Essay `` Charlotte Temple `` By Susanna Rowson

Essay `` Charlotte Temple `` By Susanna Rowson

Length: 1174 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Many people see Susanna Rowson’s book, “Charlotte Temple”, as a comment on the need for youth to listen to their elders. However, the theme is far more complicated than this as it shows that the advice itself is flawed. As the characters travel from England to America, the inherent problems of the advice appears. It is here that Montraville father’s advice which is assuming similar experiences leads to lifelong misery. Charlotte the most obvious proof that ignoring your parents advice leads to trouble suffer far greater consequences because of the reversibility of that very same advice. Even the readers experience the dangers of advice as the author cautions the mothers reading the novel that their views and consequently advice are not enough because of the inherent problem of advice not being law. Montraville’s, Charlotte’s, and reader’s stories show that it is not enough to follow parental advice if the advice is misguided, founded in untrue expectations, creating more trouble and misery for the youths.
To beginning, I must first define advice. Advice is any guidance given with the goal of alternating a perceived way of thinking in the hopes of dissuading future actions. Advice can be seen in mentalities, directions, or actions.
For Montraville, his father’s advice ends up harming the child because he assumes their experiences and understandings are the same. When the father says, “tone thing…to caution you against…young men frequently rush into matrimonial engagements, and…draw many a deserving woman into scenes of poverty…[if you find a wealthy woman you may merry her] if, on the country, [you are with a poor girl]…I will leave you”, there is a focus on “union” (40). The father thought that pursuing a romantic relati...


... middle of paper ...


...w “foolish” the action actually is (28). Because seeing what happens and apply it to their own situations and understanding allows them to avoid these disasters, the book and stories are a way to give better advice. It comes down to advice showing possibility not garneting certainty.
Through Montraville’s, Charlotte’s, and reader’s stories one can see the negative impact prenatal advice can have when it is founded in misconceptions. The author uses these key moments of guidance to expand on the theme of prenatal guidance showing parents and children the problems advice can make and how to avoid or at least overcome these problems. Together the reveling of danger and circumstances through stories, allows the problem to be overcome. It is embracing interpretation. The author is showing us that advice is only as good as it allows individuals to help themselves.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Charlotte Temple, by Susanna Rowson Essay

- Subsequent to her examination of Susanna Rowson’s Charlotte Temple, Jill E. Anderson infers that the novel resembles a woman’s captivity narrative. In fact, she compares Rowson’s novel to the spiritual autobiography of Mary Rowlandson, stating that both authors “recognize the challenges faced by women in their respective periods and engage in the doubled discourse of confirming the patriarchy and fighting within or against it” (Anderson 431). The correlation between genres suggests that Charlotte Temple coincides with an advocacy for women’s rights This is not an innovative revelation....   [tags: Marxism, Feminism, Society]

Strong Essays
2431 words (6.9 pages)

Sentimentalism in "Charlotte Temple" Essay

- Many might argue that sentimentalism is an act of weakness or that it’s an emotion that should only be expressed by the female sex. However, that is not true; the act of sentimentalism actually helps to prove the moral quality of a character or person. This is eminent in the story Charlotte Temple by Susanna Rowson in which the reader comes across many characters being sensible or acting sentimentally towards others. In the story Charlotte Temple, sentimentality is practiced amongst those characters that are benevolent; benevolent meaning a person that expresses good will, generosity, and that has the desire to help others in other words charitable....   [tags: Literature]

Strong Essays
901 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Comparing Love in Somnambulism and Charlotte Temple

- Comparing Love in Somnambulism and Charlotte Temple      In today's terms, love is an exciting, joyous, and uplifting experience to those who are fortunate enough to find it.  Literature from the late 18th century expresses a completely different view, however.  The literature of Susanna Haswell Rowson and Charles Brockden Brown show the 18th century view of love as something to be mistrusted, detrimental to the spiritual and moral well-being of those who are "in" it, and above all, show that it can only be controlled by and entrusted to the care of men....   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Strong Essays
697 words (2 pages)

Comparing Themes in Charlotte and Ruth Hall Essay

- Sentimental or Social Themes in Charlotte and Ruth Hall The subject matter of early American women writers has been criticized in the past, but the messages these authors sent women and society cannot be denied. Susanna Rowson and Fanny Fern came from two different time periods in American history, but their impact on society is similar. In both cases, the women experienced great success as writers during their time. Their popularity shows how their messages were transferred to many people of their time....   [tags: compare and contrast essay examples]

Strong Essays
4475 words (12.8 pages)

Men in the Lives of Charlotte Temple and Hester Prynne Essay

- The American novels Charlotte Temple and The Scarlet Letter are similar in many ways. Some of the most obvious are that both of the novels revolve around the lives of ruined women. In Charlotte Temple, Charlotte is seduced by the charming solder John Montraville, who singlehandedly manages to tarnish her reputation by leaving her a young, pregnant, outcast. Hester Prynne also goes through public humiliation for her actions with Arthur Dimmesdale. However, these women are greatly affected by the men in their lives, who are much of the cause of the women's turmoil....   [tags: Literary Analysis]

Strong Essays
1033 words (3 pages)

Charlotte Temple Essay

- The Tabloid of the Century (1800’s -1900’s) 	 The general reason I think Charlotte Temple stayed on the best seller list for so many years is because the subjects that were discussed in the book were taboo in that day and time. 	 Montraville was a soldier in the army who was about twenty three years old, and Charlotte was only fifteen. He was much older than Charlotte. Montraville influenced her in evil ways; he impressed her with his knowledge of love and the world by writing her a letter and giving it to her personally ....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1455 words (4.2 pages)

The Continuing Cycle of Patriarchy Essay

- Before the beginning of the women's rights movements in the late 19th century patriarchy, or a society dominated by males, was the norm in America. Men used sex and marriage to objectify and suppress women in order to maintain a society controlled strictly by males. The foundation of patriarchy was rooted deeply in the marital roles of men and women, one dominant, and the other submissive. Sex and marriage served as a mechanisms to shape the images of men and women in society. The system of patriarchy fed into itself to keep it going generation after generation....   [tags: women's rights movement, slavery]

Strong Essays
1247 words (3.6 pages)

Charlotte Temple - Ideas of Love Essay

- Charlotte Temple - Ideas of Love In the 18th century, when Charlotte Temple was written, society’s ideas about women, love, and obligations were extremely different from views held in the 20th century. Women did not have many rights, and society made them think that their place in life was to marry well. They were not supposed to have desires or hopes for an amazing kind of love. They were merely supposed to marry the man who their families intended them to marry, and live their lives being a dutiful wife and mother....   [tags: essays papers]

Strong Essays
1367 words (3.9 pages)

The Importance of Miss Temple in Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte Essay

- The Importance of Miss Temple In the novel Jane Eyre, written by Charlotte Bronte, one reoccurring motif is the idea of Jane, the protagonist, needing a motherly figure to guide her. From the very beginning it is obvious that Jane is an orphan without any real motherly figure, so she finds a few people to fill this void in every environment she is placed in. The major substitute mother is a woman named Miss Temple in which Jane meets at the Lowood Institution. Miss Temple dramatically helps Jane along her journey and comforts her in a way that only a mother could....   [tags: mother, kindness, emotion]

Strong Essays
784 words (2.2 pages)

Evolution of the Temple-Palaces in Mesopotamia Essays

- The Evolution of the Temple-Palaces in Mesopotamia The constructions of the temple-palace had large scale implications for the Mesopotamian landscape. It served as a symbolic entity for the city and towns that it was located in due to the tremendous height of these buildings that served as beacons that loomed over villages. These temples were perceived by many individuals who resided in these villages as homes for the deities. A wide cross section of villagers from various social backgrounds belonged to a particular temple in which they would worship....   [tags: archiologists, temple, dynasty]

Strong Essays
2263 words (6.5 pages)