Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre and Angela Carter's The Bloody Chamber

Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre and Angela Carter's The Bloody Chamber

Length: 1662 words (4.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
In literature a reader often discovers "strange" encounters between the main characters and others in the story. These encounters usually serve to illustrate what characters learn about themselves as a result of these encounters. In Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre and Angela Carter's "The Bloody Chamber," each heroine must deal with specific consequences of these "strange" encounters. The characters emerge as their true selves as a direct result of these experiences.
Jane Eyre and the heroine in "The Bloody Chamber" each experience a rather strange courtship which serves as each girl's first encounter with the man in her life. Jane Eyre meets her future husband Rochester when he is injured in a fall. He turns out to be the father of the girl for whom Jane is caring. Rochester is a much older man, and at age 18 Jane is wise in the ways of the world due to her orphaned upbringing with a hateful aunt and her time spent at Lowood, a boarding school. At first Rochester is harsh and abrupt with Jane. They eventually become friends and have time to build a real relationship; they have much in common in spite of their different status in life. After their engagement, Jane dislikes the wealth that Rochester pushes on her, feeling like a dress-up doll in the clothing he provides. She remains true to her "plain looks" and smart demeanor. Yet all the while Rochester keeps a dark secret from Jane: his first wife Bertha Mason is locked in a room on the third floor of the house. Rochester's explanation centers on the fact that he was tricked into marrying her and that Bertha is mad.
The heroine in "The Bloody Chamber" experiences quite a different courtship. She too is a young girl, age seventeen, and her suitor is an older man. She, in contrast to Jane, is extremely naïve and does not know herself, having lived with her mother in a close, loving relationship, which proves most beneficial in the end. She experiences a quick Parisian courtship with his third wife "dead just three short months before I met him" (p. 10). She questions what such a wealthy, influential man would want with her, for they have little in common. When her future husband showers her with fancy clothing, she gladly wears it, for what she already owns is unsuitable for her new status.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre and Angela Carter's The Bloody Chamber." 22 Oct 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay Gothic Conventions in The Bloody Chamber by Angela Carter

- Gothic Conventions in The Bloody Chamber by Angela Carter The Gothic is often distinguished by an atmosphere of terror, darkness, mystery, the unexplained and the transgression of boundaries. This essay will attempt to dissect how Angela Carter uses Gothic conventions in the passage taken out of her novel, 'The Bloody Chamber'. One of the most predominant conventions manipulated here is that of a dark and mysterious atmosphere. Throughout the passage the feeling of terror prevails. This is first started by the protagonist's taking of a "forbidden key"....   [tags: The Bloody Chamber Angela Carter]

Research Papers
1355 words (3.9 pages)

Essay Analysis Of ' The Bloody Chamber ' By Angela Carter

- In my analysis of ‘The Bloody Chamber’ by Angela Carter, I have decided to analyze hw role-reversal plays a large part in this story. The POV is set in first person, with the Heroine as the narrator. The story is told through her eyes and she is believed to be a reliable source because she clearly outlines unfortunate events that happen to her, such as the mark of shame on her forehead of the blood-stained key. I believe for many that Carter may have wanted her story to defy the cultural norm of fairytales where the female character always needs to be saved from a situation- this typically places female characters in roles that make them seem fragile, weak, and helpless....   [tags: Marriage, Wife, Husband, The Chamber]

Research Papers
1497 words (4.3 pages)

Essay about The Bloody Chamber, By Angela Carter

- Angela Carter’s “The Bloody Chamber,” is a visually intricate and feminist text; this feminism is portrayed through gender roles. The narrator is a young child who transitions into a woman searching for identity, and her husband’s masculine power defines it. In other words, this short story depicts gender roles and personal identity through the use of objectification of women. The deeper meaning behind the roles the men and women have may reflect Carter’s deconstruction of gender norms. The narrator enables the deconstruction by acting as a link; she conjoins two opposing ideas, like masculinity and femininity....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Woman, Marriage]

Research Papers
1450 words (4.1 pages)

Essay about Angela Carter's Wise Children

- Angela Carter’s attitude towards her work has always been one with intrinsic feminism at its roots. Carter’s feminist attitude within her novel Wise Children has given the reader a much more realistic and intuitive approach to Shakespeare. Carter conveys ideas of feminism through matriarchy and the power of womanhood, or rather new family structures of an acceptance of an absentee father. In some aspects, her work is an invitation to criticisms towards Shakespeare’s lack of matriarchal concentration and sometimes all together absentation, and realistic approaches towards female characters....   [tags: Angela Carter, Feminism]

Research Papers
2737 words (7.8 pages)

Essay on Angela Carter’s The Bood Chamber

- In Angela Carter’s The Bloody Chamber, the theme of transformation appears throughout the short story cycle. The hero/heroine’s virginity acts as a source of strength that protects them from harm. Their lack of fear also saves them from death. Virginity acts as power of potentia, either literally or symbolically and results in a release of an observed transformative power. The bloody chamber serves a different symbolic purpose of transformation for Beauty in “The Courtship of Mr Lyon”, the heroine in “The Tiger’s Bride” and the Countess in “The Lady of the House of Love”....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Transformation]

Research Papers
1761 words (5 pages)

Essay on The Bloody Chamber by Angela Carter

- ... The Countess makes attempts to ensure the girl dies; representing her desperation not to be seen as ‘an older model’. She also realises that the rose bites “”It bites!” She said.” Carter (1995, page 62); that the price of being a man's object is the pain of unrealistic levels of beauty and a loss of her personal identity. Carter is clearly pointing out the objectification and subjugation of women through the theme of pornography. In "The Snow Child," the girl is a mere pornographic image, a mental embodiment of naked attractiveness desired by the Count....   [tags: bluebeard, interpretation, transformation]

Research Papers
2038 words (5.8 pages)

The Bloody Chamber Essays

- Angela Carter was a writer in the 1970s during the third wave of feminism that influenced and encouraged personal and social views in her writing. This is demonstrated through her own interpretation of fairy tales in The Bloody Chamber. She combines realism and fantasy to create ‘magic realism’ whilst also challenging conventions of stereotypical gender roles. The Bloody Chamber is a remake of the original fairytale Bluebeard; however Angela Carter rewrites the fairy tale using her feminist views to raise issues concerning roles in relationships and marriage, sexuality and corruption....   [tags: Angela Carter, Gender Roles]

Research Papers
944 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Power and Knowledge in Angela Carter’s ‘The Bloody Chamber’

- The Oxford University Dictionary defines the word power as ‘authority or control’ over an individual and knowledge as ‘the sum of what is known’. In Angela Carter’s story The Bloody Chamber (1979) knowledge and power correlate with each other. The more information a character possesses the greater authority they have. In The Bloody Chamber Carter utilises a variety of literary techniques to express the importance of knowledge and power in the plot. This essay will analyse the way Carter applies these literary techniques to the story to express the importance of knowledge and power....   [tags: Literary Analysis]

Research Papers
1048 words (3 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of Angela Carter 's ' The Bloody Chamber '

- Angela Carter’s story The Bloody Chamber heavily tampers with a reader’s prior knowledge of the fairy tale genre by manipulating expected conventions in order to showcase the dark side of fairy tales. Carter challenges the genre’s aspects of happy endings, of the mother figure, and of the masking of women’s desires by giving each a twist in the story in order to truly depict how fairy tales are not just a tale of a dream come true. The rite of passage in fairy tales is often shown as something spectacular and morally good, however, Carter subtly demolishes that expectation in her story, which is very dependent on the readers’ prior knowledge of the genre, and thus allows for the readers to s...   [tags: Little Red Riding Hood, Fairy tale]

Research Papers
1159 words (3.3 pages)

Magic Realism in Wise Children by Angela Carter Essay

- Magic Realism in Wise Children by Angela Carter Magical realism is a primarily Latin American literary movement from the 1960s onwards, which integrates realistic portrayals of the ordinary with elements of fantasy and myths. The result of this is a rich but disturbing world that appears at once to be very dreamlike. The term ‘magical realism’ was first used by German art critic, Franz Roh, who said it was a way of depicting ‘the enigmas of reality’ and literary critic Isabel Allende has said that ‘in magic realism we find the transformation of the common and the everyday into the awesome and the unreal....   [tags: Wise Children Angela Carter Magic Realism Essays]

Research Papers
787 words (2.2 pages)

Yet she later wants to stay in her own clothes rather than formally dress for dinner. She does not yet clearly know herself as Jane does. Once again the reader finds a man keeping a secret from his girl: the bloody torture chamber holding three dead wives. His explanation centers on "those infrequent yet inevitable occasions when the yoke of marriage seems to weigh too heavily on my shoulders. I go there to savour the rare pleasure of imagining myself wifeless" (p. 21).
Each heroine experiences another "strange" encounter with their man that changes the direction of her life. For Jane Eyre this moment arrives on her wedding day. As the minister asks, "Wilt thou have this woman for thy wedded wife?" a distinct voice replies, "This marriage cannot go on: I declare the existence of an impediment" (p 293). When asked the details of this impediment, the man says, "It simply consists in the existence of a previous marriage. Mr. Rochester has a wife now living" (p. 294). In this moment the reader sees the moral strength of Jane as she refuses to stay and be Rochester's mistress. Even though these two clearly love each other and connect on both an intellectual and an emotional level, Jane knows it cannot continue, and she sneaks from the house in the middle of the night.
In "The Bloody Chamber" the heroine faces her encounter when her husband states he must sail from France to the New World for business. He leaves her with a large set of keys with the instruction to use each to explore all the rooms in the castle except for one small chamber. As the heroine, of course, uses the key anyway and opens the chamber door, she discovers a torture chamber containing the remains of his three previous wives. She, unlike Jane, has no means of escape from the situation. She is saved only by the "mental telepathy that sent my mother running headlong from the telephone to the station . . . I never heard you cry before" she explains (p. 40). Her mother then "put a single, irreproachable bullet through my husband's head" (p. 40). Now the heroine must decide which direction her life will take.
Each of these encounters is indeed strange, and the author of each story provides foreshadowing for the event. In Jane Eyre several events hint that something strange is going on in the house. Jane hears a noise in the hall and then discovers Rochester's bed curtains on fire. After a Jamaican gentleman, Richard Mason, arrives for a house party, loud yelling is heard. It turns out Mason has been stabbed and bitten. In both instances Rochester blames Grace Poole, one of his odd servants who lives on the third floor.
In "The Bloody Chamber" the author also hints at the evil nature of the husband. The body of his third wife is never found. The girl has been "invited to join this gallery of beautiful women" (p. 10). His wedding gift is "a choker of rubies, two inches wide, like an extraordinarily precious slit throat" (p. 11). She feels "a sharp premonition of dread" (p. 12) on the train ride to his castle. During her exploration of the castle, she discovers a pornographic book, and he confronts her with "a curious mixture of mockery and relish" (p. 17). The lilies he has placed in her bedroom make it "look like an embalming parlour" (p. 18). He even goes so far as to tell her, "Every man must have one secret, even if only one, from his wife" (p. 21). While not specifically hinting at the exact nature of the secret, the reader is prepared for a "strange" encounter.
Both women learn much about themselves as a result of their "strange" encounters with the men in their lives. Following her discovery of Bertha Mason, Jane Eyre has the strength to walk away from the situation. Her moral fiber will not let her become a mistress. She flees, almost penniless, from the house. After being taken in by three people, St. John Rivers and his two sisters, Jane is able to find a job as a teacher and build a life. She displays grace and strength in the face of a difficult situation. She later discovers that these three are actually her cousins. In am amazing turn, their Uncle John has died, leaving Jane a substantial inheritance. She once again remains true to her moral self and splits the money with her cousins even though they had had a falling out with their uncle. Jane also does not want to marry just to be married. St. John has asked, and Jane declines, seeing him as more of a brother. Jane also shows she remains compassionate. Curious about Rochester, she returns to the house she shared with him to find him living elsewhere, having been injured and blinded in a fire set by his now-deceased mad wife. Still in love with him, Jane marries Rochester. Jane is able to stay true to herself and her beliefs throughout the story and still marry the one she loves.
The heroin of "The Bloody Chamber" also learns about herself as a result of her relationship, her encounters, with her husband. Part of her discovery about herself is disturbing to her where, in contrast, most all of what Jane learns reinforces her positive qualities. When she wears the ruby choker, she sees herself as he must see her: "I saw how much that cruel necklace became me" (p. 11). She senses in herself "a potentiality for corruption" (p. 11). She blushes when she realizes "he might have chosen me because, in my innocence, he sensed a rare talent for corruption" (p. 20). After he has gone, she lays alone in bed: "And I longed for him. And he disgusted me" (p. 22). The heroine does have the good sense to call her mother which is fortunate since it is her mother's arrival which spares her life. Like Jane, she is now free to escape her situation. She too inherits a great deal of money from her husband's estate, and like Jane, is generous, giving most away to charity. She chooses a positive path in life. She too ends up with the one she loves, Jean-Yves, the blind boy her husband had hired as the piano tuner. She, Jean-Yves, and her mother live together, strong enough to dismiss the gossip said about them. She does continue to carry the shame of her experience in the red mark on her forehead, the key her husband so cruelly pressed upon her. She is glad Jean-Yves cannot see it. In the end, Jane and this heroine just happened to both end up wealthy women, in more ways than just financial, building a life for themselves with men they love.
Jane Eyre and the heroine of "The Bloody Chamber" end up being alike in some ways and different in others. While Jane stays true to herself throughout the story, the other girl must choose to do the right thing and not follow what she fears could be her corrupt side. Jane is able to flee her situation on her own whereas the young married girl must be rescued by her mother. Both women do show incredible strength enduring their situations. Both show their tremendous compassion toward others when they both share their wealth. Once again the girl chooses the right path in giving most of her money to charity, just as Jane has shared her wealth. Both prevail in the end, in spite of the "strange" encounters they experience with the men in their lives.
Return to