The Civilized and the Primitive: Two Contrasting Perspectives Essay

The Civilized and the Primitive: Two Contrasting Perspectives Essay

Length: 1537 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


European writers of the late 19th and early 20th centuries, permanently captured the cultural attitudes and popular opinions associated with the ideas of civilization and the primitive of their time. The Era of New Imperialism brought culturally polarizing ideas to the forefront of public thought—ideas like the exploitation of primitive peoples for the benefit of civilized Europeans. Several decades later, during the Interwar Period, many ideas of the previous century were challenged, yet many established attitudes remained. H. Rider Haggard’s She epitomized the new imperialist culture of the late 19th century as it promoted a naturally determined separation between the civilized and the primitive. Sigmund Freud’s Civilization and Its Discontents embodied the reflective yet traditional culture of the early 20th century by furthering the animalistic characterization of primitive people and by criticizing civilization for its impediment of people’s happiness.
In 1887, H. Rider Haggard wrote She, a novel that incorporated the attitudes and ideologies associated with the new imperialism that dominated European thought and policy of its time. During this era, European powers greatly increased their global influence; from the French colonization of Indochina to the British in India, nearly every western European country claimed possession of an overseas colony. One of the most important events of this imperialist period was the Berlin Conference of 1884-85. During this international meeting, European powers divided up the continent of Africa into separate European colonies. Not a single African was present; the conference was an exclusive meeting of European powers to negotiate the details of their possession of an entire continent....


... middle of paper ...


...ss. When compared to Haggard’s older, more polarizing opinions, Freud’s ideas seem more moderate, as he noted both positive and negative features of each societal type. These two sets of opinions on civilization and the primitive could be made relevant to some of today’s issues, like the widening technological gap between developed countries and third-world nations. As western countries become remarkably more advanced in technology, medicine, and education, a moral question arises: is it the duty of first-world nations to share their modern advancements with the people of more primitive countries? Perhaps a closer look into the ideas of Haggard or Freud would lend a valuable answer.

Works Cited

Freud, Sigmund. Civilization and Its Discontents. Ed. and Trans. James Strachey. New York: Norton, 1962.
Haggard, H. Rider. She. New York: The Modern Library, 2002.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

What Are Contrasting Perspectives Of Actions? Essay

- What are contrasting perspectives of actions. Robert Collier describes opposing views as “One might as well try to ride two horse moving in different directions, as to try to maintain in equal force two opposing or contradictory set of desires.” These actions that America takes to form a better nation, since the reconstruction era until present day, results in two different reactions: one against and the other one in support. For example opposing views appear in the New Deal. The New Deal meant to help Americans during the Great Depression had supporters as well as opponents....   [tags: Lyndon B. Johnson, United States, New Deal]

Powerful Essays
1697 words (4.8 pages)

The Contrasting Elements of Civilization and Savagery in William Golding’s Lord of the Flies

- Modern events, such as the recent chlorine gas usage in Syria, shows that even with civilized culture not too far away, people can still revert to savage, primitive desires for power and authority (Hubbard 1). William Golding portrays these same ideas in his novel, Lord of the Flies, only Golding portrays these natural desires with english schoolchildren stranded on a tropical island paradise. In William Golding’s Lord of the Flies, civilization and savagery take contrasting roles and are represented by a number of different symbols including people, places, and objects (Koopmans 70)....   [tags: chlorine gas, syria, evil, primitive desires]

Powerful Essays
1557 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on Chondrites: The Most Primitive Rocks in the Solar System

- Chondrites give geologists insights on the makeup of the early solar system. Geologists are driven by understanding how the Earth came to be what it is today. Chondrites formed at the time o Introduction Chondrites are the most primitive rocks in the solar system. Chondrites are stony (non-metallic) meteorites that have not been modified due to melting or differentiation of the parent body. Chondrites are formed when dust and small grains that originated from the early solar system accreted to form asteroids....   [tags: geologists, dust, primitive solar system]

Powerful Essays
838 words (2.4 pages)

Pre-Civilized and Post-Civilized Happiness Essay

- “Discontented with your present condition for reasons which presage for your unfortunate posterity even greater discontent, you will wish perhaps you could go backwards in time – and this feeling must utter the eulogy of your first ancestors, the indictment of your contemporaries, and the terror of those who have the misfortune to live after you” (P.79). In Rousseau’s A Discourse on Inequality, he not only argues the inequalities between men, but also the inequality of happiness between the pre-civilized and post-civilized human....   [tags: Rousseau, desires, savage man, lifestyle]

Powerful Essays
1733 words (5 pages)

Savage or Civilized: Is There a Difference? Essay

- Many different groups make up the human population of the world. Each differentiates itself from the others based on customs, traditions, language and culture, thinking that what they have is the best. When two groups or people from different civilizations come into contact with each other, in theory both groups believe that their way of life is the sophisticated one and the other’s is the savage one, but more often than not, there is little difference between the two groups. Murder is a savage crime, yet both sides are able to explain it through their traditions, making it acceptable for themselves and appalling if it’s the other side doing it, yet in reality, murder is a cruel act and no m...   [tags: Homer's Odyssey analysis]

Powerful Essays
1621 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on What Are The Losses And Gains Of The Civilized Life?

- 1. What are the losses and gains of the civilized life (think about Enkidu). The losses and gains of this civilized life can be shown in both Enkidu and Gilgamesh’s experiences. Enkidu first loses his own innocence. Shamhat sexual actions towards him take the purity that he once had and soils it. He also loses his own connection with nature and the wildlife. After the interaction with Shamhat Enkidu is shunned by forest creatures and he is not accept back into their group (Jackson Pg. 9). Enkidu losses are small to what he gains....   [tags: Death, Afterlife, Epic of Gilgamesh, Cedar Forest]

Powerful Essays
1035 words (3 pages)

Primitive Beginnings in Herman Melville's Moby Dick Essay

- Primitive Beginnings in Herman Melville's Moby Dick       Among the numerous themes and ideas that author Herman Melville expresses in Moby Dick, one of the less examined is the superiority of the primitive man to the modern man. As an undertone running through the entire book, one can see in Moby Dick the same admiration of the "noble savage" that is so prevalent in Melville's earlier tales of the simple and idyllic life of the cannibals, even though the focus has been shifted to the dangers of seeing things from only one point of view and to the struggle between good and evil....   [tags: Moby Dick Essays]

Powerful Essays
1383 words (4 pages)

A Primitive Civilization In A Failed Utopia Essay

- A Primitive Civilization In A Failed Utopia Symbolism can be used to represent many aspects of a person place or thing. Throughout the novel the boys lose all symbols that represent there civilization such as there clothes and uniforms. In this novel symbolism is used to show how the boys change their outlook on their primitive society and rules. They are used in the novel Lord of the Flies to show the deterioration and destruction of the boys society and rules. The conch, the glasses and the masks all have a greater meaning in the novel....   [tags: essays papers]

Powerful Essays
720 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Perspectives of Psychology

- Perspectives of Psychology Psychology can be defined as the systematic study of mental processes, couple with behaviors, and experiences (Kalat, 2011). There are many ways in examining, mental processes and behaviors among people, and therefore psychologist uses different perspectives to understand how human beings, think, act, and behave. Some psychologist uses one perspective to analyze behaviors, and other uses a multidimensional approach. Carter & Seifert (2013) identified 7 major perspectives that are used to study people’s behavior, and mental processes....   [tags: cognitive, biological perspective]

Powerful Essays
1154 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about "Civilized In Their Hearts"

- In To Kill a Mockingbird two children named Jem and Scout learn an important lesson, the characters Atticus Finch and Dolphus Raymond teach them what it means to be “civilized in [their] hearts” through the course of the novel. Atticus Finch, Jem and Scouts father is a civilized man and sets the standard for the children. His life is an example of being civilized in your heart, and what it means to be a 'good person' and really believe in it. Atticus teaches Scout this when she explains she doesn't want to attend school, disliking it enough to pretend to be ill....   [tags: Classic American Literature]

Powerful Essays
541 words (1.5 pages)