Essay Cinderella, By The Grimm Brothers Tell The Story Of Cinderella

Essay Cinderella, By The Grimm Brothers Tell The Story Of Cinderella

Length: 1050 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

There have been countless versions of Cinderella, thus meaning there are many different interpretations of Cinderella. One of which, by Elizabeth Panttaja, tells the story after Cinderella’s mother died. Panttaja explains how Cinderella is only successful because of the magic that her mom is giving her, but is this true? The answer is no, since there is no evidence in her mother doing all of the work in Jakob and Wilhelm Grimm’s “Ashputtle”, another version of “Cinderella”. If fact, because of her use of magic, Cinderella is a lot weaker than many people imagine.
In Jakob and Wilhelm Grimm’s “Ashputtle”, the Grimm brothers tell the story of “Ashputtle”, beginning with Ashputtle’s sick mother, and Ashputtle at bedside. Before she dies, Ashputtle’s mother promises to be with her and watch her in heaven. Ashputtle’s dad then marries a new lady and brings her and her two daughters into the house. Ashputtle’s new step-sisters were warm and welcome on the outside, but cold and devilish on the inside always mocking Ashputtle. Ashputtle’s father goes to the fair and promises to bring each of his daughters back a gift. While the step-sisters choose dresses and jewelry, Ashputtle asks for something different. “Break off the first branch that brushes against your hat on your way home, and bring it to me” (Grimm 629) requested Ashputtle. Her rich father kept his promise, and Ashputtle placed the hazel branch over her mother’s grave, and cried to water it. The hazel branch would soon grow into a beautiful tree, and Ashputtle would weep and prey under it three times a day. Each time that Ashputtle made a wish, a little bird would throw down what she had wished for. Later on, the king had planned a celebration where his son, the ...

... middle of paper ... she must be the daughter of some foreign king,” (Grimm 630) the Grimm’s brothers say, describing the irresistible Cinderella. “Indeed, the battle for the prince’s attention was not waged at the level of character at all but at the level of clothes,” (Panttaja 660) Panttaja adds, which is proven by the fact that after the prince chooses to dance with Cinderella, he does not dance with any other girl.
Overall, Panttaja is wrong in the sense that Cinderella’s mother is the one who is creating all of the magic. In fact, it is the animals and the tree that possess magic. However, Panttaja makes up for her mistake by explaining how Cinderella is not morally superior, because of her use of magic to not only win over the prince with her dress, but also punish her step-sisters by not only making them cut off their toes and heals of their feet, but also by blinding them.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Tale Of Cinderella By Anne Sexton And The Brother 's Grimm

- As the world has transformed and progressed throughout history, so have its stories and legends, namely the infamous tale of Cinderella. With countless versions and adaptations, numerous authors from around the world have written this beauty’s tale with their own twists and additions to it. And while many may have a unique or interesting way of telling her story, Anne Sexton and The Brother’s Grimm’s Cinderellas show the effects cultures from different time periods can have on a timeless tale, effects such as changing the story’s moral....   [tags: Fairy tale, Cinderella, Brothers Grimm]

Better Essays
1358 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on The Obedience Of Women By The Brothers Grimm

- III. The Obedience of Women Introduction Not only are women expected to lead lives in which they depend on men to be happy and wealthy, but they are expected to do so with total obedience to the expectations of men. It is important to see how women react to the requests of men and how much freedom for thought and action they are allowed to have and what consequences occur when a woman disobeys what is asked of her. Cinderella In the Brothers Grimm, the first characterization of Cinderella is a description that “she was always good and said her prayers” (Grimm 122)....   [tags: Snow White, Brothers Grimm, Grimm's Fairy Tales]

Better Essays
722 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Similarities Between Cinderella And Cinderella

- Cinderella is the story of a girl whose stepmother does not treat her well. Cinderella goes to a ball, with no help from her evil stepmother, and meets her prince charming. Cinderella and her true love get separated from each other and the only way for the prince to find Cinderella was from a single shoe that Cinderella left behind. “Cinderella” by the Brothers Grimm and "Cinderella" by Charles Perrault have many similarities as well as many differences. Cinderella’s sisters in the stories were similar, but their lives played out different....   [tags: Cinderella, Brothers Grimm, Fairy tale, Family]

Better Essays
959 words (2.7 pages)

Cinderella 's Around The World Essay

- Cinderella’s Around the World While reading and watching films of different cultural Fairy Tales, you notice like an every Cinderella Tale there is a girl who is tired of living a life where they just want to be better. Also from all the different versions of Cinderella stories, all of them are surrounded by jealousy, hate, and negative vibes. However, there are cultural difference that is expressed in each of the different versions of these Fairy Tales. In my paper I am going to express these differences, the two versions that I’ll be talking about is “Aschenputtel” which is the Germany version, and a modern version “Maid in Manhattan”....   [tags: Cinderella, Brothers Grimm, Fairy tale]

Better Essays
1021 words (2.9 pages)

Cinderella, By Anne Sexton Essay

- The poem “Cinderella” by Anne Sexton tells the story of Cinderella but differently then the beloved fairy tale portrayed by Walt Disney. Sexton emphases the way the Grimm Brothers told the story of Cinderella. Readers will feel a sense of hatred toward the idea of Disney’s version of the story. Sexton shows the Cinderella story in a more realistic way and explains how not everything will have a happy-ever-after. In the first four stanzas of the poem Sexton makes fun of these unrealistic fairy tale stories....   [tags: Fairy tale, Cinderella, Brothers Grimm]

Better Essays
749 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Cinderella A Fairy Tale That Creates Many Stereotypes

- Fairy tales and movies can be very similar or very different in many ways. But wait. What exactly is a fairy tale. Well, to me a fairy tale exists when a short story can fulfill ones imaginations. After reading many short stories I then ask myself are these stories beneficial to young children. Do we really want our kids to imitate certain traits these characters portray. I argue that the fairy tale “Cinderella,” creates several stereotypes. By “sterotypes” Im implying that fairy tales are starting to create expectations on how much power a women or men can possess....   [tags: brothers grimm, rodgers and hammerstein]

Better Essays
942 words (2.7 pages)

Analysis Of The Book ' Cinderella ' Essay

- Imitation is the most sincere form of flattery is a common saying. If it is in fact true, then modern writers sure do love fairytale authors of the past. However, in the modern versions, many things are changed drastically, most notably the characters and their actions. One such example of this is the many different adaptions of what is now known as Rapunzel, the original is an Italian fairytale that is very different from the tales by the Brothers Grimm or Disney that most people are familiar with....   [tags: Fairy tale, Brothers Grimm, Giambattista Basile]

Better Essays
1558 words (4.5 pages)

I Can Tell You What to Teach Essays

- I Can Tell You What to Teach. Oh my, this is my chance. I can finally tell a teacher what to teach, and you may or may not listen. I have to make this good; really good. I enjoyed the Strange and Mysterious unit a lot. Learned about strange and creepy stories and how difficult it is to put those stories into motion pictures. Now for next year, when a new set of students come in and they are just as eager to start this unit, I have a great set of authors who should be your top pick for your new minions to read about and learn more about their history; R.L Stine, The Brothers Grimm, and my absolutely best pick, Patrick Carman....   [tags: Patrick Carman, Brothers Grimm]

Better Essays
654 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on Fairy Tales By Charles Perrault

- There is a plethora of fairy tales that have survived into the modern age, familiar stories such as; Jack and the Bean Stock, the Little Mermaid, The Tin Soldier, Little Red Riding Hood, and many others have all been used in modern films and literature. However, there is one storied classic that has been captivating children and adults alike for centuries, Cinderella. Charles Perrault wrote the familiar tale over three hundred years ago, yet modern adaptations of the story continue to be used. One example of a modern rendition of Perrault’s tale is the 1998 major motion picture titled Ever After (   [tags: Cinderella, Brothers Grimm, Fairy tale]

Better Essays
1150 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on The Movie ' Cinderella '

- noticed that in a number of films the father is dead thus it is impossible to protect his children, such as in Cinderella. Also stepfathers seem to not be portrayed in pop culture as evil thus stepmothers are the only ones that receive such hideous flack. Because stepfathers are not portrayed in a negative way, when it comes to real life they have less difficultly finding their place in their new family. (Church 1994) (Hall and Bishop 2009) Stepmothers in Popular Culture The evil stepmother was first seen in the original story of Cinderella which was written in 1697 by XXX....   [tags: Family, Mother, Stepfamily, Father]

Better Essays
1075 words (3.1 pages)