Case : The Court Was Appalled Essay

Case : The Court Was Appalled Essay

Length: 868 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Case Study #1: “Case: The Court Was Appalled”

1. Explain the issue or dilemma using information from the readings in the book and other sources.
In the case of Tomcik v. Ohio Dep’t of Rehabilitation & Correction, the main issue present was the medical negligence demonstrated by the staff of the medical clinic at the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction towards the inmate Tomcik. Specifically, nonfeasance, or the “failure to act, when there is a duty to act as a reasonably prudent person would in similar circumstances” (Pozgar, 2016, p. 192), was displayed when the employees at the medical clinic failed to give immediate medical attention to Tomcik when she continually signed the clinic list and “provided the reason she was requesting medical care” (Pozgar, 2016, p. 202). Due to the fact that there was a long delay in diagnosis of her cancer, it resulted in the removal of Tomcik’s entire right breast, thereby causing both physical and emotional damage. In addition, there is the issue of medical malpractice when Dr. Evans failed to give Tomcik a thorough examination and a proper diagnosis. Failure to diagnose is a type of medical malpractice (Boeschen, n.d.).
2. What are the ethical theories most appropriate to apply this case and why?
An ethical theory that is most appropriate to apply to this case is consequentialism. By definition, consequentialism revolves around the presumption that an act is considered to be right or wrong depending upon whether the outcome turned out to be good or bad (Pozgar, 2016, p. 8). In the situation involving Tomcik, she ended up facing the end result of having her right breast removed and thereby led to both physical and emotional distress. This was all due to the fact that Dr. Evans h...

... middle of paper ...

... and the incredibly long delay in diagnosis and treatment. The negligence from Dr. Evans, along with the lack of medical attention sought out by Tomcik after she had first discovered the lump in her breast, may contribute to Tomcik’s life being in danger as well as the emotional anguish she may have felt during that time period. Overall, the incident of Tomcik’s expectations from the original physician and other employees at the institution not being met is an ethical issue that should be dealt with suitably.
4. Who are the stakeholders?
The stakeholders are the public. Frankly, this incident can happen to anyone, not just the prosecutor Tomcik in this case. Also, this case poses as an important lesson for the general population of healthcare providers, that they should not be negligent towards any kind of patient, regardless of his/her social rank or background.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Case Of Wolf V Colorado Essay

- Second, in the case of Wolf v Colorado, Wolf was convicted of a crime by the state due to the fact that deputies seized medical records from a doctor’s office without a search warrant. He appealed on the grounds that this was a violation of the Fourth Amendment which impels the court to exclude the record seized at trial. The exclusionary rule was differentiated as a permitted variation because this case was tried on in a state court as a state prosecution. In the case of a federal crime for a federal prosecution the search and seizure would have been excluded....   [tags: United States Constitution]

Better Essays
1059 words (3 pages)

Essay about The Terri Schiavo Case and Euthanasia

- The poem “To the Mercy Killers” by Dudley Randall refers to the ongoing debate of the right to live. “If ever mercy move you murder me, I pray you, kindly killers, let me live” (Randall 623). Here he is most likely referring to doctors as “kindly killers” who feel that letting him die would be a mercy to him. Randall clearly believes that life is a treasured gift, and should not be purposely extinguished for any reason. However, terminally ill patients should have the right to decide whether they want to die or not....   [tags: Medicine Assisted Suicide]

Better Essays
1515 words (4.3 pages)

The Supreme Court Vs. Salazar V. Buono Case Essay

- The Supreme Court was faced with a unique paradox during the case Salazar V. Buono; in which their ruling had to coincide with the establishment clause in the first amendment, while avoiding the dissenting opinions of thousands of veterans and their families they threatened to insult with their decision. In 1934, the VFW commissioned a white cross to be constructed on an outcropping known as Sunrise Rock in the Mojave National Preserve. In 1999, the plaintiff, Frank Buono, requested for the NPS to tear down the cross on the grounds that it was in severe violation of the Establishment Clause....   [tags: Supreme Court, Case]

Better Essays
966 words (2.8 pages)

Texas V. Johnson Essay

- Texas v. Johnson (1989) In 1984, following a protest march through the streets of Dallas, Texas against the policies of the Reagan Administration, Gregory Lee Johnson was handed an American flag. Outside the Dallas City Hall, Johnson through the flag onto the ground, poured kerosene on it, and set fire to it. Many protesters around Johnson began a chant of, "America, the red, white, and blue, we spit on you!" While many protesters agreed with what Johnson had done, there were several others who felt extremely offended....   [tags: Flag Burning Legal Case Law]

Free Essays
1117 words (3.2 pages)

The Fair Credit Reporting Act Of The United States Court Case Essay

- The majority opinion on this case is ignoring the most significant claim that in the United States court case there needs to be standing. With that the standing there must be an injury-in-fact and that injury must be presented and that this injury is redressable. After that fact is made clear there needs to indication that the Fair Credit Reporting Act has allowed Congress to go beyond the power enumerated to them and have begun to violate the separation of powers. We must examine where both sides are presenting their argument....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States, Law, Case law]

Better Essays
1297 words (3.7 pages)

The County Courthouse And Criminal Court Case Essay

- On Thursday, November 17, 2016 I went to the Watauga County Courthouse and observed a criminal court case. That day there was only thirty-five cases on the docket, so it was a less-busy day compared to most days in criminal court. For instance, the Thursday before there were one hundred sixty-three cases on the docket. Since it was going to be a quick day, I decided to arrive around 10:00pm to skip the roll call and the usual wait. I was checked in quickly, and even though the metal detector beeped on me, the officer still let me go without further checks....   [tags: Judge, Law, Lawyer, Court]

Better Essays
2137 words (6.1 pages)

Essay on Judicial Minimalism and Mazimalist in Court Rulings

- Courts frequently turn to a number of different methods and techniques in an effort to adequately rule on cases and controversies. One approach in particular in known as judicial minimalism. Through this approach, judges attempt to provide specific interpretation that simply address the case and issue at hand. Judges who implement judicial minimalism often rule in a “narrow and shallow” manner as noted by Professor Cass Sunstein. This consequentially lessens the likely hood of mistakes and additionally minimizes the ramifications of any errors made....   [tags: court, case, law, controversy]

Better Essays
2200 words (6.3 pages)

Supremem Court and Juan Smith Essay

- It really does not seem that reliable for someone to describe a man in a mask at first glance. One would not think anyone could, but evidently, someone “can.” Larry Boatner, the eyewitness in this Supreme Court case claimed he “could.” On Monday, June 13, 2011, the United States Supreme Court granted a hearing to the petitioner Juan Smith. Smith had previously been convicted of five murders by both state and trial courts. This verdict was made in the absence of physical evidence, no DNA, no fingerprints etc, only based off of the eyewitness’ statement....   [tags: Case, Court, Crime, Convict, Murder]

Better Essays
1702 words (4.9 pages)

The Supreme Court Case : Plessy V. Ferguson Essay

- Throughout history, segregation has always been a part of United States history. This is showed through the relationships between the blacks and whites, the whites had a master-slave relationship and the blacks had a slave-master relationship. And this is also true after the civil war, when the blacks attained rights. Even though they had obtained rights the whites were always one step above them and lead superiority over them continuously. This is true in the Supreme court case “Plessy v. Ferguson”....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States]

Better Essays
1113 words (3.2 pages)

The Supreme Court Case Of U.s. V. Lopez Essay

- In the U.S. Supreme Court case of U.S. v Lopez (1995), a twelfth grade boy, Alfonzo Lopez, brought a loaded .38 caliber firearm to his local Texas high school. After being reported to the front office, Lopez was questioned about the gun and openly admitted that the firearm was in his possession. Texas then convicted Alfonzo of a criminal statute, which prohibited the carrying of a gun on school grounds. However, the charges were dropped rather quickly when the United States Government charged Lopez with violating the Gun-Free School Zones Act....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States]

Better Essays
1364 words (3.9 pages)