City Of God Directed By Fernando Meirelles And Katia Lund Essay

City Of God Directed By Fernando Meirelles And Katia Lund Essay

Length: 1511 words (4.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The film City of God (2003) co-directed by Fernando Meirelles and Katia Lund explores the impact of urban planning and urban environment on the social and cultural behaviors of urban residents. The movie portrays urban planning as a factor in the allocation of resources to different urban neighborhoods, and how this allocation promotes the development of two social classes the poor and the rich. Secondly, the film attributes urban planning to social decadence as the marginalization of poor neighborhoods through government policies that limit resource allocation creates the perfect social environment for crime, moral decadence, and socialization of a whole generation into criminal activities.
City of God is set in the sprawling slums of Rio de Janeiro, in a poor urban neighborhood built in the 1960s to host the city’s poor inhabitants. Lins Paulo, the author of the book of the same title on which the movie is based, describes a grim picture of the slum in its early years. He writes, “the new residents brought garbage, bins, mongrel dogs” (Paulo 6), depicting the poverty of those who moved into the slum. The favela (the slum) is located far away from central Rio, in what can be interpreted as an attempt to create a as comfortable as possible distance between the rich who frequent and live with the main city, and the poor residents who present a security threat to businesses and Rio’s upper class society. This design of urban planning in which authorities go to great lengths to separate the haves from the haves not indicate a conscious and deliberate effort by governments to protect the rich at the expense of the poor. This may be partly explained by the fact that the upper class are either in government or have the political and fin...


... middle of paper ...


...rce allocation to poor neighborhoods. The ending scene drives this point home powerfully when the Runts ask each other if anyone of them can write so they can make the hit list. Without education, how does the government expect such youths to earn a living, and how much can they be justifiably blamed for turning out the way they did? In the City of God, crime is the beast. If you run away, it will catch up with you, if you stay, it will eat you.
In conclusion, City of God is a portrayal of the impact of poor urban planning on the social and behavior culture of marginalized urban dwellers. It demonstrates that poor urban planning promotes the growth of urban slums and the creation of a social environment that encourages lawlessness and decadent behaviors. It links urban planning to the unequal allocation of resources, and its consequences such as poverty and crimes.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

City Of God By Fernando Meirelles Essay

- “In the eyes of too many people, street children are not even human, and so they are dispatched in much the same way one would step on a cockroach” (Latin 281). This is not a productive way to view such a large group of children, especially since they populate much of the poorer cities and areas. There are approximately 40,000 children who live in the streets throughout just Mexico City. Also, both Sao Paolo and Bogota contain similar amounts of street children, somewhere in the tens of thousands....   [tags: Education, School, Urban decay, Poverty]

Better Essays
982 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about City of God, by Fernando Meirelles and Pixote, by Hector Bebenco

- The innocence of Brazilian lower class children are lost in both films ,City of God directed by Fernando Meirelles, and in Pixote directed by Hector Bebenco. In both of these films the loss of innocence stems from a lack of authoritative power and most importantly the lack of a familial structure. This lack of innocence derives from the lower class socio-economic status the youth are born into. The children and teenagers are able to gain an astonishing amount of power when introduced to violent lifestyle of the streets ....   [tags: film analysis and comparison]

Better Essays
3023 words (8.6 pages)

Movement in City of God Essay examples

- Movement is the act of changing physical location or position. Filmmakers have a goal of transmitting a message throughout their film; therefore, they make or create meaning by extensively using the movement technique. This is how a scene is put together to produce an image. Fernando Meirelles directed the Movie City of God, a Brazilian crime drama film. City of God strikingly portrays the evolution of the city’s crime from robbing gas trucks, to a city owned by one boss, Lil Ze; leading to an all out war zone between rival dealers....   [tags: filmmaking, film analysis]

Better Essays
1159 words (3.3 pages)

Film Comparative: City of God and Sexy Beast Essay

- The films City of God and Sexy Beast are both crime films that share many similarities such as narrative shape, light, and in both films the narrative unravels in foreign countries. The on difference they have is the classification of crime genre. City of God 2002, directed by Fernando Meirelles depicts the Rocket’s past, how he became a photographer, and how he got out of the slums in a chilling sequence of flashbacks to the people he knew and the life he ends up leading, the whole film could play out as a drama....   [tags: foreign countries, adventure]

Better Essays
1762 words (5 pages)

Essay about Impact Of Urban Planning On The Film City Of God

- The Impact of Urban Planning on Poverty and Crime in the Film City of God The film City of God (2003) co-directed by Fernando Meirelles and Katia Lund explores the impact of urban planning and urban environment on the social and cultural behaviors of urban residents. The movie portrays urban planning as a factor in the allocation of resources to different urban neighborhoods, and how this allocation promotes the development of two social classes- the poor and the rich. Secondly, the film attributes urban planning to social decadence as the marginalization of poor neighborhoods through government policies that limit resource allocation creates the perfect social environment for crime, moral d...   [tags: Sociology, Poverty, Decadence]

Better Essays
1525 words (4.4 pages)

The Director Of The Movie Fernando Meirelles Essay

- Just as the Olympics were held in Brazil, we heard on the news the constant increase of violence in children, and the even higher increment in the organized crime events in this country. But few of us understand the cold, horrific, and the traumatic experience of living surrounded by violent children in organized crime gangs, as well as the characters of City of God. The director of the movie Fernando Meirelles purposely shows us the way in which young children in Brazil learn to become violent at a young age, eventually still young get involved in organized crime gangs and their drug business, as well as in the gangs’ battles over territory and power....   [tags: Crime, Gang, Organized crime, Illegal drug trade]

Better Essays
1409 words (4 pages)

The San Fernando Valley Is An Urbanized Basin Essay

- The San Fernando Valley is an urbanized basin situated in the County of Los Angeles, California, bordered by mountains its home to about 1.69 million people. Yet, amidst its cool mountain breeze residents of the Valley have learned to recognize its environmental hazards. Experiencing great impacts from its larger more celebrated neighboring cities undergoing urban gentrification. As a consequence, it has led a number of people to make their way to the San Fernando Valley. Unfortunately, many of them are homeless fleeing the unsafe streets of skid row and making their home in different areas of the valley....   [tags: Poverty, Homelessness, San Fernando Valley]

Better Essays
740 words (2.1 pages)

Fernando, 16, Finds a Sanctuary in Crime Essay

- Research indicates that a combination of adverse socio-economic factors such as poverty, abusive or neglectful parents, and living in a violent environment, along with personal vulnerabilities such as impulsivity, puts a child at risk for delinquency and crime (Barnet & Barnet, 1998). Fernando’s story depicts how individual factors interact with environmental factors to shape an individual’s life. Social influence: Family and neighborhood Research shows that risk for crime behavior is worsened by poverty and lack of positive influences like a loving father, good neighbors or a teacher willing to reach out to the troubled child....   [tags: Fernando Morales Case Study]

Better Essays
3371 words (9.6 pages)

Three is Better Than One: An Analysis of Fernando Pessoa and His Heteronyms

- Writer Fernando António Nogueira Pessoa had a very dynamic way of writing poems because of his countless personalities. Pessoa was known to write poems as different personas, which made each of his works very different from each other. Pessoa had a total of 72 different heteronyms, which “were individuals with their own history, biography, personal characteristics and unmistakable literary style” (5).These heteronyms included himself, because even his own person was a heteronym on its own” (3). Some of his most famous alter egos were Alberto Caeiro, Ricardo Reis, and Alvaro de Campos....   [tags: Fernando Nogueira, Writing Styles, Analysis]

Better Essays
1172 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on The Movie, Crash, Directed By Paul Haggis

- Most people in this world think that they are all alone, then something happens and you find out that you all are intertwined somehow. In the movie, Crash, directed by Paul Haggis, it is a film that exemplifies how people live their daily life either in the suburbs or the city. In reality living in the city is easier to protect your family rather than in the suburbs because it is believed that more crime and gun violence happens in the suburbs making it hard to raise a family and on the flip side people in the cities are more likely know what to do in a situation with a scare than suburb people who rely on the police or other emergency people to help them out, although people believe concea...   [tags: Police, Crime, City, Suburb]

Better Essays
1111 words (3.2 pages)