Essay on Causal Ditermism in the Movie Groundhog Day

Essay on Causal Ditermism in the Movie Groundhog Day

Length: 1957 words (5.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

What does it mean to have free will when one cannot choose the environment in which they live in? Because the environment in which one lives in shapes their beliefs and practices, how is it they are morally responsible for their actions and decisions when they are not in control of the environment they live in? Causal determinism is a belief that everything that happens is completely caused by whatever happened before it. Furthermore determinism implies if the conditions under which one made a choice were precisely the same, one could not have done otherwise (Kamber). While it is difficult to argue against causal determinism there is still freedom to reflect on possible alternatives before acting. Though, the question is not whether one can choose to do what they want (to follow their desire) but whether one is free enough to be held accountable for their decisions even though one can judge the importance of these desires and their place among other reasons for action (Horton www.oocities.org/emilische/free-will.doc). In the movie Groundhog Day, Phil Connors experiences the same day (Groundhog Day) over and over again. At first Phil uses this to his advantage until he discovers he is forced to stay in the same place with the same people who do the same thing every day. While Phil Connors lives in an identical situation every day and therefore a deterministic setting, does Phil have free will and is he morally responsible for his actions? According to compatibilists Harry Frankfurt, Susan Wolf, and John Martin Fischer in certain events where one “could not do otherwise” one could still have free will and moral responsibility over their actions. With the example of Phil Connors and the ideas of compatibilists Harry Frankfurt, Susan ...


... middle of paper ...


...ch causes the boy to get hurt, is he still morally responsible? Sometimes humans know something is going to happen if no one intervenes. According to Peter Singer, if that something is bad and one can stop it with little to no cost of oneself, then it is reasonable that one ought to stop it and is blameworthy if one fails to stop it if they do not have an adequate excuse. Because Phil knows something bad is going to happen if he does not intervene and he can stop it with no cost to himself, Phil is blameworthy of letting the child fall. Phil still has free will because his desire was to not help the child and yet he is still blameworthy of not saving the child from the fall.
Also John Martin Fischer offers the idea of semicompatibilism, an idea that allows us to confidently attribute moral responsibility to agents even if we are unsure whether determinism is true.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Realism in the Movie, Training Day Essay

- "Realism in, art and literature, [is] an attempt to describe human behavior and surroundings or to represent figures and objects exactly as they act or appear in life" (Realism 1). During the 1840's through the 1890's realism was present in much of the literature from the United Sates and Europe. It has been said that realism is easily visible in many pieces of modern literature and even in present day films. In 2001, the movie Training Day was released into theaters. Many critics agreed that the movie was very realistic....   [tags: Training Day Movie]

Powerful Essays
1210 words (3.5 pages)

Review of the Movie, A Hard Day's Night Essay

- "A Hard Day's Night" catches the first flaring of Beatlemania in a manner at once subtle and intelligent. The plot is simple: a day in the life of the Beatles as they try to make it to a performance, burdened by Paul's trouble-making grandfather (Wilfred Brambell); inept reporters, police, and studio moguls; and, of course, hordes of screaming teenage girls. All the while, the Beatles remain as laid back as can be, responding with dry, very British one-liners and shifting easily into melodic musical interludes, such as "Can't Buy Me Love," "All My Lovin'," and "I Wanna Be Your Man." This is the pre-Sergeant Pepper Beatles, and their pleasant, playful enthusiasm mirrors the general innocence...   [tags: Movie Film Hard Day's Night Beatles]

Powerful Essays
1442 words (4.1 pages)

Essay on The Longest Day: Book Vs. Movie

- The Longest Day: Book Vs. Movie For a long time, when anyone thought of a war movie, they immediately thought of Darryl F. Zanuck’s, The Longest Day. Cornelius Ryan, who was the author of the book by the same name, and happened to be a D-day veteran himself, wrote the movie. The book meticulously recreates the events preceding and during the invasion. It is filled with detailed descriptions of multiple occurrences during the invasion. It explains everything from mass attacks on beaches and towns to humorous anecdotes....   [tags: Longest Day Compare Contrast Film Essays]

Powerful Essays
1581 words (4.5 pages)

The Causal Theory of Action: Overpopulation Essay

- The problem of mental overpopulation is pretty easy to see. It is visible in situations like freezing on a test, cramping on the field, or overthrowing the first baseman. Basically, those times when you overthink or try to do too much in a situation, those thoughts actually become detrimental and stop us from performing as well as expected. Philosophers Ruben and Dreyfus do a really good job of highlighting this problem in the Causal Theory of Action. Thinkers like Davidson and Clarke do not do enough to solve this problem of mental overpopulation....   [tags: human action, philosophy]

Powerful Essays
1309 words (3.7 pages)

Training Day Essay example

- In 2001, one of the most memorable performance’s in Hollywood was Honored with an Academy Award, for Best Actor In A Leading Role. The Oscar, went to Denzel Washington, for is amazing performance in Training Day. A powerful departure from his good guy roles, Denzel Washington, plays Alonzo Harris, a street smart, crocked, undercover narc, out on the mission to save his ass, from the Russian mob. On the day in question, he is giving rookie cop Jake Hoyt (Ethan Hawke) a chance to prove himself worthy to be a part of his elite squad of undercover narcotics officers....   [tags: Training Day Movie]

Free Essays
749 words (2.1 pages)

Analysis Of The Movie ' Daddy Day Care ' Essay

- Daddy Day Care is a film directed by Steve Carr in 2003. The movies writer was Geoff Rodkey and the production companies that where involved in this movie included Revolution Studios, Davis Entertainment and Day Care Productions. This movie follows an African American family. The family has two parents, Charlie and Kim Hinton, with their four-year-old son, Ben Hinton. The family seems to be in the middle class with Charlie being the sole provider and Kim benign a stay at home mom. The movie starts with Kim wanting to go back to work, which leads to putting Ben in an exclusive and expensive preschool....   [tags: Family, Parent, Mother, Father]

Powerful Essays
1031 words (2.9 pages)

Analysis Of The Movie ' Groundhog Day And The Philosopher ' Essay

- 1 / 2 In my discussion, I am going to write about one of the most impact full movie and philosopher back in their times of the 19th century. The movie was groundhog day and the philosopher was Jean-Paul Sartre . My main point will be to write about the concept of freedom that both of them having it in common. But, the meaning of freedom in the movie is different than in the philosophy of Jean-Paul Sartre , since they interpret it in different ways. Such as, the meaning of freedom for Sartre is when a man is condemned to be, free....   [tags: Jean-Paul Sartre, Existentialism, Meaning of life]

Powerful Essays
718 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Book Critique of The Longest Day

- Book Critique of The Longest Day Cornelius Ryan, born in Dublin, Ireland in 1920, worked as a reporter covering the battles in Europe from 1941-1945 and then the final months of the Pacific Campaign. His articles were printed in both Reuters and the London Daily Telegraph. His first book was The Longest Day, published in 1959, selling over 4 million copies in 27 different editions. In 1962 a director named Darryl Zannuck made the book into a movie. Ryan's next book was The Last Battle, published in 1966....   [tags: The Longest Day]

Powerful Essays
868 words (2.5 pages)

Theories of Causal Attribution in Social Cognition Essay

- Theories of Causal Attribution in Social Cognition In social cognition causal attribution is one the most important models. In causal attribution we attempt to find cause-effect relationships between human behavior and possible causes which made it happen. There are seven different theories of causal attribution, and I shall talk about the Kelley’s covariation model and then talk about some biases in attribution. Kelley’s covariation model Kelley’s covariation model is a form of attribution model, possibly the best known of them all....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
959 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about Dog Day Afternoon

- In the movie, Dog Day Afternoon, there were many things that the police and the FBI did wrong. It seemed as if there was no manual to guide the police officers and the FBI through the hostage situation. Sonny and Sal never really thought about what they would do if they were to get caught. One of the first mistakes that officer Moretti made was when he called the bank to let Sonny know he was in there. I think that there never would have been a hostage situation if officer Moretti would have let Sonny and Sal think they were going to get away and grab them when they came out the bank....   [tags: movie film]

Free Essays
735 words (2.1 pages)