Case Analysis : Prosecutor 's Duty Essay

Case Analysis : Prosecutor 's Duty Essay

Length: 1126 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Prosecutor’s duty is to seek justice, present the judge and jury with facts and sound legal arguments that result in the conviction of the guilty defendant and not conviction of the innocent as we have seen in many cases in the past. They have a duty also to disclose exculpatory evidence to the defense attorney (Burke, 2010. P. 2135). Prosecutors consist of the group of criminal justice professionals with no accountability for their professional action or deliberate inaction. They willfully manipulate facts and evidences in order to secure a conviction at all cost. They are driven, not by the desire to ensure justice, rather, they are fixated on winning by all means possible, to enhance their professional record of successes, measured by the number of cases they prosecuted that resulted in conviction. Schoenfeld (2005) thinks prosecutors’ “score-keeping mentality” or conviction psychology that compels them to win at all costs, is the reason for prosecutorial misconduct (Schoenfeld, 2005. P. 252). Morey, (2012) states, "prosecutorial misconduct stems from a 'win at all cost ' mentality underlying the desire to further a career, or a firm belief in the defendant 's guilt notwithstanding admissible evidence”. John (2005, p. 53) wrote, “While certainly the vast majority of prosecutors are ethical lawyers engaged in vital public service, the undeniable fact is that many innocent people have been wrongly convicted of crimes as a result of prosecutorial misconduct; prosecutors are rarely disciplined or criminally prosecuted for their misconduct”
One would think that criminal trials, having the potential to deprive a defendant of liberty and indeed in some jurisdictions, life, would necessitate a stringent process before conviction, id...

... middle of paper ...

...every phase of a criminal case, from the commencement of an investigation through the sentencing of a defendant after conviction. It is crystal clear that the supposed checks on prosecutorial misconduct fail to deter or punish misconduct or to protect the wrongfully accused. Empirical studies establish that prosecutorial misconduct is a significant factor leading to the wrongful conviction of many innocent people. According to Johns, (2005. P. 149), “Civil liability will provide a needed check on misconduct and a needed remedy to the victim; qualified immunity provides sufficient protection to the honest prosecutor while permitting the development of constitutional doctrine, the evolution of enforceable professional norms, and the implementation of needed remedies” Prosecutorial accountability holds the key to the enhancement of the criminal justice system integrity.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The On The Job Of The Prosecutor

- 1. The text lists three inherent contradictions in the job of the prosecutor: (a) Prosecutors have nearly limitless discretion in the most critical matters they must consider, yet they are held to very high ethical standards. One contradiction in the job of the prosecutor is that they have nearly limitless direction in critical matters; however, prosecutors’ are also held to a very high ethical standard. Prosecutors must screen cases to determine which ones need to be prosecuted; nevertheless, this is the source of controversy with most people....   [tags: Criminal law, Crime, Criminal justice, Jury]

Better Essays
986 words (2.8 pages)

George Orwell 's ' The Deer Prosecutor Said ' Essay

- “We understand Mr. Rabbit. Please take your time.” the deer prosecutor said. “Yes, well... what did Timothy Barren do to me. WELL, I 'll tell you what Timothy Barren did to me. Timothy Barren set up a snare trap right the path I used every day when I foraged for food. He covered it with leaves and handfuls of grass so I wouldn 't see it. And, when I was on my way to collect a few pieces of fresh lettuce for dinner from Timothy’s neighbor 's garden, I found my let caught up in it.” “What did you do then?” asked the deer....   [tags: Jury, Judge, Prosecutor, Court]

Better Essays
955 words (2.7 pages)

Duty to Protect vs Patient Confidentiality Essay

- On October 27th of 1969, after returning home from a summer in Brazil, University of California at Berkley student, Tatiana Tarasoff was repeatedly stabbed and killed by a fellow classmate, Prosenjit Poddar. As tragic as the crime itself was, more tragic was the fact that it could have been prevented. Poddar had developed an unhealthy obsession with Miss Tarasoff during the year leading up to her death. Her continuous rejection of his advances sent him spiraling into a deep depression. He was encouraged by friends to seek treatment at the University’s student health center....   [tags: Duty to Warn]

Better Essays
602 words (1.7 pages)

The Role of the Prosecutor Essays

- The Role of the Prosecutor All serious criminal cases require the participation of three individuals: the judge, counsel for the prosecution, and counsel for the accused. If any one of these are absent from the procedure, "the criminal justice system is incomplete" (Congress). The prosecutor stands at a critical stage in the criminal justice system as well as playing a critical role before, during and after the trial. They serve many functions throughout the criminal process. Some of which are investigating, plead bargains, questioning both jurors and witnesses, and being involved through the sentencing as well....   [tags: Law Legal]

Better Essays
895 words (2.6 pages)

The Role of the Prosecutor Essay

- In the American Criminal Justice System, there are four key attributes in the role of the prosecutor. There are discretion, resource dependence, sequential tasks, and filtering. The prosecutors are lawyers that are accountable for presenting criminal cases in trial. The United States Attorneys are pointed by state or government, and represent the federal government in courts. They prosecute all adults who commit felonies and juveniles who commit delinquent crimes. Conjointly, the prosecutors have further responsibilities, such as legal adviser of the country commissioners, the Board of Elections, and written admonition of the prosecutors....   [tags: Justice System ]

Better Essays
1509 words (4.3 pages)

The Enforcement Of State And Local Prosecutors Essays

- The coordination of state and local prosecutors and their use of discretion has also introduced disparities in sentencing patterns even across the federal venue when there has been a more localized or tactical response to a specific crime issue, especially when local jurisdictional concerns may be at odds with more national policy goals. Bibas (2005) examples how federal districts within border states may use the leverage afforded by selective federal prosecution to “fast-track” plea-negotiations for criminal offenses that involve immigration issues by offering significant reductions in other potential criminal charges in exchange for guilty pleas regarding immigration violation...   [tags: Criminal law, Crime, Prosecutor, Criminal justice]

Better Essays
1360 words (3.9 pages)

Duty of Care Analysis Essay

- Introduction: The purpose of this report is clarify what the Duty of Care Policy of Western Australia is and the contents of the policy. This analysis will be using the Duty of Care Policy on the Department of Education webpage as the reference guide. The Policy was written by the Department of Education for students in the state. It is used to define what is required relating to the duty of care between teachers and students. In this paper, issues that are covered in the policy will be discussed....   [tags: Education]

Better Essays
1528 words (4.4 pages)

Hbs Tivo Case Analyais Essay

- TiVo's problem rests in its inability to convince consumers to change their television consumption habits. Improper targeting and positioning have led to an ineffective product, price-point and promotion strategy that has stranded TiVo in the chasm between the early market and the early majority. TiVo is a truly discontinuous innovation, a product that requires consumers to dramatically change their past behavior with the promise of gaining equally dramatic new benefits. TiVo's main challenge is convincing the consumer to buy an expensive product in a new product category....   [tags: Business Case Study]

Free Essays
2172 words (6.2 pages)

Mcdonalds Case Analysis Essay

- CASE ANALYSIS McDonald’s, Inc. COMPANY NAME: McDonald’s, Inc. INDUSTRY: Food Service COMPANY WEBSITE: COMPANY BACKGROUND: As a company, McDonald’s was first introduced in Des Plaines, Illinois in 1955. This was the very first McDonald’s restaurant, which all started in San Bernardino, California in 1954 when Ray Kroc approached the McDonald brothers with a business proposition to start a new company. In 1965 McDonald’s went public and was later, in 1985 added to the Dow Jones Industrial Average....   [tags: Case Study SWOT Analysis McDonalds]

Free Essays
1425 words (4.1 pages)

McDonald's Case Analysis Essay

- McDonald's Case Analysis I.     Objectives McDonald's mission was to provide customers with quality food at a low price with a focus on the speed, service and cleanliness they received while patroning one of their restaurants. The case focuses on a specific segment of the McDonalds restaurant chain that was opened in 1996, McDonald?s India. This segment of the restaurant giant had a more specific mission/philosophy to fulfill and had developed a special menu for these Indian customers to take into account their culture and religion....   [tags: Mcdonalds business Case Analysis Essays]

Better Essays
1183 words (3.4 pages)