The Case Of Prosecutors Call Victimless Prosecutions Essay

The Case Of Prosecutors Call Victimless Prosecutions Essay

Length: 714 words (2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

This case presents a precedent of a recent practice that prosecutors call victimless prosecutions. The trademark of such cases is not that they lack a victim, but rather that they lack any in-court testimony from a victim. Prosecutors seek to prove the defendants’ guilt notably by means of out-of- court accusations; namely, reports people make right after alleged crimes to police or other personnel associated with law enforcement. The question this case presents is how Crawford applies to a victimless prosecution based essentially on statements reporting a crime to a 911 operator.
The Supreme Court appropriated its “primary purpose” test to determine whether McCottry’s statements made during the 911 call constituted testimonial statements for purposes of the Confrontation Clause (Breitenbach, 2008). Highlighting four primary bases, the Supreme Court distinguished the interrogation in Davis from that of Crawford; thereby, contrasting the nature of the statements made in each. The court determined that McCottry was not describing past events, rather immediate current events in a frantic tone which made it apparent that she was not in a safe environment. Ultimately, the court determined that McCottry’s intention was to enable assistance to law enforcement to meet with an on-going emergency; thus, her statements during the initial portion of the 911 call were, therefore, deemed to be nontestimonial: No ‘witness’ goes to court to proclaim an emergency and seek help” (Breitenbach,, 2008).
I am of the opinion that in addition to the 911 call, the text message and the photograph should admissible on the basis that although McCottry may not be present in body, she was there. I concede with the prosecutions argument:
And if you really, t...

... middle of paper ...

... efforts.
The hearsay rule and the Confrontation Clause were designed to protect separate values, and, although both doctrines require a similar factual analysis, each rule must be considered individually in order to ensure both evidentiary accuracy and constitutional protection against prosecutorial abuse (Breitenbach, 2008). Davis v. Washington improves upon Crawford by providing courts with objective means for determining whether or not a statement made out-of-court statement sparks the Confrontation Clause. It does so by moving the lower courts ' inquiry away from the subjective mental state of the declarant and toward an objective view of the circumstances in which the statement was made. This approach will provide courts with something close to a bright-line rule, which will tend to produce more consistent results across jurisdictions. (Breitenbach, 2008).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Managed Development of Call Centers Essay

- Under-scrutinized until the late 1990s, call centres have now got significant scholastic consideration. The astounding and managed development of call centres, stretching out far past their starting bases in the financial and telecommunications areas, has bewildered the early scepticism. The competitive advantage for the companies picked up through the combination of phone and VDU advances, giving immediate phone based client services and selling led to widespread of this phenomenon. The growing financial sector has given the UK government's modernising motivation, which expects to guarantee that, by 2002, 25% of its administrations are open electronically....   [tags: it work, telecommunications, call centres]

Better Essays
1383 words (4 pages)

Essay on Judicial Method in a Lawless Person Case

- ... At an primary appearance, a referee suggests the defendant of the allegations filed, considers if the defendant should be held in prison until trial, and works out if there is likely origin to accept as true that an infringement has been pledged and the defendant has pledged it. Defendants who are incapable to pay for counsel are advised of their right to a court-appointed advocate. The court may assign either a government public defender or a personal attorney who has acquiesced to accept such appointments from the court....   [tags: defendent, prosecutions, evidence, attorney]

Better Essays
711 words (2 pages)

Carol Stack’s Call to Home Essay

- Progress and individualism are very much celebrated in American culture. Many people migrate to urban cities in the search of economic prosperity and to achieve the elusive “American Dream.” City life can often come as a shock to individuals not accustomed to a fast-paced lifestyle; conversely it can change a person. Such change can transform a person to lose the values and beliefs they were raised with which consequently attribute to losing the bonds that they once held with their families. This is not the case with the families portrayed in Carol Stack’s ethnography Call to Home....   [tags: Call to Home Essay]

Better Essays
1441 words (4.1 pages)

What Are Victimless Crimes Essay

- A victimless crime is also known as a consensual crime and is really a crime against oneself. Generally, these crimes are labeled in such a way because there is no physical harm to a person or property “the only person being hurt is the person committing the crime themselves” (Schmallegar 2010, p.365). Victimless crimes are considered illegal, primarily because of statutory laws (Ward, 2003). These types of crimes typically involve willing participants and in most cases are violations by law. As a rule,” participants freely engage in the activities that are considered to be illegal or harmful” (Schmallegar 2010, p.365)....   [tags: Crime, Self Harm]

Better Essays
638 words (1.8 pages)

Essay on Public Prosecutions Must Be Held Responsible

- Now, to the layman, that appears simply to be a frame up – when you arrest and charge and find the evidence subsequently. To make matters worse, when we examine the manner in which that evidence was put forward by the prosecution (a matter for which the director of Public Prosecutions must be held responsible), we find some startling inconsistencies, strange and frightening things. Like one man giving three statements. – two of them before Arnold Rampersaud was arrested, never mentioning the accused or anything to do with the accused....   [tags: Jury, Judge, Court, Trial]

Better Essays
1163 words (3.3 pages)

Growth of Call Centers Essay examples

- In this paper of Taylor and Bain there is a discussion about the fast pace of growth the call industry is following in the late 1990’s. The astounding and oversaw advancement of call centres, extending far past their beginning bases in the monetary and telecommunications zones, has bewildered the early doubt. The point of interest for the organizations got through the consolidation of telephone and VDU developments, giving prompt telephone based customer administrations and offering prompted boundless of this sensation....   [tags: Taylor and Bain, Fast Pace Growth, Call Industry]

Better Essays
1434 words (4.1 pages)

Courtroom Procedures and the Role of the Prosecution Essay

- During a trial, there are many rules, procedures, and codes of conduct that must be observed. These are in place to allow a trial to proceed more efficiently and fairly for both the defense and prosecution. According to one author, “Police, prosecutors, and criminal court Judges see too much crime, so they tend to see crime everywhere. We need rules to control their conduct, Judges to carefully apply those rules, and other Judges to review those decisions (” Courtroom procedures are important because, without them, defendants and prosecution alike could be treated unfairly....   [tags: police, prosecutors, criminals]

Better Essays
922 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Provide Evidence in a Prosecution Case

- Provide Evidence in a Prosecution Case Experiments to Provide Evidence in a Prosecution Case with the Pervis Vinegar Company on Unknown Toxins The aim of this experiment is to preform tests on two samples of vinegar, one that is commercially safe and the other not (from the Pervis Company) to determine the unknown toxin contained in the Pervis Vinegar. Materials: * Numerous Beakers/Conical Flasks * Phenolphthalein Indicator * Burette * Numerous Test Tubes * Sticky Tape * Test Tube Rack * Sodium Hydroxide (NaOH) * Calculator * Sample of Commercially Safe Vinegar * 2 Surgical Swabs (large cotton bud) * Sample of Pervis Vinegar (Toxic) * 2 Agar Gel Plates * Universal Indicator...   [tags: science]

Free Essays
1002 words (2.9 pages)

Jack London's The Call of the Wild Essay

- Call of the Wild Where did man come from?   Scientists thought they had answered this simple yet complex question through Charles Darwin's theory of evolution.   According to him, living organisms evolved due to constant changing.   Organisms which gained an edge would reign, while those without would die.   Jack London's books during the late 1800's animated this theory through the use of wild animals in a struggle for survival.   In fact, many prove that to survive a species "must" have an edge.   In London's book the Call of the Wild, the harsh depiction of the Klondike wilderness proves that to survive life must adapt....   [tags: Call of the Wild Essays]

Free Essays
879 words (2.5 pages)

Call It Sleep by Henry Roth Essay

- Call It Sleep  by Henry Roth  The book Call It Sleep written by Henry Roth is a literary work that explores immigrant life as they adjust to the new and unfamiliar ways of American life.  The book is somewhat of a social commentary on the period of the Eastern European immigration to America at its peak.   The novel gives an inside view on how foreigners (primarily Jewish immigrants) fit into main stream society.   Throughout the course of the novel, you travel along with the main character David Schearl as he ages from six to eight and grows up in Brownsville on the lower East side of New York.  David is torn between the love of his over protective mother and the hatred of his angr...   [tags: Call it Sleep Essays]

Free Essays
1107 words (3.2 pages)