The Cloak Of Competence

The Cloak Of Competence

Length: 916 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
"The Cloak of Competence"
Robert B. Edgerton is an anthropologist with interests in psychological and medical anthropology. His early work was focused on individual adaptation to differing ecological conditions on the one hand and mental retardation on the other. His interests in mental retardation led to books such as The Cloak of Competence, which will be analyzed in this paper and Lives in Process. His ecological interests produced The Individual in Cultural Adaptation, followed by Rules, Exceptions and Social Order. He then turned his attention to studies of deviant behavior (Alone Together) and mental illness (Changing Perspectives in Mental Illness with S. Plog).
In recent years, he has developed an interest in how people cope with the stresses of warfare, a focus that has led to several books (Like Lions They Fought, Mau Mau, The End of the Asante Empire, Warriors of the Rising Sun, Death or Glory, and Warrior Women and Hidden Heroism). This interest continues, as does his concern with the impact of cultural relativism on cultural theory, best seen in Sick Societies: Challenging the Myth of Primitive Harmony, published in 1992. Throughout his career, he has maintained an interest in the community adaptation of persons with mild mental retardation. Over the past 40 years Edgerton has also been a teacher and mentor in the Neuropsychiatric Institute at UCLA where he has received a lot of support for his research.
Robert Edgerton began studying mental disability in the late 1960s. Edgerton was interested to discover how deinstitutionalized intellectually disabled adults adapted to life in the community and how they coped with the stigma of being labeled mentally retarded. He argued that they utilized a 'cloak of competence' to hide both the stigma of their discredited past and their inherent incompetence.
Rather than taking the issue of intellectually disabled peoples' incompetence as unproblematic and given, Edgerton in his book has, in a different way, questioned the social and cultural assumptions that exist within notions of competence. He also argues that the concept of incompetence automatically take as fact notions of competence and seek to situate cultural interpretations of incompetence within this broader framework. In doing so the book contributes both to debates on labeling and competence and to cross-cultural studies of intellectual disability.
While acknowledging the diverse influences of capitalism, colonialism, urbanization, and industrialization on the perceptions and constructions of intellectual disability, this book also adds a new and significant dimension by including analysis of social and cultural notions of identity, personhood and selfhood.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Cloak Of Competence." 23 Feb 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Cultural Competency : Cultural Competence

- Cultural Competency Training Cultural Competence • What is it. • Why do we need it. • Where do we get it. According to Cross, Bazron, Dennis, and Isaacs (1989), cultural competence can be defined “as a set of congruent behaviors, attitudes, and policies that come together in a system, agency or among professionals and enable that system, agency or those professions to work effectively in cross-cultural situations”. Denboba, MCHB (1993) believes that cultural competence is a “set of values, behaviors, attitudes, and practices within a system, organization, program or among individuals and which enables them to work effectively cross culturally”....   [tags: Culture, Intercultural competence]

Research Papers
1022 words (2.9 pages)

Nuala Ní Dhomhnaill’s The Astrakhan Cloak Essay

- Nuala Ní Dhomhnaill’s The Astrakhan Cloak The Astrakhan Cloak, published in 1992, is a collection of poems by Nuala Ní Dhomhnaill. Several aspects of the book deserve notice from the reader, including structural and thematic elements that work to develop an overall sense of mystery, wonder, and loss. A significant theme of the poems in the collection is the dichotomy of the supernatural and civilized worlds, and the sense that there are forces in the world just beyond our perception and understanding....   [tags: Astrakhan Cloak]

Research Papers
2383 words (6.8 pages)

Essay on Competence Model : Competencies Training And Development

- The ASTD Competence Model serves to identify the competencies training and development professionals must exhibit in order to be successful in the field. The model consists of six foundational competencies, which include “business skills, global mindset, industry knowledge, interpersonal skills, personal skills, and technology literacy” (Anderson, Rothwell, & Naughton, 2013, p. 17). The model also identifies ten areas of expertise, which include “performance improvement, industrial design, training delivery, learning technologies evaluating learning impact, managing learning programs, integrated talent management, coaching, knowledge management, and change management” (Anderson et al., 2013)...   [tags: Skill, Competence, Four stages of competence]

Research Papers
1116 words (3.2 pages)

Definition Of Competence And Likability Essays

- A respectable speakers’ goal is to appear both competent and likable. They aim to effectively communicate their message in such a way that the receiving party understands and agrees with their point. Whether speaking to a crowd of 1,000 people or a best friend, this underlying goal remains. Both competence and likability are factors in whether people trust or reject the speaker. If someone appears inept, they will not be viewed as a reliable source for the subject at hand. On the flip side, if someone appears unapproachable, cold, or unfriendly, they will have a harder time convincing people to stand by them, as people tend to trust those who are likable....   [tags: Competence, Incompetence, Term, Leadership]

Research Papers
826 words (2.4 pages)

Concepts Of Cultural Competence And The Terry Cross Intercultural Competence Model

- Introduction Cultural competence is defined as the capacity for effective interaction with persons from diverse cultures and socio-economic setups, more so at the workplace. The concept of cultural competence focuses on and individual’s cultural worldview and awareness, recognition of diverse cultural practices and views, his/her attitude to these differences and the ability to accommodate and interact effectively with people from diverse cultures; that is, the individual’s cross cultural skills (Vaugh & Martin, 2007)....   [tags: Culture, Health care, Competence]

Research Papers
921 words (2.6 pages)

Social Competence Defined As The Impact Of Social Behavior Essay example

- Social competence is essential to living and participating in society, but it is a term that has been defined in many different ways. According to Stichter (2016), “ competence is defined as the impact of social behavior” (p. 02). Meanwhile Shujja (2015) says, “ competence refers to socially effective actions...unrelated to cognitive ability” (p. 02). Fernandez (2015) defines social competence in an even more complicated manner. He states that social competence includes: social cognition, regulation of attention, decoding and interpretation of information, the ability to empathize, regulation of behavior, use of appropriate eye contact and gestures, and the ability to initi...   [tags: Competence, Skill, Sociology, Psychology]

Research Papers
1927 words (5.5 pages)

Intercultural Communication Competence Into Language Learning Classes Essay

- This article outlines a course guide where students partake in community service projects over the course of sixteen weeks in order to interact and communicate with people from other cultures. The course consists of various components that include having the students participate both in the classroom and at the community service site, examinations to test students’ growth in intercultural communication, and self-reflection papers. The expected results for this course, which run parallel to testimonies given in the articles from students that took the course, include increase in cultural awareness and intercultural communication skills....   [tags: Culture, Intercultural competence, Communication]

Research Papers
913 words (2.6 pages)

Review For Enhancing Cultural Competency Essay

- ANALYSIS OF REVIEW FOR ENHANCING CULTURAL COMPETENCY IN NEW NURSING GRADUATES Cultural competency is indispensable knowledge and skill that allows nurses to deliver optimal care for patients with diverse cultural backgrounds. Inadequate knowledge and skills of other cultural traditions have continued to increase racial and ethnic inequalities in healthcare for minority groups (Alpers & Hanssen, 2014; Dunagan et al. 2013; Long, 2012). As nurses interact with clients they provide nursing care, health education and advocacy at any point in need (Bearskin, 2011; Calvillo, 2009)....   [tags: Culture, Nursing, Cultural competence]

Research Papers
1480 words (4.2 pages)

Invisible Cloak Essay

- I could almost taste the aroma of machine oil with just a hint of tobacco as I took a deep breath in an effort to calm myself. The janitor’s room was dark and silent, so unlike the hustle and bustle of the fourth grade classroom that I had just been kidnapped from. As my eyes adjusted to the dim lighting, my attention jumps from object to object. Drills, saws, tool boxes and hung on the walls were all sorts of gadgets that were begging to be explored. After a second deep breath, reality dashed any hope of exploration....   [tags: Personal Growth]

Research Papers
1541 words (4.4 pages)

Competence Essay

- Competence Introduction: Global competitive pressures, liberalized economic policies, ever-changing customer expectations and technological advancement have put excessive demands on business organizations. In order to survive and thrive business organizations need to prepare themselves in such a way that they can anticipate future changes and pro-act to deal with them. In the endeavour of forecasting change in the environment, human capital of organizations will play very critical role. A central component of human capital is competence....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
3472 words (9.9 pages)

They raise fundamental questions concerning broader issues, such as concepts of humanness, sociality and the role that ideas of 'normality' play in the construction of identity. The consequences of these for intellectually disabled people are further talked about in terms of issues of power and social control. Some parts of Edgerton's book explore these issues and situates them within the problem of what, if anything, constitutes intellectual incompetence as an analytical category.
The general argument of the book is that the classificatory practices that assign a label of incompetence to intellectually disabled people must be understood within complex and shifting contextual, historical and cultural frameworks. These differences exist within a broad comparative basis, but also within individual life stories, as was pointed out by the lives of those in he book. While the label of mental retardation might control and oppress the lives of some who live with the title, it does not destroy them entirely. Instead these people do find different strategies to cope with their life experiences.
Not only do other cultures perceive incompetence and intellectual disability in diverse ways, but within Western societies construction of an intellectually disabled identity has also changed over time. The major role that medical and psychological interpretations of intellectual disability now play are a consequence of this, and, as Edgerton points out, these can have a profound and dislocating effect on the experiences of mentally disabled people and their families in other cultures.
Western conceptions of the term, different cultural perceptions of personhood and identity, and different cultural interpretations of competence and the causes of incompetence, profoundly affects the way in which people come to understand, relate to and treat mentally disabled people. Consequently, the criteria for social competence can be based on factors such as kinship ties, social interaction and family wealth which can help one decide their place within the social world through being named or how a person creatively deals with particular circumstances.
Edgerton also takes a different approach to the analysis of incompetence. Rather than focusing only on cultural values and conceptions of the person whose incompetence is formulated through economic and social structures of opportunity around issues of work and gender. He looks at different categorizations of difference into 'incompetent others' such as indigenous people, non-Western cultures, and women or the lower classes.
This book is primarily concerned with the processes of classification of incompetence and their relation to issues of cultural difference. As such it contributes to the debate that challenges the dominance of biomedical interpretations of intellectual disability by analyzing it as a cultural phenomenon. The social construction of incompetence is a significant part of this research. While there can be a problem with focusing too much attention on constructions of identity where that the complex and dynamic realities of intellectually disabled peoples' lives are obscured or perceived as just a product of these social and cultural categories, this book adds considerably to the growing cultural literature on mental disability and points to important new areas of research and debate within the field.
Return to