The Case Of Marvin Pickering Essay

The Case Of Marvin Pickering Essay

Length: 1447 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Marvin Pickering was a science high school teacher in Will County, Illinois. Pickering was dismissed from his job after he wrote a letter to the editor of the local paper, Lockport Harold. The letter was sarcastically criticizing the way his superintendent and school board raised and spent funds. The superintendent and school board took offense to the comments within the letter and dismissed Marvin Pickering from his teaching job.
The Will County School District asked voters in February 1961 to approve a bond to raise $4,875,000 to build two new schools. The bond proposal was not approved by voters. The school board brought another proposal to the voters in December of 1961. This time the amount rose to $5,500,000 to build the two new schools and it passed. Three years later, the school board asked to voters to approve a tax increase that would be used for educational purposes.
In May of 1964, the voters turned the proposal down. Five months later in September, the board asked the voters again to vote on a tax increase for educational purposes (“Marvin L.,” n.d.).
There were a variety of articles written and submitted to the local newspaper by District 205 Teachers’ Organization. The articles were urging voters to approve the tax increase of 1964. The articles emphasized there would be a decline in the educational process if the tax proposal did not pass. The superintendent of the Will County School District also ran a letter in the newspaper two days prior to the election. His letter was claiming there would be a decline in the educational process to if the proposal did not pass (“Marvin L.,” n.d.).
After the voters turned down the tax increase for a second time, Martin Pickering wrote his l...

... middle of paper ...

... opinion for the court. He states the court reopened a question in Garrison v. Louisiana (1964).
“The Court gratuitously suggests that when statements are found to be knowingly or recklessly false, it is an open question whether the First Amendment still protects them unless they are shown or can be presumed to have caused harm. Deliberate or reckless falsehoods serve no First Amendment ends and deserve no protection under that Amendment. The Court unequivocally recognized this in Garrison, where after reargument the Court said that ‘the knowingly false statement and false statement made with reckless disregard of the truth, do not enjoy constitutional protection.’ As I see it, a teacher may be fired without violation of the First Amendment for knowingly or recklessly making false statements regardless of their harmful impact on the schools” (“PICKERING,” 2015).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Case Of Marvin Williford Essay

- In 2000, Delwin Foxworth was beaten and set on fire outside of his North Chicago home. Foxworth survived the attack but died two years later in a nursing home. Marvin Williford was arrested and convicted for the murder in 2004 and was given an 80 year life sentence in prison. Williford’s defense attorney David Owens is requesting a retrial for the case because of the absence of Williford’s DNA profile in the DNA samples that were taken from the crime scene. Additionally Owens makes the argument that the eye witness testimony of a woman who was present during the attack was unreliable....   [tags: Eyewitness identification, Witness, Testimony]

Better Essays
718 words (2.1 pages)

Pickering & Chatto Essay

- Pickering & Chatto Every Romanticist is heavily indebted to Pickering & Chatto for their publication of a series of valuable sets of Romantic texts. From the Works of Mary Wollstonecraft (published in 1989), to the Novels and Selected Works of Mary Shelley (published in May 1996), and continuing with forthcoming editions of Hazlitt's and De Quincey's Selected Works, Pickering & Chatto continues to foster the study of Romantic writers with excellent scholarly editions. Under the general editorship of John Mullan, Pickering & Chatto offers us a new collection in their series of Romantic studies publications: Lives of the Great Romantic Poets ....   [tags: Pickering & Chatto]

Free Essays
1282 words (3.7 pages)

The Abominable Pig by Marvin Harris Essay

- The Abominable Pig by Marvin Harris Is it possible that the almighty God is wrong. The bible explicitly states, in no questionable terms that whatever is of the hoof and is cloven footed and chews the cud among animals, you may eat. Obviously, the pig has fallen short of the statement’s requirements, hence the reason why, Marvin Harris author of the article “The Abominable Pig,” has opted to explore the reasons why this is the case as his central argument. Harris does not seek to completely refute this theory; in fact, even though he pinpoints certain flaws in the biblical proclamation, he scrutinizes the reasons why God has chosen to isolate this particular animal, for it is no more a ca...   [tags: Abominable Pig Marvin Harris Essays]

Better Essays
622 words (1.8 pages)

Essay about Life Through The Eyes Of Marvin Gaye

- Life Through the Eyes of Marvin Gaye Throughout America’s history, people have been expressing their thoughts and feelings toward social injustices by violently acting against condescending authoritative figures, but not everyone chose to share their point of view this way. Marvin Gaye was an extremely influential individual during the late 1960’s to the early 1970’s, where he not only sang about his personal problems and past relationships, but also provided a voice for the people of his city who were being marginalized and scapegoated for things that were unreasonably implicated....   [tags: Marvin Gaye, Motown, What's Going On, Berry Gordy]

Better Essays
1879 words (5.4 pages)

Comparison between Hypatia and Marvin Gaye Essay examples

- Thank you. After reviewing the question, I saw that I failed to compare my week one person, which was Marvin Gaye to Hypatia. However there are few things I would consider in this comparison between Hypatia and Marvin Gaye as far as developmental processes are concerned. First the obvious one is that one Hypatia was a female scholar who grew up in a stable home and learned different skills from her father. I will also mention the fact that, she was born in the time female were not consider to be equal to man intellectually....   [tags: developmental processes]

Better Essays
547 words (1.6 pages)

Essay on John McPhee's In Search of Marvin Gardens

- John McPhee's In Search of Marvin Gardens Im his essay In Search of Marvin Gardens, John McPhee examines Atlantic City, New Jersey, the city upon which the board game of Monopoly was based. In his writing, he touches upon both the board game and the physical city equally which begs the reader to ponder the purpose of McPhee’s essay. Did he write his essay to provide for the reader the physical basis for the game of Monopoly. Or did McPhee wish to expose the once glamorous AtlanticCity as a city in its present near-squalor state....   [tags: Rhetorical Analysis]

Better Essays
1205 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on The Wedding Of Marvin And Emily

- There are many traditions that go into an American wedding. My family had the pleasure of attending the wedding of Marvin and Emily Murphy in October of this year. The bride Emily and my family have known each other for the past four years, we attend church together. In the American culture one of the most important traditions among women is the engagement. Woman are so interested in the love story behind the couple and how romantic the event is. Emily met her groom through a mutual friend. Marvin and Emily hit it off immediately....   [tags: Wedding, Marriage, Wedding reception]

Better Essays
1808 words (5.2 pages)

Essay about Tax Exemtion Case Analysis

- Article Analysis: Hospitals use tax exemption as a way for facing financial burdens. This allows hospitals to continue their operations by providing high quality care and providing free or discounted care to poor individuals. The implications for denying tax exemption can be financially detrimental to many non-for-profit hospitals and subsequently for many uninsured individuals who need access to care. Although I truly believe that there should be very strict regulations to rule tax exemptions for hospitals and healthcare organizations and I totally agree with the Supreme Court ruling in this case, I feel that this case is very controversial and leads to many fundamental arguments in regards...   [tags: Case Review ]

Better Essays
890 words (2.5 pages)

Marvin Bower - An Outstanding Leader Essay

- McKinsey & Company has a unique culture, and it makes a huge difference in the way we perform our job. Just briefly, our mission is: “to help leaders make distinctive, lasting and substantial improvements in performance and constantly build a great Firm that attracts, develops, excites and retain exceptional people”. And our values are: As professionals, we: 1) Put the client’s interest ahead of our own. We focus on making our clients successful, because our success is measured by theirs 2) Uphold absolute integrity 3) Tell the truth as we see it....   [tags: Business Analysis Culture]

Free Essays
1461 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on In Search of Marvin Gardens

- In Search of Marvin Gardens The televisionshow "Mr. Roger’s Neighborhood" takes place in two different locations,one is Mr. Rogers home, and the other is make-believe land where the talesMr. Roger’s teaches are acted out for children by puppets. To even theyoung children watching the show, it is obvious that the transition fromone place to another is helped along by parallel themes or events. Thepiece "In Search of Marvin Gardens" is obviously divided into two separatesections, one part takes place during a Monopoly game and the other isa more descriptive set of passages about Atlantic City....   [tags: McPhee Atlantic City Essays]

Better Essays
1015 words (2.9 pages)