Essay on The Case At The Memorial Medical Center

Essay on The Case At The Memorial Medical Center

Length: 1619 words (4.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

According to the information from Sheri Fink’s New York Times article, in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, the Memorial Medical Center was running low on resources with care administered by exhausted doctors and nurses. In the sustained process of waiting for help and evacuations, Anna Pou, Ewing Cook, and the other doctors at the Memorial Medical Center made the controversial decision to inject several patients with drugs, which, at extraordinary high doses, are known to lead to death. In this situation, the patients who were in question were those who doctors designated as very ill and had the lowest chance for survival. While we have examined many hypothetical thought experiments to delve deeper in the discussion of end-of-life ethics, the case at the Memorial Medical Center demonstrates a situation in which the right choices were not made. Instead, if informed consent was not given, the doctors should not inject those patients with lethal doses and instead should have provided care until help arrived or until the patient died of their condition.
First, I would argue that regardless of the stated intent, injecting patients with the high doses of drugs, like morphine and midazolam, is a form of killing, specifically considered involuntary euthanasia (Fink). Involuntary euthanasia means killing a person who did not want to die or were not asked to provide consent, even though they were able to provide consent, for the sake of reducing pain the suffering (Shogry). Essentially, involuntary euthanasia is killing against the patient’s will or without their knowledge. Doctors regularly use morphine and midazolam to make patients comfortable because these drugs are used for pain control and sedation for medical procedures (Fink). ...


... middle of paper ...


...low them to have a life and autonomy to choose not to die by the doctors’ needle.
To address what the doctors could have done differently, they could have cared for the patients normally and allowed the patients to live until help arrived or the patients died of preexisting conditions. If the patient does complain of pain and suffering, the doctors could have administered normal doses of morphine to solely alleviate pain and not to hasten death. As mentioned earlier, if resources were an issue, the patients could just have been left to fight for their own life because they did not have to die for the doctors to tend to other patients. In conclusion, the doctors at the Memorial Medical Center did not make the right decision to inject their patients with lethal doses of drugs, because their actions equated to involuntary euthanasia, and should be considered murder.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

CAM and the Medical Community Essay

- CAM and the Medical Community Alternative, complementary, and integrative healing are all part of a well debated but poorly researched area of medicine. Doctors of the conventional American and European medical communities have been long prone to dismiss unconventional healing methods such as acupuncture, herbal supplements, and massage therapy as ineffective, or outright crackpot methods of treating illness. The view of the medical community, however, seems to have little impact of the growing popularity of CAM (complementary and alternative medicine) among patients....   [tags: Medicine Medical Health Essays]

Free Essays
1283 words (3.7 pages)

Risk Management and Prevention at a Medical Facility Essay

- Risk Management Risk management is defined as a program directed toward identifying of, evaluating of, and taking corrective action against potential risks that could lead to injury of patients, staff, or visitors. It is a planned program of loss prevention and liability control, and its main purpose is to identify, analyze, and evaluate risks and then to develop a plan for reducing the frequency and severity of accidents and injuries (Decker and Sullivan, 2001). Risk management is a continuous daily program of detection, education, and intervention....   [tags: Medical Errors Safety Case Study Studies, solutio]

Strong Essays
1443 words (4.1 pages)

Business Case For Quality : Americans Should Receive The Medical Care Essay

- Business Case for Quality Americans should receive the medical care based on the most up-to-date evidence-based practice and best scientific technology, but there is strong evidence showing that health care industries have inertia implementing the needed changes to reach its potential benefits (Institute of Medicine, 2001). A discrepancy exists between the health care now receive and the health care that could receive. The reason for this gap is that medical science and technology are advanced at a rapid speed, and the current health care system falls short in dissimilating the knowledge and technology into clinical practice....   [tags: Medicine, Illness, Health care]

Strong Essays
761 words (2.2 pages)

Assisted Suicide As A Medical Practice Essay

- ... Forty-five dead bodies were discovered and when tested, the doctors found that a large portion of the deceased patients had a fatally high amount of morphine, versed, or a combination of the two in their bodies. Anna Pou, the doctor said to have been distributing the injections was put on trial for her actions. Her actions were considered unethical due to the fact that her patients were unaware that those would be their last moments. After her trial, she was charged with manslaughter, though she denied the claims made against her labeling her a murderer (“Playing God”)....   [tags: Death, Suicide, Assisted suicide, Euthanasia]

Strong Essays
1557 words (4.4 pages)

Applying Act Utilitarianism And The Incidents At Memorial Medical Center

- ... Babies, particularly those in the NICU, were evacuated first, followed by adult ICU patients depending on life support. The remaining patients were labeled numerically according to their condition, and their ability to handle evacuation. Patients marked as “1’s” were the healthiest and most likely to benefit from evacuation, those marked as “2’s” were slightly less well off, and all patients labeled as “3’s” were those deemed unresponsive and in critical condition. After five days of caring for patients, and moving them up many flights of stairs, to the helipad, with barely any sleep, the employees reached complete exhaustion....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Medical ethics, Physician]

Strong Essays
963 words (2.8 pages)

A Brief Note On The Memorial Medical Center Essay

- ... On top of that they also were supposed to have help from FEMA (Fink, Sheri, 2009).” The hospital had staff members including doctors, nurses responsible for taking care of patients, civilians taking shelter in the hospital and civilians who stayed behind to ride out the storm were the ones who helped carry out patients, or at least helped when they were able to. There were also “helicopters from the Coast Guard and private ambulance companies transporting patients out of the hospital, volunteer driving airboats, FEMA was also suppose to help evacuate the hospital (Fink, Sheri, 2009).” With plans being in place to handle this natural disaster, plans were not in place at the time to handle...   [tags: Hurricane Katrina, George W. Bush, Storm surge]

Strong Essays
766 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Case Study : Howard County General Hospital

- ... Still, over the years the hospital continues to expand and transition while less than six years later, we are expecting another adjusted in the subsequent three years due to the development expansion in the community, and we feel our need to grow as well. Community involvement, Where is the competitive doing and how well are they doing, could make it possible my organization to top what other organizations are doing and how we can take it to the next level and make it a better product for our organization....   [tags: Hospital, Patient, Johns Hopkins University]

Strong Essays
722 words (2.1 pages)

Community South Medical Center Essay

- Strategic planning is crucial for the success of all business endeavors. Analyzing currents trends in technology, consumer markets, competition, and the workforce can play a pivotal part in whether or not the organization can survive. Overtime, strategic planning strategies must be modified in order to compensate for changes in the industry. Goals and strategic planning often necessitate change to ensure that the organization is performing at peak level, while offering the most beneficial and quality services to consumers....   [tags: Case Study]

Strong Essays
1404 words (4 pages)

Essay about Three Medical Case Studies

- Introduction This module of study has focused on many aspects of human health, anatomy, and the disease process. It has included such topics as the human organ systems, the mechanism of disease and the resulting disruption of homeostasis, the integumentary system, and the musculoskeletal system. The following case studies explore how burn classification will affect treatment, how joint injuries can disrupt mobility, and last, how a sedentary lifestyle can contribute to a decline in a person’s health status....   [tags: Medical Case Studies]

Strong Essays
1253 words (3.6 pages)

Heritage Valley Medical Center Case Study Essay

- The purpose of this paper is to examine the Heritage Valley Medical Center case study. The paper will start off with a brief background of Heritage Valley, along with a summary of the major problems and issues faced there. Next, the author will explain the role that was chosen while addressing the challenges of Heritage Valley and their reasoning in doing so. The author will then identify the strengths and weaknesses of Heritage Valley and offer to select the best alternative and recommended solutions, which will be followed by a brief description of the evaluation plan that could be used to measure the effectiveness of the recommended solution....   [tags: Patient, Health care provider, Illness, Hospital]

Strong Essays
1029 words (2.9 pages)