The Case of Valentine Shortis Essay

The Case of Valentine Shortis Essay

Length: 1401 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Before the eighteenth century it was very common for a guilty person to try to escape harsh punishment under the plea of impulsive insanity after committing a crime. However, by the early eighteenth century it was more difficult to prove that an individual was insane after committing a vicious crime. The case of Francis Valentine Shortis was one of such cases. His lawyers had a very difficult case on their hands and the only option they felt could help their client was to use the insanity defence. Their attempt was to persuade the twelve men jury that at the time of this dreadful crime, Shortis was in fact not mentally responsible and therefore suffering from a disease of the mind. There was an extensive amounts of evidence provided from the crown about Shortis’ mental capacity that pointed toward him being a sane man, challenging the very movement of the defence case. The crown had a reasonable amount of evidence presented by Shortis' coworkers, former friends and neighbours to support their argument that Shortis was not insane and in fact, acted very intelligently.
There are no doubts that Shortis did commit some very bad things during his childhood in Ireland that would make an individual assume that he must be insane. On the contrary, some of his former neighbours found Shortis to be an ordinary boy who was playful and very mischievous growing up. According to Friedland (1986), the crown (Macmaster) stated that “he committed many eccentric, rash and even reckless acts in Ireland, but he never was arrested there or confined in a Lunatic Asylum” (p.27). One of the psychiatrists Dr. Buck during the trial testify that he did not agreed with the other psychiatrists about Shortis’ state of mind at the time of the killing. He told...


... middle of paper ...


...gs which, if it existed, would justify or excuse his act” (Friedland, 1986, p.109).
Based on the evidence and testimonials presented in the case of Valentine Shortis, there is no mistake that Shortis is indeed a sane person who committed a brutal crime. Evidence presented by the crown indicated that Shortis was sane and did know that the act he committed was wrong. Shortis tried to cover up any evidence that he had shared with his friends about the killing and robbery at the mill. He also had spoken with Millie Anderson and her brother Jack about providing him with an alibi. This shows that Shortis knew it was wrong to commit such a crime and therefore, requested an alibi as a way to be excluded as a possible suspect. Consequently, according Canada’s criminal code Francis Valentine Shortis is not insane and therefore guilty of the brutal murder of his coworkers.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Price of Revenge in Sleepers and Valentine

- The Price of Revenge in Sleepers and Valentine Many people advocate the philosophy of "An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth," but few of them realize that to take revenge is often to sacrifice oneself and that the very purpose of law is to put an end to revenge. People are willing to sacrifice their freedom, their careers, and even their lives for revenge. Lorenzo Carcaterra's novel Sleepers, and Tom Savage's novel, Valentine, evidently express this. Although its true that it might take couple of years for criminals to get what they deserve, most of the time the law gets the job done....   [tags: Sleepers Valentine]

Free Essays
798 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on The Making Of Valentine's Day

- Valentine’s Day, also known as St Valentine’s Day, is recognized in most Christian lead countries around the world. The word valentine comes from ancient roman days. ‘Valens’, in Latin, means worthy. The Latin meaning of valentine is; Valentinus and represents several martyred saints of the time. There are many different legends and versions of the origin of Valentine’s Day. The most stated legend is that during 3rd Century Rome, Emperor Claudius II made it illegal for young men to marry. He felt young, single men were better soldiers....   [tags: Valentine's Day, history,]

Powerful Essays
500 words (1.4 pages)

The Death Of Saint Valentine Essay

- River established ways for them to live amid the humans undetected. His first and ultimate law was; they were to never draw attention to themselves, or show their true nature to the mortals. He had made it a law that as each found their Mate, they were to notify him. He accordingly made it law that on February 14th of every year they gathered together to celebrate the death of Saint Valentine consequently, allowing him the ability to account for everyone. As time went on River had all but given up as the other vampires found their mates, yet he and a handful of others had not....   [tags: Girl, Woman, Saint Valentine, The Little Girl]

Powerful Essays
2053 words (5.9 pages)

Challenging the Content of "Vegan Virgin Valentine" Essay

- Banned means to prohibit; to not allow someone to read it. It could be for many reasons, but most are for inappropriate topics for teens and kids. Most books are banned from libraries and schools. Vegan Virgin Valentine by Carolyn Mackler is one of the books that was challenged because of fowl language and references to sex and drugs. Mara, the main character, is a perfectionist. She has straight-As, is in National Honors Society, and is a future Yale student. She is competing with her only ex-boyfriend for the Valedictorian....   [tags: censorship, Vegan Virgin Valentine, public schools]

Powerful Essays
726 words (2.1 pages)

Dramatic Techniques in Shirley Valentine by Willy Russell Essay

- Dramatic Techniques in Shirley Valentine by Willy Russell How do the dramatic techniques use in the play help the audience to understand the importance of Shirley’s transformation. You should refer to the significance of the play’s social and historical (settings, attitudes to women SHIRLEY VALENTINE Task: How do the dramatic techniques use in the play help the audience to understand the importance of Shirley’s transformation. You should refer to the significance of the play’s social and historical (settings, attitudes to women, attitudes to marriage, expectations of life, etc) context and the literary context (kitchen-sink drama, comedy, tragedy, drama, etc)....   [tags: Shirley Valentine Willy Russell Essays]

Free Essays
3414 words (9.8 pages)

Willy Russell's Use of Devices to Invite the Audience to Sympathize with Shirley in the Screenplay Shirley Valentine

- Shirley Valentine, a story about a middle-aged house-wife whose life couldn’t be more mundane; she has no one but the wall to talk to. Shirley Valentine, written by Willy Russell, is one of his most famous screenplays. This essay will look at how Russell invites the audience to sympathise with Shirley through his use of language, ideas and themes, the effects of dramatic devices and characters in the play. Russell uses characters and their actions to invite us to feel sympathy for Shirley. The way she is treated by her family and especially Joe makes the readers feel compassion for her....   [tags: shirley valentine]

Powerful Essays
1891 words (5.4 pages)

The Celebration Of Valentine 's Day Essays

- Valentine’s Day is a holiday that has been celebrated by lovers for hundreds of years. The holiday, with its origins dating back to the 5th Century, was started as a day to celebrate Saint Valentine, a priest who was imprisoned for marrying Roman soldiers who were forbidden to wed. Modern celebrations of Valentine’s Day, however, have changed the focus to a more commercialized day, run by Hallmark. Typical ways of celebration include giving your partner gifts such as chocolates in heart shaped boxes, roses, jewelry, teddy bears, and greeting cards, and many would agree that there is not a holiday where one’s relationship status is as salient as on Valentine’s Day (Morse and Neuberg)....   [tags: Rape, Sexual intercourse, Human sexuality]

Powerful Essays
1988 words (5.7 pages)

A Comparison of Shakespeare's Sonnet 18 and Duffy's Valentine Essay

- A Comparison of Shakespeare's Sonnet 18 and Duffy's Valentine Shakespear's attitude towards his lover is she is superior to the summer and very beautiful " Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?" This show Shakespeare is thinking about comparing her to the summer but then he gives examples of how she is better than the summer. He says she is lovelier than the summer " Thou art more lovely and more temperate." He then goes on to say "Rough winds do shake the darling buds of May" this means that she is more like a darling bud of May than a rough wind that come in the summer....   [tags: Poems Shakespeare Sonnets Duffy Valentine ]

Powerful Essays
635 words (1.8 pages)

Saint Valentines Day Massacre Essay

- The 1920's were a time of Prohibition, Illegal Gambling, and Prostitution. The 18th amendment made the sale and distribution of alcohol illegal. Many people including Al Capone were involved in those illegal activities. Al Capone was notorious for this illegal activity. He got rich by manufacturing and distributing alcohol. He also owned many illegal bars. Many other gangs were doing the same illegal activity. There was competition over the alcohol. Every gang wanted it since that was how they made their money....   [tags: Al Capone St Valentine Massacre]

Free Essays
1185 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about St. Valentine's Day Massacre

- The 1920's was a decade marked with lawlessness. There was plenty of money to be made, and after the National Prohibition Act, everyone wanted a piece of the action. Two gangs went head to head for control of the lucrative illegal alcohol business. One group was led by George "Bugs" Moran, and the other, by Al "Scarface" Capone. Both sought to rule this business at the cost of the other. This confrontation climaxed on a chilly February morning in 1929. In an empty warehouse in Chicago, seven men were executed by a firing squad....   [tags: American History]

Free Essays
973 words (2.8 pages)