Case Study : A Question Of Compromise Essay

Case Study : A Question Of Compromise Essay

Length: 1115 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Case Study: “A Question of Compromise”

This is a case study regarding a family in Senegal that follows the Muslim culture. However, unlike most Muslims, they practice the form of female circumcision. The tradition is to have all girls coming of age to be circumcised; otherwise they would be shunned and would never be able to get a husband. The family’s tradition believes that if a girl does not have this procedure done, they will be considered deformed and their clitoris will hang down to their knees. Awa is concerned because she and her husband, Joseph, have two daughters who are coming of age and her mother-in-law is demanding to know why they have not made the arrangements for the girls’ circumcision. Awa’s dilemma is whether or not she should carry on this tradition with her girls; suggest possibly a simpler procedure of just removing the small skin over the clitoris or to not have either of the procedures done.

When Awa was a girl, her mother and father, after a lot of arguing, agreed that she would not go through the traditional procedure that most girls go through. Awa’s father took her to a doctor, where anesthesia was used so there was no pain and only the small skin over the clitoris was removed. She is living a normal life, with sexual desires and able to give birth to children. Unfortunately, her husband is being pressured at work and being threatened to lose his job if the procedures are not being done their girls.

Joseph feels that if they talk to people they know to discuss the process of the smaller procedure and they all agree to this procedure with their own daughters, this would be considered acceptable. He would be able to keep his job, his mother would not harass Awa and they would be able to say...


... middle of paper ...


...en, if this tradition is what she has grown to know, who am I to say it is wrong? There are so many cultures that are tied with religion, which makes it so much more important to that culture.

Knowing the repercussions that can take place by a girl being circumcised is all the more reason as to why these practices should be abandon. At a young age, girls are so vulnerable and something like this could be so traumatic for them. It is hard for me to believe that this is a religious practice. I feel that if it were, this would be a practice across all religions. From the two responses, I am seeing that this is not the case. Neither response has convinced me that this is a practice that should be carried on today in any country or any culture.

Where did this tradition come from? What evidence did they have that supported that this was a religious practice?

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Medical Ethics Case Study

- Medical Ethics Case Study Introduction Professionals in every field are always confronted with some kind of ethical issues. It has however been noted that these ethical issues become high in magnitude and extent when public officials are involved. Due to the involvement of human life, an industry like healthcare holds ethics in highest regard. Even though these healthcare practitioners are highly trained to deal with issues of these kinds, their decisions can sometimes have a lasting impact on their professional and personal lives (Edwards 2009)....   [tags: Healthcare Industry]

Better Essays
1964 words (5.6 pages)

The Economics of End Stage Renal Disease: A Case Study Essay

- The purpose of this paper is to discuss healthcare financing in America, as it relates to a case study about End Stage Renal Disease (ESRD). I will discuss the major reimbursement mechanisms for ESRD. Additionally, I will provide the organization’s point of view about the economics of providing ESRD treatment. I will share options and potential trade-offs related to cost of treatment, quality of treatment, and access to treatment. Finally, I will discuss the ethical implications of resulting treatment options based on cost evaluation....   [tags: Healthcare]

Better Essays
998 words (2.9 pages)

Dred Scott V. Sandford Case Essay

- Roger B. Taney and John McLean: On Dred Scott v. Sandford case Slavery was pervasive in the South of the United States, where virtually all states in this territory relied on cash crop farming and as such used the slaves to perform manual work. The slaves were treated harshly and subjected to horrible conditions to provide sordid labor. On the advent of President Abraham Lincoln’s rule, various reforms began that ushered in the battle for slave freedom. The northern states were utterly averse to slavery while about ten southern states clung on and defended it on the basis of managing their economy....   [tags: American Civil War, Slavery in the United States]

Better Essays
1111 words (3.2 pages)

Questions On Fundamental Facts Of The Case Study Essay

- Introduction Many researchers, books, and articles have disclosed their opinions concerning to study methods. Following the prejudice of different persons, this paper will inform the reader about fundamental facts of the case study. The purpose is to dismantle any wrong idea stated through the years, and permit the researchers to freely do this method, which is convenient for some specific situations as following the next paragraphs. Facts About the Case Study Definition of the Case Study A case study is the report of a set of data obtained from working with a person or group of people....   [tags: Scientific method, Case study]

Better Essays
926 words (2.6 pages)

Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis Case Study Essay

- Case Study: A thirty six year old male has developed severe muscle weakness throughout the body. The condition began fifteen months ago with a left foot drop and within a year, he described difficulty with speech and swallowing, muscle twitching and cramping, and muscular atrophy throughout the upper and lower limbs. Within the last two months, his breathing has become more difficult, and there has been a noticeable difference in his voice. Prior to the fifteen months, he presented little to no symptoms....   [tags: Case Study]

Better Essays
1519 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on Apple & Foxconn Case Study

- Foxconn: Impact of globalization on labor conditions. Hon Hai Precision Industry Co., Ltd which trades as Foxconn Technology group or as the media calls it Foxconn has been in media limelight recently due to labor problems that have surfaced from the organization. Foxconn is a major equipment manufacturer supplier to electronics giants like Blackberry, Apple, Microsoft Xbox, Sony PlayStation and the Nintendo Wii. The internet has several articles and controversies regarding the deplorable worker conditions and cases of suicides by the workers....   [tags: Foxconn Case Study]

Better Essays
2511 words (7.2 pages)

Business School Ethical Dilemma Case Study Essays

- After reviewing the case study, Business School Ethical Dilemma, it was obvious that the Dean and other committee members responded positively to the ethical problem that related to the organizational ethics and certain employees. The Dean of an AASB accredited College of Business, Northern Kentucky University, was notified that research misconduct was occurring within the school (Carrell, 2007, p. 91). Once verbally notified, a written complaint was requested, and, eventually, a memo was sent in so documentation would be present....   [tags: Case Study]

Better Essays
961 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about Multiple Case Study Analysis

- Summary This is an education research paper that explores the qualitative research method known as Multiple Case Study Analysis. It will look at design, implementation, and analysis. It will further touch on what is meant by a case study in itself. Introduction As asserted by Stake (2006), “The multicase study is a special effort to examine something having lots of cases, parts, or members” (p. vi), which by the study of those parts, is able to then better understand the something as a whole, and the ways in which it functions across different scenarios....   [tags: Education, case study, definition, solution]

Better Essays
2110 words (6 pages)

Cisco Case Study Essay

- CASE QUESTIONS – CISCO 1a. How did Cisco find itself in trouble with regard to its intended IT prior to Brad Boston's arrival. Prior to his arrival, CISCO had a decentralized approach to IT spending. Independent business groups were making decisions in fuctional silos. Each group their own funds for IT, therefore, redundant applications such as CRM systems were created. This was a global issue as well as a localized issue. The Cisco philosophy regarding IT was simple: As long as someone was willing to pay for it, the IT department would work on whatever process/project specified....   [tags: Case Study Cisco Technology Question Answer]

Better Essays
992 words (2.8 pages)

Critical Thinking Case Study Essay example

- Critical Thinking Case Study Chris had just been promoted as an Executive Assistant for Pat the CEO, Chief Executive Officer, of Faith Community Hospital. Pat had given Chris her very first assignment on her first day of work as an executive assistant and that was to gather information so that Pat can present the issues to the board of directors....   [tags: Business, Case Study, solution]

Free Essays
1794 words (5.1 pages)