Catholic And Mormon : A Theological Conversation Essay

Catholic And Mormon : A Theological Conversation Essay

Length: 1155 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The book Catholic and Mormon: A Theological Conversation is a great example of how to properly discuss religion with members of different faiths. The books authors Stephen Webb (Catholic) and Alonzo Gaskill (Mormon) are extremely knowledgeable about their respective faiths and obviously believe in their religion with all of their hearts but yet do not fall into the traps that so many people fall into when discussing religion. They exhibit holy envy for other religions, they do not step on already bruised toes, are respectful of others and their beliefs, are objective and open-minded, and they focus on the similarities of their religions rather than dwell on the differences.
Mormons are encouraged (through the emphasis on member-missionary work as well as, for some, experiences as full-time missionaries) to proselytize, proselytize, and proselytize. This is all well and good but there are people that are firm in their beliefs and that is also fine. God does not necessarily want everyone to be a Mormon but rather wants everyone to have faith and live a virtuous life. The book does a good job of presenting the beliefs of both of the religions without attempting to persuade the other author or the reader to convert. This is an important aspect of quality inter-faith dialogue. When in a discussion about our religions we should seek merely to present what we believe. An example of this in the text is when Alonzo says, “Please know, I am not trying to prove the LDS view here; only to demonstrate the concept . . .” (pg. 184).
Avoiding the urge to proselytize is a very respectful thing to do. Respect should always be given to everyone of differing beliefs and respect should be given also to their beliefs themselves. Stephen and Alonzo ...


... middle of paper ...


...n our focus is on our polarizing viewpoints. In order to understand other religions better we need to explore common positions. An excellent example of this is found in the chapter on rituals. It says, “Mormon baptism for the dead is surely its most controversial ritual, and I cannot help but [draw] some parallels between that and the Catholic belief in transubstantiation” (Pg. 86). The author could have very well expounded on what makes baptism for the dead so controversial but instead made a connection with an aspect of his own faith. Making connections is imperative to growth and development. Without Stephen seeking to find similarities and sharing it, I would probably have never made this connection between baptism for the dead and transubstantiation. This helps me better understand the idea of transubstantiation and am more accepting of this Catholic practice.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparing the Mormon Religion to Catholic and Protestant Faiths Essay

- Comparing the Mormon Religion to Catholic and Protestant Faiths The Mormon religion is very unique in many of its doctrine. While technically a Protestant faith, the Mormons generally share more doctrine with the Catholics. Because of its unique nature, I will be analyzing the Mormon faith, its history, organization, and doctrine, in comparison with the beliefs held by both Catholics and Protestants. Establishment On April 6, 1980, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (aka the Mormon Church) was founded....   [tags: Religion Religious Mormon Compare Essays]

Better Essays
3693 words (10.6 pages)

Essay on The Mormon Symbolism in Twilight

- The Twilight Saga tells the story of a young woman named Bella Swan and her love interest, Edward Cullen. Stephenie Meyer has said that the idea for the Twilight Saga came from a dream she had. In her dream, Meyer had a vision of an unbelievably perfect male being and an average teenage girl (cite). The odd pair, obviously in a state of infatuation with each other, was sitting in a small, round meadow when all of a sudden; the male reveals himself to the young woman as a vampire (Sykley 262).The dream served as the inspiration for the entire Twilight Saga....   [tags: Mormon beliefs, vampire analogues]

Better Essays
1520 words (4.3 pages)

Analysis Of The Book ' Mormon ' Essay examples

- ... The people of Nephi are example of this in 2 Nephi 5:27: "And it came to pass that we lived after the manner of happiness". These and other people found peace, joy and happiness in being disciples of Christ and in obeying the commandments of God. As I have worked to better understand how to 'stay at the tree ' this semester, I have found myself participating in the sacrament in a way I have not in a long time. As I have pondered making and keeping my covenants with God more fully in my life, I have had some incredible insights into the importance of the sacrament....   [tags: Jesus, Christianity, Holy Spirit, Book of Mormon]

Better Essays
711 words (2 pages)

When to Speak in a Conversation Essay

- Introduction A conversation necessarily requires multiple participants, and assuming all members have the right to speak, the act of turn-taking will take place. Schegloff and Sacks wrote that “two basic features of conversation are proposed to be: (1) at least, and no more than, one party speaks at a time in a single conversation; and (2) speaker change recurs” (1973:293), with the latter highlighting the ubiquity of turn-taking in spoken discourse. The first feature is rather idealistic, with overlaps frequent in everyday conversation, but it implies a sense of general cooperation, with participants typically allowing speakers to finish their turn before taking their own....   [tags: Conversation, Speaking, Communication]

Better Essays
1536 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on A Crucial Conversation

- A crucial conversation, according to authors Patterson, Grenny, McMillian & Switzler (2012), is one in which “opinions vary”, “stakes run high”, and “emotions run strong” (p.1-2). Leaders will often avoid these conversations until the situation has become serious (Patterson et al., 2012). It is an important nursing leadership skill to effectively manage these tough conversations. Whether the conversation is about disrespectful behavior, professional practice issues, or patient safety, it is never easy (Maxfield et al., 2005a; Patterson et al., 2012)....   [tags: Nursing, Nurse, Conversation, Florence Nightingale]

Better Essays
1508 words (4.3 pages)

Bad Catholic : Why It Is Okay Essay

- ... Therefore, in the set standards of being a good Catholic, it is not expected of me disagree with the view of the church whether what the church deemed as acceptable is right or wrong but, I am accepted too willing to agree to all their teachings. I would like to clarify that I do in fact agree with many of the teachings of the church such as the New Commandment, "Love one another. As I have loved you, so you also should love one another" (John 13:34). However, teaching about homosexuality, "If a man lies with a male as with a woman, both of them have committed an abomination; they shall surely be put to death; their blood is upon them." Leviticus 20:13, calls for one to be put to death o...   [tags: Christianity, Roman Catholic Church, Religion]

Better Essays
946 words (2.7 pages)

Age Of Early Catholic Texts Essay

- ... These false teachings are seen in the Story of Thecla where Thecla was attracted to Paul’s teaching of abstinence for the followers of Christ. Chapter 4 in 1st Timothy goes on to encourage Christians against this false teaching and encourages them to stay strong in their faith so that they will not fall victim to these erroneous teachings. In 2nd Peter, chapter 2 harshly speaks out against the false prophets that will cause “many to follow their licentious ways, and because of these teachers the way of truth will be maligned” (2:3)....   [tags: Christianity, New Testament, Catholic Church]

Better Essays
1260 words (3.6 pages)

The Catholic View On Marriage And Family Essay

- The Catholic View on Marriage and Family As one of the oldest and most widespread religions on earth, the Catholic faith has often come under fire for the doctrines it relentlessly upholds. At the center of its social teachings, the Church shields the human dignity that is commonly thrown aside, reminding the world of where true human value lies. Along with it, Catholic doctrine puts forth her teachings on marriage and family, and all their implications, which serve as the fundamental building blocks of a fruitful society....   [tags: Pope John Paul II, Catholic Church]

Better Essays
1669 words (4.8 pages)

A Conversation Overheard Essay

- A Conversation Overheard Laughing and crying. Like salt and pepper, peanut butter and jelly, they go together. Yeah, they do. Think about it. People laugh until they cry, some people laugh through their tears. And, after you finish either process, you usually feel better, am I right. Also, both laughing and crying are essential to survival in life. No one can successfully thrive and function without doing either of these things, laughing and crying. All that emotion kept inside, with no means of escape....   [tags: Dialogue Conversation Essays]

Free Essays
1390 words (4 pages)

Essay on Gregory's First Theological Oration

- Gregory's First Theological Oration Growing up as a Catholic, I never even considered watching whom I spoke in front of when in a conversation about God. I never dwelled on the fact that I might be putting "the sword into the enemies hands", or that only people that were concerned with God should speak of Him. Gregory of Nazianzus believed that only certain people, certain places and certain occasions were worthy of the discussion of God. In Gregory's First Theological Oration, he clearly delivers the guidelines that believers should heed when speaking of or about God....   [tags: Religion Religious]

Free Essays
1623 words (4.6 pages)