Classical Vs. Modern Tragedy Essays

Classical Vs. Modern Tragedy Essays

Length: 1196 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Classical vs. Modern Tragedy
Paulo Coelho once said, “Tragedy always brings radical changes in our lives, a change that is associated with the same principle of loss.” In Poetics, Aristotle describes the qualities of a tragedy and uses the character of King Oedipus as a perfect example of tragedy. In the modern world, authors continued to create tragedies as depicted in the modern book of Death of a Salesman. Considering the time difference between the two books, one is left wondering how the concept of tragedy has remained relevant for many centuries, and whether in the modern world tragedy has changed in any way. In light of these facts, the author gives a personal definition of tragedy and examines the tales of Oedipus the King and Death of a Salesman as tragedies. In addition, the author discusses the difference and similarities between the two works before making a conclusion regarding the importance of the differences/similarities 2400 years later.
Personal Definition of Tragedy
From a personal perspective, tragedy refers to a composition that describes a series of misfortunes on the lives of major characters. For instance, the major character will face major challenges and obstacles that sometimes lead to problems such as severe injuries, death, imprisonment, loss of a loved one, loss of a property, or loss of respect and a revered position in society among others.
Oedipus the King and Death of a Salesman as Tragedies
According to Aristotle, there are qualities one can use to identify a tragedy. For instance, the tragic hero is always a person of high standing in society, but misfortunes often cause his downfall or death. Violence is another common element identified by Aristotle in tragedies. In the Common Man, Miller argu...


... middle of paper ...


...ttings. The basic theme is to explore the struggles common people go through in their daily lives. Loman’s struggles after being dismissed by his employers depict the basic themes of modern tragedies.
Conclusion
The persistence of the concept of tragedy in ancient and modern literature works implies that tragedy is a common challenge that man continues to struggle with more than two millennia later. Based on the different positions that Oedipus (king) and Willy (salesman) hold in society, it is also clear that regardless of one’s position in society, people’s mental processes and emotions are the same, and, therefore, they are prone to same fates when they do not handle their challenges properly. Finally, heroes are not determined based on the positions they hold in society, but rather the qualities that make them standout from others or in times of great challenges.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Tragedy Of Sophocles ' Oedipus Rex And Hamlet '

- There is no doubt that tragedy has changed considerably since Aristotle first wrote the definition of tragedy in his Poetics in Ancient Greece, but these changes raise the question of whether modern tragedy still fits the classical definition of tragedy. Tragedy has evolved greatly since the times of the classical tragedies, including Oedipus Rex and Hamlet, to the more modern forms of tragedy, as seen in The Hairy Ape and Death of a Salesman. Despite its evolution and deviation from Aristotle’s definition, modern tragedy holds by the same principles, and retains the same power and message expressed by Aristotelian tragedy....   [tags: Tragedy, Tragic hero, Poetics, Sophocles]

Better Essays
1546 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on The play Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller

- The play Death of a Salesman, written by Arthur Miller, is about an average salesman living in Brooklyn, New York in the 1940’s named Willy Loman. Willy firmly believes in the American dream and is living his life aspiring to gain the wealth and materials associated with those of higher status in society. This American dream tears apart his family and the end result is his own demise. Glengarry Glen Ross, by David Mamet, has a plot similar to Death of a Salesman in that it is about salesmen and it shows the effects of capitalism on people and society....   [tags: modern tragedy, american dream]

Better Essays
1067 words (3 pages)

Oedipus the King: A Classical Tragedy Essay

- Oedipus the King as a Classical Tragedy Aristotle, in his work 'The Poetics', tried to define the tragedy. Aristotle said that the hero, or at least the main character in a tragedy must be essentially good, but must bring upon himself his fall, due to a fatal flaw. Were the character not noble, many reason, an audience would not care about the person, and would not really notice his fall - from the street to the gutter is not a long way. In today's society this, of course, has been shown not to be true.  Modern playwrights have proven that an audience certainly can care about less prolific heroes, but in classical literature this rule stands, and all heroes of tragedy were noble, and tried...   [tags: Oedipus Rex Essays]

Better Essays
755 words (2.2 pages)

Essay Renaissance Tragedy and Investigator Heroes

- Renaissance Tragedy and Investigator Heroes The role of the investigator in Renaissance tragedy, with special reference to Shakespeare's Hamlet and Thomas Kyd's The Spanish Tragedy I therefore will by circumstances try, What I can gather to confirm this writ Hieronimo The play's the thing Wherein I'll catch the conscience of the King Hamlet The roots of the blossoming tree of crime fiction can be traced back to the ancient soil of The Bible, and beyond, in literature which contains mysteries to be solved, and figures who act as detectives....   [tags: Shakespeare Hamlet Kyd Spanish Tragedy Papers]

Better Essays
2492 words (7.1 pages)

Tragedy and Thomas Hardy Literature Essay

- Many critics and commentators think of tragedy as a broad thematic concept that covers the majority of Hardy’s work (Wright, 2003; Brooks, 1971; Goodheart, 1957; Lawrence, 1936; Johnson, 1923). D. H. Lawrence (1936) comments that tragedy is a central concept in many of Hardy’s novels and places Hardy as a great writer of tragedy at the same level as Sophocles, Shakespeare, and Tolstoy. The tragic approach to understanding Hardy’s work is very old. The first one to discuss it on tragic grounds seems to be Lionel Johnson....   [tags: Literary Elements]

Better Essays
749 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about Death of a Hero in Modern Tragedy

- Death of a Hero in Modern Tragedy *No Works Cited Is there anything that can evoke more emotion from an audience than a hero's downfall. The most effective plays in history, from " Oedipus ", the most famous of all tragedies, to plays like " Romeo and Juliet ", tragedies are always the plays with the greatest emotional impact on an audience. There are many critics who believe that tragedies can no longer be effectively written in today's world. These critics believe that " the tragic mode is archaic, fit only for the very highly placed, the kings or the kingly "and therefore cannot realistically exist in the modern world (Tragedy 1)....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
617 words (1.8 pages)

Death of a Salesman: Tragic but Not a Tragedy Essay

- Death of a Salesman: Tragic but Not a Tragedy Though a more modern version of tragedy in its’ classical sense, Death of a Salesman in many ways is very much like an ancient Greek play. In his ‘Poetics’ Aristotle tries to set out the common ideas throughout tragedy, attempting to demystify the necessary elements for such plays. One of his main ideas was that of the ‘Three Unities’ - that of Space, that of Time and that of Action. He stated that all the action of a tragedy must occur in the place, which was often the front of a palace, which allowed the poet to have many characters coming and going, and allowed random meetings to occur easily, rather than having to ‘explain’ the reaso...   [tags: Death Salesman Arthur Miller essays]

Better Essays
1374 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on French Neo Classical

- The French Neo Classical era of theatre has influenced today’s society in a number of ways including woman’s fashion, dance, architecture and theatre performance. We have seen this throughout history and it still has continued into today’s society. The term Burlesque is usually thought of as slightly naughty theatre produced and performed between the 1700s and World War II. Webster defines it as a literary or dramatic work that seeks to mock by means of bizarre embellishment or comic imitation, mockery usually by caricature or theatrical entertainment of a broadly humorous often earthy character consisting of short turns, comic skits, and sometimes striptease acts....   [tags: Theater ]

Better Essays
1000 words (2.9 pages)

Comparative Character Analysis of Classical Vs. Modern Tragic Protagonists.

- Comparative Character Analysis of Classical Vs. Modern Tragic Protagonists. A hero/ heroine is described as the principal male/ female character in a literary or dramatic work or the central figure in an event, period, or movement. The classic tragic hero was defined by Aristotle in the fourth century as, “someone who is highly renowned and prosperous” (LATWP, 639), suggesting that there is a “natural right ordering and proportion of traits within the human being that if violated, produces calamity” (LATWP, 639)....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
784 words (2.2 pages)

The Tragedy of Othello, the Moor of Venice Essay

- A talented poet and playwright writer, William Shakespeare came during the golden age of England. His writings are the greatest in the English language. No one really know Shakespeare real birthday. The closet date the scholars can come up is on his baptism on April 24th, 1564. It has been over 400 years since his death; Shakespeare’s writing is not just limited to English scholars, but also appears on modern historical events and newspaper as well. Playwright and poetry are an art that appeals to the conscious mind, but the best classical playwright such as Othello not only appeals to conscious mind, but also to the subconscious mind....   [tags: Shakespearean Literature ]

Better Essays
1146 words (3.3 pages)