages)

The First Age Of Colonization Essays

- The first age of colonization, puts a spotlight on the birth of European exploration of the Americas and the peoples who inhabited them. Numerous countries of Europe sent adventurers to explore, with primary intentions to discover resources, to trade, and spread Catholicism to the “uncivilized” natives of the areas. Spain, after the Reconquista, started their golden age. After Columbus’ discovery of the new world, explorers and treasure ships made their way to the Americas. The Spanish conquest through South America was a huge success in terms of Spanish influence, power, and economy....   [tags: Spain, Spanish colonization of the Americas]

Strong Essays
736 words (2.1 pages)

Intelligent Design is a Fact, Not a Theory Essay

- There are things in the universe and on the planet that point to an intelligent design and that God is that Intelligent Designer. There are many unique items within animals, plants, and human beings. These items are just too unique and complex to have just happened. The intelligent design of these items points to an Intelligent Designer not just chance. Intelligent design is the study of patterns in nature, animals, and human beings that are best explained as the result of intelligence....   [tags: Intelligent Design is a Fact]

Strong Essays
1532 words (4.4 pages)

True Shakespeare or Not True shakespeare Essay

- Many historians and famous authors, such as Mark Twain and Sigmund Freud, have trouble believing that William Shakespeare truly wrote the plays published in his name. As TIME writer Jumanna Farousky wrote, “Doubters started questioning the true identity of the writer in the late 19th century. Ever since then, the theory of an alternate author has flirted with the mainstream as some scholars and researchers have tried to get the broader academic community to treat the question as a legitimate debate”....   [tags: Sir Francis Bacon was the true creator]

Strong Essays
1450 words (4.1 pages)

The Colonization Of The English Colonization Essay

- Discussions of early English colonization have often focused exclusively on the perspectives of the colonists and the colonial promoters and organizers, such as the commercial joint-stock companies. Beyond their role in the issuance of charters, the English Crown and its related bodies, such as the Privy Council, are given little consideration or confined to roles as secondary figures within the greater colonial narrative. The problem lies in the fact that imperial involvement and the politics of empire are frequently excluded from the English colonial narrative by scholars....   [tags: British Empire, Colonialism, United Kingdom]

Strong Essays
1250 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on The Wounded Knee Massacre : Hollywood Fiction Or Historical Fact?

- The Wounded Knee Massacre: Hollywood Fiction or Historical Fact. The United States government initially celebrated the Battle at Wounded Knee as the final conflict between Native Americans and the United States military - after which the western frontier was considered safe for the incoming settlers. Over 20 medals were awarded to the soldiers for their valor on the battlefield. However, the understanding has changed regarding what actually took place at Wounded Knee on December 29, 1890. The Hollywood version of the Battle of Wounded Knee accurately presents the case that the Battle at Wounded Knee was actually a massacre of the Sioux - the culminating act of betrayal and aggression carrie...   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
1418 words (4.1 pages)

The Colonization Of The Americas Essay

- The colonization of the Americas by the Spanish, starting in the late 15th century, was marked by the violent suppression and exploitation of the indigenous populations. Legitimized by royal support and proselytizing papal decree, the colonists expanded territory by force and enslaved natives for the purpose of labor. The colonists had differing views on the practices involving the natives and produced varying descriptions of them. The way in which these men and other settlers viewed the native cultures, practices, and achievements provided the justification or condemnation of the actions that unfolded around them....   [tags: Colonialism, Spanish colonization of the Americas]

Strong Essays
1337 words (3.8 pages)

A True and Exact History of the Island of Barbadoes Essay

- Whether native or foreign, the forced laborers discussed in the five historical documents—“A True and Exact History of the Island of Barbadoes”, “Description of a Slave Market in Rio de Janeiro”, “Notes on the Treatment of the Natives in Northeast Siberia”, “Mercury Mining in Huanacavelica and Silver Mining in Potosí”, and “The General Slavery at Achin”—were impelled to fulfill responsibilities and lead lives that were believably unnatural, being that those laborers forced to work were typically exposed to extreme and destitute living conditions due to the mandatory demands of their overseer, while those “enslaved” in the country of Sumatra were allowed profuse independency in comparison to...   [tags: Historical Documents]

Strong Essays
1338 words (3.8 pages)

Colonization in Literature Essay

- Our current world has been extremely shaped by colonization, but the rapid spread of its influence has neglected to minister to the diverse and significant traits of each country. In Margaret Atwood’s Surfacing, Atwood explores the effects colonization on Quebec’s cultural and social environment. With the expansion of the English language, French subculture has been slowly pushed back and forced to integrate with an Anglophonic culture. Along with integration of culture, comes the loss of the history and traditions that define a people....   [tags: Margaret Atwood's Surfacing, Quebec]

Strong Essays
829 words (2.4 pages)