The Case Against Perfection by Michael Sandels Essay

The Case Against Perfection by Michael Sandels Essay

Length: 945 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Recent breakthroughs in the field of genetics and biotechnology have brought attention to the ethical issues surrounding human enhancement. While these breakthroughs have many positive aspects, such as the treatment and prevention of many debilitating diseases and extending human life expectancy well beyond its current limits, there are profound moral implications associated with the ability to manipulate our own nature. Michael Sandel’s “The Case Against Perfection” examines the ethical and moral issues associated with human enhancement while Nick Bostrom’s paper, “In Defense of Posthuman Dignity” compares the positions that transhumanists and bioconservatists take on the topic of human enhancement. The author’s opinions on the issue of human genetic enhancement stand in contrast to one another even though those opinions are based on very similar topics. The author’s views on human enhancement, the effect enhancement has on human nature, and the importance of dignity are the main issues discussed by Sandel and Bostrom and are the focus of this essay.
The author’s both have opposing views regarding the adoption of human enhancement. Sandel argues against human enhancement and believes that our genetic modification will result in the loss of humanities appreciation of natural giftedness. It is his belief that this “drive to mastery” will transform how humanity interprets humility, responsibility and solidarity. Sandel claims as humility gives way, our appreciation for our natural talents and abilities will be lost. Sandel argues that diminishing humility will result in an explosion of personal responsibility, placing the burden of achievement on us instead of human nature. Sandel believes that enhancement will lead to the loss of h...


... middle of paper ...


...pen manner that allows us to perceive the opportunities offered by human enhancement. I disagree with Sandel’s argument that genetic enhancement for its own sake is wrong but is permissible when used in medical context. I find it hypocritical of Sandel to argue against one form of genetic manipulation while favoring another. The subject of human enhancement is too pervasive and offers too many potential benefits to restrict its use. I believe that genetic manipulation and human enhancements are inevitable. I favor an open-minded and morally grounded approach to advances in genetic engineering, only then can we deal with the moral and social ramifications that stem from the conept of human enhancement.



Works Cited

Bostrom, N. (2005). In Defense of Posthuman Dignity. Bioethics, 19(3), 202-214.
Sandel, M. J. (2004, April). The Case Against Perfection. The Atlantic.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about The Case Against Perfection by Michael Sandel

- Michael Sandel is a distinguished political philosopher and a professor at Harvard University. Sandel is best known for his best known for his critique of John Rawls's A Theory of Justice. While he is an acclaimed professor if government, he has also delved deeply into the ethics of biotechnology. At Harvard, Sandel has taught a course called "Ethics, Biotechnology, and the Future of Human Nature" and from 2002 to 2005 he served on the President’s Council on Bioethics (Harvard University Department of Government, 2013)....   [tags: ethics, biotechnology, genetic engineering]

Better Essays
972 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on The Death of Humanity: A Response to Michael Levin’s Article,

- In his essay “The Case for Torture” Michael Levin makes the argument that although torture is often thought of as barbaric and a primitive way of information extraction in today’s modern world, it is however in actuality a viable means of preventing terrorist attacks and should be used as such. Levin acknowledges that using torture as a means of interrogation is probably unconstitutional however that the lives of millions should outweigh the constitutional morality of the issue. He goes on to state that although he does not condone the use of torture as a means of punishment he does however consider it a logical solution to drawing terrorist plots out....   [tags: The Case fir Torture, Michael Levin]

Better Essays
1266 words (3.6 pages)

Cons of Genetic Engineering: The Case Against Perfection by Michael J. Sandal

- Genetic engineering includes altering heredity structures of living organisms and food products to provide the substance with certain traits which may appeal more to one. Other desired characteristics with regards to the Human genome project scientists have had a breakthrough in science. Now scientists are able to create synthetic organs for transplants and prevent disease by manipulating genes. According to Grocery manufacturers of America 70% to 75% of processed foods contain genetically modified ingredients from plants....   [tags: organisms, ethics, cloning]

Better Essays
1417 words (4 pages)

The Case For Torture By Michael Levin Essay

- In his essay “The Case for Torture,” printed in The Norton Reader 13th Edition, Michael Levin argues that torture is justified and necessary under extreme circumstance. He believes that if a person accepts torture to be justified under extreme cases, then the person automatically accepts torture. Levin presents weak argument and he mostly relies on hypothetical scenarios. There is not concrete evidence that torture solves problems and stop crime but rather the contrary. Under international law, torture is illegal and all the United Nation members have to abide by those rules....   [tags: Human rights, United Nations]

Better Essays
794 words (2.3 pages)

Essay about The Case For Torture, by Michael Levin

- In “The Case For Torture” an article written by Michael Levin, he attempts to justify the use of torture as a means of saving lives. Throughout the article, Levin gives the reader many hypothetical examples in which he believes torture is the only method of resolution. Though I agree with Levin, to some degree, his essay relies heavily on the fears of people and exploits them to convince people into thinking pain is the only way. In certain aspects, I could agree entirely with Levin, but when one reads deeper into the article, many fallacies become apparent....   [tags: Article Analysis ]

Better Essays
1173 words (3.4 pages)

The Case For Torture By Michael Levin Essay

- Torturing is a Psychological Behavior “The Case for Torture” by Michael Levin introduces the topic of torture as an acceptable measure for preventing future evil. According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, torture is the act or practice of inflicting severe pain on someone as a punishment that forces them to do or say something, or for the pleasure of the person inflicting the pain. Victims may be tortured for various reasons, such as for the tormentor’s own pleasure, a motive for revenge, or the need to obtain answers....   [tags: Stanford prison experiment, Milgram experiment]

Better Essays
1482 words (4.2 pages)

The Case Of Michael Hugh Mirsky Essay

- Appelbaum’s article primarily focuses on the case of Michael Hugh Mirsky, who tells his personal story which highlights the struggle many men in America face. In 2012, Mr. Mirsky initially had lost his job working at Verizon which snowballed two years later into a conviction for resisting arrest. Due to the conviction, work is hard to find and this led to the threat of foreclosure of his home. Mr. Mirsky is unable to afford child support payments for his 8-year-old daughter. The search for a permanent position is near impossible, Mirsky says, “even your lower-paying fast-food jobs are now doing background check......   [tags: Criminal law, Arrest, Crime, Employment]

Better Essays
1280 words (3.7 pages)

Michael Levin's The Case for Torture Essay

- In “The Case for Torture,” Michael Levin presents logical fallacies that originate at the authors desire to relate the importance of his message. Though his specific argument is a very plausible solution to a taboo problem, the manner in which he presents it has some fallacies that cause it to be unsupported Levin argues that torture should be used on terrorist in order to save people from terrorism. He further implies that this is the morally correct thing to do, because it ensures the good of the people....   [tags: Torture, Terrorism, Analysis, Fallacies]

Better Essays
981 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Michael Jackson : A Star Of Stars

- Michael Jackson – A Star among Stars Music lives and makes us happy. His contribution as a musician brought us some of the most exciting times in the history of music industry. He was a cultural icon, a star whose career spanned for four decades and a man who was always surrounded by controversy. He inspired many artists, changed the way people see pop music and built a dynasty that will last for many years. His name was Michael Jackson. Michael was born on August 29, 1958 in Garry Indiana. He was raised by his parents along with 8 other siblings who lived in a two bedroom house....   [tags: Michael Jackson, The Jackson 5, Janet Jackson]

Better Essays
1250 words (3.6 pages)

Case Against Conrad Murray Essay

- Month’s after the death of Jackson, fans began to create uproar against Murray and surprised investigators. August 2009, LA police investigators, Houston officials and DEA agent’s raided Murray’s practice for forensic evidence and collect medical instruments. The raid was executed in order to help build a case against Conrad Murray. Investigators and the coroner’s office for LA found that Jackson died because of the propofol. Around this time, speculations were made that Murray would be charged with manslaughter....   [tags: death, manslaughter, guilty, addiction, drug]

Better Essays
872 words (2.5 pages)