Challenges and Opportunities of Achieving Consensus on a UN Reform Proposal

Challenges and Opportunities of Achieving Consensus on a UN Reform Proposal

Length: 1138 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Reforms and changes in the United Nations have always been fraught with obstacles that must be overcome amidst competing national interests of member states. There are challenges that must be addressed and opportunities that must be seized for member states to come into consensus on a proposal that would have repercussions and consequences to international and national policies and norms, which would affect domestic, regional and international relations. The UN Emergency Peace Service proposal, which aims to effectively and quickly respond to genocide and other humanitarian crimes, is no exception. Challenges abound, but not without opportunities to move forward. Challenges to bring about a UNEPS are generally hinged on the issues of sovereignty, the credibility and intention of states supporting the proposal, and perceptions as to the legality and legitimacy of purpose.
Issues related to state sovereignty and non-interference in domestic affairs have been the bone of contention of most member states in the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) .Composed mostly of developing countries, except China, which had been colonised by the Western powers, their main concern is that UNEPS could be used as a tool for neo-colonialism. Already critical of West intervention, their suspicion could have been entrenched further when the United States, without authorisation from the Security Council, invaded Iraq using humanitarian intervention as a pretext. According to Bellamy, ‘critics argued that the US and the UK were abusing and selectively applying a partial account of human rights to justify armed intervention in weak and mainly postcolonial states’ .Bellamy also points out that advocates of traditional sovereignty are worried that advocating sovere...


... middle of paper ...


... support the proposal. Real opportunities to advance UN reform is not during the formal debates in the plenary but in informal and outside of the UN meetings and dialogues where diplomatic courtesies are less observed and detailed discussions can be done without inhibitions.









References:

BBC News, ‘Profile: Non-Aligned Movement’, updated 7 August 2009, http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/country_profiles/2798187.stm viewed 24 July 2010.

Bellamy, Alex, Responsibility to Protect: The Global Effort to End Mass Atrocities, Polity Press, Cambridge, 2009.

Davide, Hilario, Philippine Permanent Representative to the UN, Thematic Debate on the Report of the Secretary-General on Implementing The Responsibility to Protect Speech transcript, UN General Assembly, 23 July 2009, http://www.un.int/philippines/statements/20090723.htm, viewed 21 July 2010.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Reform Proposals For The United Nations Essay

- PROPOSALS FOR REFORM Introduction There is a worldwide acceptance of the need for the United Nations (UN) to reform to current global trends. Yet reforms have been stagnated by lack of global consensus on the nature of implementation. Resistance to reforms is nothing new with the UN since its formation. However, at the end of the cold war with changes in the nature of peacekeeping, the organization became receptive to reforms rather than resistant. The receptive reform process have been on a piecemeal process, with the magnitude of reforms varying from one Secretary General to the other....   [tags: United Nations, Peacekeeping]

Strong Essays
1135 words (3.2 pages)

Food Stamp Reform Bill Proposal Essay

- ... They believe the money that is given should be used in other areas of the government. According to an article, there is a farm bill that recently has been passed that cut the Food Stamps by an estimate of $39 billion (Bump, Ohlieser). Over the next years that what have accumulated to 800 billion dollars saved and used to another government funded project. According to another source, the new current controversy of Food stamps is soda. Michael Bloomberg believes that they should not cover soda because it contributes to various health diseases such as diabetes and obesity (Lubrano)....   [tags: abusing, taking advantage of the system]

Strong Essays
1608 words (4.6 pages)

Borgmann’s Proposal to Reform Technology Essay

- Borgmann’s Proposal to Reform Technology Albert Borgmann follows the general project by Heidegger to see how technology has harmful effects on humanity and to determine how it can be reformed. Borgmann shares Heidegger’s view that modern technology is starkly different from premodern technology in its pattern of disclosing the world to human beings. Borgmann agrees that a sort of ethical reform must be undertaken to limit technological ways of living from dominating the lives of individuals and to keep technology in its place....   [tags: Philosophy Albert Borgmann]

Strong Essays
2169 words (6.2 pages)

A Modest Proposal By Jonathan Swift Essay

- It was back in the 1700’s in Britain that true power struggle, rebellion, doubts in the government and extreme poverty began to take light. Thousands of people were left homeless and without clothes, forcing them to defecate on the streets, ultimately leading to disease and plight. Discrimination also played a very large role in Britain, as they treated the Irish as mere scum, leaving them without basic human needs or rights. Jonathan Swift, an Anglo-Irishman born in Dublin in the year 1667, became a key role in the digressing of discrimination and helped better the failing British nation with his satirical – yet influential – writings that easily swayed society....   [tags: Jonathan Swift, Satire, A Modest Proposal]

Strong Essays
963 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about Scientifically Based Research School Reform

- The policy mandates that school reforms and practices should be grounded on “Scientifically Based Research” and employ educators that are “Highly Qualified” (Manna & Petrilli, 2008, p. 63). The “Scientifically Based Research” (SBR) and “Highly Qualified” (HQ) teachers are supposedly, fruits of collaboration between educational researchers and the policy makers. Regretfully, the overuse phrases have become mantras and in the process the real definitions of the words or how they are supposed to be implemented is convoluted....   [tags: Education reform, educational reform]

Strong Essays
1544 words (4.4 pages)

Jonathan Swift 's A Modest Proposal Essay

- When faced with adversity society often turns to satire to relieve the frustrations the people feel. One of the most widely known examples of satire is Jonathan Swift’s “A Modest Proposal” Swift uses this work to vent his frustration with not only the governing bodies of 1729 Ireland, but also its residents. Swift discusses the possibility of ending Ireland’s famine and economic troubles by using the children of poor families as a source of nourishment for the workers. This suggestion although meant in a comedic way served a more serious role in displaying Swift’s and many others displeasure with the state of their nation....   [tags: Satire, Jonathan Swift, A Modest Proposal]

Strong Essays
901 words (2.6 pages)

The Role of Consensus in Business Essay

- Understanding consensus and its role in a business As mentioned earlier in the introduction, consensus is a general agreement that is made within different groups. Consensus is another word for consent, which means to give permission. It is part of the process of decision-making where everyone within the group has a say and agrees to support a decision in the best interest of the business as a whole. Consensus builds a relationship within the workforce and this helps them find a solution that meets the needs of the group and work together to strategically make the best decision suited for the company....   [tags: decision-making, discussion]

Strong Essays
1644 words (4.7 pages)

Policy Proposal for Economic Reform in Russia Essay

- Policy Proposal for Economic Reform in Russia Despite making a recovery after the 1998 market crash, Russia remains weighted with numerous holdovers from the Communist era that keep its economy from taking advantage of free-market reforms. In short, Russia has not prospered under capitalism because it has not yet discovered it. In order to do so, the Russian government must engage in extensive reform in several key areas: improving the rule of law, creating stable monetary policy, and ending a policy of favoritism to particular businesses....   [tags: Economics Political Politics]

Strong Essays
2756 words (7.9 pages)

Study Proposal for a Social Studies and Premedical (Premed) Student Essay

- Study Proposal for a Social Studies and Premedical (Premed) Student As a Social Studies and premedical student, I aspire to lead an international health and development non-governmental organization (NGO). Combining my skills as a physician and practitioner of development, I plan to enhance the health of marginalized, persecuted, and exiled populations. Through direct interaction with government bodies and humanitarian NGOs, I hope to highlight and curb the medical and psychological burdens stemming from human rights violations....   [tags: Study Proposal]

Strong Essays
509 words (1.5 pages)

Business Proposal Essay

- Business Proposal In today’s busy world where time is precious to everybody; getting readymade food at the door steps is everyone’s wish. That’s the precise reason anyone from small restaurant to the biggest have home food delivery service. Everyone have their own choice in foods and eat different stuff at different time. Even In same family someone may want pizza for dinner, someone want subway sandwich, and someone may want Mexican food. In such situation when everyone in family want different stuff to eat at same time; you may end up spending lots of time going through different food menus, calling different restaurants, putting up separate orders and wait to get all orders delivered so...   [tags: Business Proposal]

Free Essays
434 words (1.2 pages)